From a Jupiter-like gas giant type exoplanet, which generate radio emissions through entirely natural processes just like the gas giants in our own solar system. The title is a tad more spectacular than the actual discovery.
Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected
11–20 of 86 posts
Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected
#12From a Jupiter-like gas giant type exoplanet, which generate radio emissions through entirely natural processes just like the gas giants in our own solar system. The title is a tad more spectacular than the actual discovery.
This comment left me wondering: What's the astronomy equivalent of “in mice”?
Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected
#13Is “signal” the correct word to use for naturally occurring radio bursts? I thought that word implied radio waves used to convey meaning.
Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected
#14How likely is it for another civilization to follow the same path? Some of our breakthrough scientific advances happened by accident. What are the odds that we missed some big new technologies because we haven't happened upon the accident yet, even though it was right here all the time?
Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected
#15From a Jupiter-like gas giant type exoplanet, which generate radio emissions through entirely natural processes just like the gas giants in our own solar system. The title is a tad more spectacular than the actual discovery.
I guess significance here is that if we can isolate radio signals from naturally-emitting planet, we potentially can isolate radio signals from artificially-emitting planet.
[1] https://www.space.com/26419-jupiter-radio-waves-alien-life.h...
Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected
#16From a Jupiter-like gas giant type exoplanet, which generate radio emissions through entirely natural processes just like the gas giants in our own solar system. The title is a tad more spectacular than the actual discovery.
Very awkward spot for the science PR people writing this. It’s almost like it needs extra words to prevent people from adding
“Possible (But Definitely Non-Alien) Radio Emission From Exoplanet (Which Cannot Support Life) Detected”
Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected
#17Is “signal” the correct word to use for naturally occurring radio bursts? I thought that word implied radio waves used to convey meaning.
Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected
#18From a Jupiter-like gas giant type exoplanet, which generate radio emissions through entirely natural processes just like the gas giants in our own solar system. The title is a tad more spectacular than the actual discovery.
The title is in an odd spot where, on the face, it is completely anodyne, and not at all misleading or “clickbait.” Yet even sensible readers (like me!) see “radio” and “exoplanet” in the same sentence and think “ALIENS!” Very awkward spot for the science PR people writing this. It’s almost like it needs extra words to prevent people from adding “Possible (But Definitely Non-Alien) Radio Emission From Exoplanet (Whic…
Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected
#19So, different to the signals from Proxima Centauri?
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/dec/18/scientists-l...
Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected
#20It seems that we expect an alien civilization, if it exists, to follow a similar discovery path as we did. As such we listen for radio signals as a way of communication, because that's what we are doing. How likely is it for another civilization to follow the same path? Some of our breakthrough scientific advances happened by accident. What are the odds that we missed some big new technologies because we haven't happ…