Live data from Hacker News

Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

freedom.press

11–20 of 527 posts

Re: Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

#11
post #9

In some protests, when things get violent, is it easy to spot a journalist or do they just look like other protestors? honest question.

Usually they're pretty easy to spot by the microphone they carry, the docile behavior, sometimes an official nametag/badge/card, and the loudly announced "I'm a journalist"

But the police have even been arresting people who show all those signs

Re: Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

#12
post #7

What's their definition of journalist here? Journalists, at these protests, that were arrested? In other words, how many twitter followers do I need before I can identify as a journalist?!

Let's not pretend that it just happened to smaller-audience journalists. There's videos of CNN reporters being arrested while on air.

Re: Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

#13
post #7

What's their definition of journalist here? Journalists, at these protests, that were arrested? In other words, how many twitter followers do I need before I can identify as a journalist?!

From their FAQ:

Why doesn't the site include data from before 2017? We do not feel that data collected retroactively would meet our rigorous research standards. We believe that data collected before we established a tracking system, methodology, and outreach is likely to be less comprehensive and therefore likely to underestimate the number of incidents before 2017.

So it's a record number of journalists arrested since... 2017?!

And finally, the definition of journalist:

Who does the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker count as a journalist? The U.S. Press Freedom Tracker adopts a functional definition of who is a journalist. It doesn’t matter whether the individual has a press pass or went to journalism school, whether they work for The New York Times or work for themselves. What matters is whether the person was performing an act of journalism. The Tracker will count journalists whose rights to gather and disseminate information were violated in the course of their work or as a result of their work.

In the case of border stops, the resistance of U.S. authorities to provide information makes it extremely difficult to identify whether a journalist has been stopped because of their work. So although it is possible that some journalists may be stopped for other reasons, we will report cases of all journalists who are stopped at the border and questioned for a certain amount of time.

A journalist who attends a protest in order to protest publicly, rather than to document the protest, and is arrested or attacked in that capacity will not be counted on the site. While we recognize the importance and the rights of the private citizen who snaps a photo or video of an arrest, this site will only cover individuals who self-identify as journalists and have some track record of journalistic work.

In summary: this is a meaningless article.

Re: Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

#14
post #2

> The vast majority of these arrests occurred while journalists were documenting the historic, nationwide protests over the police killing of George Floyd and in support of Black Lives Matter. So basically, it's not a coincidence - police are more likely to arrest journalists that are attending anti-police protests. And it's sort of understandable. Imagine you are a police officer called to go to a protest where ever…

Was anyone suggesting it was a coincidence? It makes sense more journalists were arrested, but it's still notable.

It’s also not like they have press cards in their hat or some press pass lanyard. They look like everyone else and are probably recording/photographing like everyone else. An arrest by itself doesn’t mean much in this context. But I assume they are released once they can be proven to be a journalist and no charges are brought.

Re: Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

#15
post #9

In some protests, when things get violent, is it easy to spot a journalist or do they just look like other protestors? honest question.

Many are clearly journalists, e.g. Omar Jimenez, the CNN reporter who was arrested on live TV along with his camera crew: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ftLzQefpBvM

Re: Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

#16
post #2

> The vast majority of these arrests occurred while journalists were documenting the historic, nationwide protests over the police killing of George Floyd and in support of Black Lives Matter. So basically, it's not a coincidence - police are more likely to arrest journalists that are attending anti-police protests. And it's sort of understandable. Imagine you are a police officer called to go to a protest where ever…

Was anyone suggesting it was a coincidence? It makes sense more journalists were arrested, but it's still notable.

Well I went into the article (based on the title) thinking police all over the nation were randomly deciding to arrest journalists more often. But this makes it clear that no, it's only journalists at anti-police protests getting arrested at elevated rates. This article could very well have been titled "Record Breaking Number of Anti-Police Protests in U.S. This Year"

Re: Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

#17
post #9

In some protests, when things get violent, is it easy to spot a journalist or do they just look like other protestors? honest question.

journalists and other reporting figures usually have a lanyard saying "Press" I believe? totally anecdotal, but I've seen more than few instances of police brutalizing press members like other protesters unfortunately. I think such press members are easily identifiable, the police just don't care

Re: Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

#18
One line from the report jumped out at me as I was skimming it:

> About half the journalists here are freelancers, who may lack the institutional support of a newsroom and the financial resources for a potentially expensive legal defense.

I hadn't really thought of the value of legal defense from journalism institutions (as opposed to non-institutional platforms like Substack) before.

Re: Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

#19
post #7

What's their definition of journalist here? Journalists, at these protests, that were arrested? In other words, how many twitter followers do I need before I can identify as a journalist?!

Don't know about their definition for this article, but the US Constitution doesn't define credentials required to exercise freedom of the press. Everyone in America gets that right. Literally anyone can be a journalist by acting as one, even if they don't have an audience.

Re: Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year

#20
post #9

In some protests, when things get violent, is it easy to spot a journalist or do they just look like other protestors? honest question.

It is conventional in non-oppressive societies for police to only arrest the people who are actually being violent or destroying property.

Police arresting people at protests who aren't being violent, including journalists, merely for being in proximity to those who are violent or for sharing similar political objectives is a warning sign that a society is becoming oppressive.

Post reply on HN