Live data from Hacker News

SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first suborbital flight

wired.com

101–110 of 222 posts

Re: SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first suborbital flight

#101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's clickbait because it implies test failure, which isn't true. The test was successful, as the primary objectives were all met.

"Nearly lands" means crash anyway so any implication of the latter is still there.

Fair point. I suppose I find that the positive language is more harmonious with the actual test outcome, which was a success.

Re: SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first suborbital flight

#102

I make efforts to add to discussions instead of subtracting with negativity. Recently, I've broken my rule quite a few times, fretting over the future of general compute. I'd vowed to not break it again, but the discussion about Starship lacks a vital perspective. . I don't understand the hype behind Starship. It's confusing to me. It is touching and nice; it's great to see people excited about space. However, the ex…

https://craft.co/spacex/funding-rounds

SpaceX is funded a lot more than by just NASA.

Re: SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first suborbital flight

#103
post #11

i know they got the data they needed/wanted but can you really call it a success with that ending? on a side note: how much money do they lose whenever they have a crash landing like that?

Listen to one of the engineers who designed part of the rocket. https://twitter.com/PBearATX/status/1336847380499468289

Re: SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first suborbital flight

#104
post #6
post #2

HN: "SpaceX Launches and Nearly Lands Starship on Its First Suborbital Flight" vs Article: "SpaceX Launches—and Crashes—Its Starship Mars Rocket"

For whatever reason, Wired preferred the clickbait title, but the opening sentence of the article is: "On Wednesday afternoon, SpaceX successfully launched—and nearly landed—a fully-assembled prototype of its next generation Starship rocket on a suborbital flight from its facility in south Texas."

Headlines are usually written by an editor, not the writer, and chosen to generate clicks. That’s why there’s often such a contrast between the headline and the article.

Re: SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first suborbital flight

#105
post #87
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ms Shotwell is no man.

The fact that SpaceX's President and COO is a woman seems to get surprisingly little publicity, especially given that she seems like the more qualified engineer out of Musk and herself as well.

I thought gender wasn’t supposed to matter. She’s the best for the job; sexist to dwell on “she’s a she”.

Re: SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first suborbital flight

#106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

RUD is very much a euphemism that has I guess drifted a bit from it's initialism; I'm pretty sure in this case the disassembly was planned and the survival case would have been unplanned.

I take your point, but they're not planning for a launch failure even if they're pretty sure that's what's going to happen. What happened when most of the mass of a Space Shuttle launch hits the ocean: that's an RPD.

If you’re not planning for failure modes you’re not engineering correctly.

Re: SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first suborbital flight

#108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For those who don't want to click the tweet: > Fuel header tank pressure was low during landing burn, causing touchdown velocity to be high & RUD, but we got all the data we needed! Congrats SpaceX team hell yeah!!

> RUD “Rapid Unplanned Disassembly”? I love reading Musk’s tweets :)

I like reading Musk's tweets when he talks about something he knows (e.g. engineering). I don't much like them when they're ignorant and irresponsible commentary on Covid-19 (something he knows less about than even most ordinary but interested people, seeing as he wouldn't have the time to follow much expert commentary), or when he's sharing his puerile taste in humour or music or literature etc (although, to be fair, it's his personal account so he can share what he likes).

Re: SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first suborbital flight

#109
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The fact that SpaceX's President and COO is a woman seems to get surprisingly little publicity, especially given that she seems like the more qualified engineer out of Musk and herself as well.

I thought gender wasn’t supposed to matter. She’s the best for the job; sexist to dwell on “she’s a she”.

Given how many cultural biases exist that inform young girls that their value is directly proportional to their beauty, it's helpful to draw attention to women who are successful for other reasons.

Re: SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first suborbital flight

#110
post #12
post #3

I remember watching the Tesla going into space and the rockets landing on the platform. I remember thinking "Wow this man has restarted the space race for my generation." It was a hopeful and wonderful feeling, I figured with the budget cuts, the politics, and the general "been there done that" attitude that was prominent for much of my life space was closed. To see it opened again, gives me some sort of hope, some i…

As a young person (21), I feel the same way. Space exploration and a beautiful future suddenly seems achievable with hard work and a lot of engineering instead of just feeling impossible.

At your age, I had a similar feeling as the pictures from Spirit and Opportunity started rolling in. Quit my cushy but relatively dead-end web dev job, and went back to school. Busted my ass, got the grades, and found a love for math, but eventually found my way back to high tech. It's not what I set out to do, but absolutely worth the effort.

An amazing future is within your grasp. It might not be what you're picturing, but an education in math, physics, engineering, mechatronics, whatever... will open doors to a brilliant future. Go get em!

Post reply on HN