Live data from Hacker News

Philip Glass: My problem is people don’t believe I write symphonies (2017)

theguardian.com

31–40 of 185 posts

Re: Philip Glass: My problem is people don’t believe I write symphonies (2017)

#31

I saw Glass at a performing arts center in my hometown. The PAC has a lot of season ticket holders, and Glass' music triggered an older attendee to march to the front of the auditorium and yell, "this isn't music". He was quickly ushered out by his wife, but Glass was noticeably smirking, and the whole thing really added to the avant garde vibe of the performance. Amazing concert BTW. One of my favorite artists.

I wonder if there is any chance that's stagepersonship.

Paid actor.

Re: Philip Glass: My problem is people don’t believe I write symphonies (2017)

#32

I miss the documentary about Glass that used to be available on streaming. It's one of the few discs I plan to actually buy. I don't understand the business model of small films that withdraw from streaming completely, especially documentaries. Surely that can't be more profitable? I think about this question a lot while going through the dreck on Netflix and Amazon Prime. I think about all that work and knowledge an…

Why do you assume it's the owners of the small films that withdraw, and not the streaming services that drop them in order to redeploy funds to other content?

Re: Philip Glass: My problem is people don’t believe I write symphonies (2017)

#33

I saw Glass at a performing arts center in my hometown. The PAC has a lot of season ticket holders, and Glass' music triggered an older attendee to march to the front of the auditorium and yell, "this isn't music". He was quickly ushered out by his wife, but Glass was noticeably smirking, and the whole thing really added to the avant garde vibe of the performance. Amazing concert BTW. One of my favorite artists.

The label "avant-garde" is surprising to see used to describe Philip Glass's works. What performance were you attending?

Re: Philip Glass: My problem is people don’t believe I write symphonies (2017)

#36
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm very interested in what minimalist tropes you would say Berio and Feldman explored in any of their work.

Feldman's second string quartet ( https://youtu.be/QPMUHVza-KA ) is very long, has lots of repetition, with occasional pulsating rhythms/drone notes. I quite like it when I'm in the mood. There's a lot in it, but it's so slowly developed so slowly moment to moment it has characteristics of minimalism. This short article covers some of his work including the second quartet from this perspective in slightly more detail…

Well sure, most of Feldman's work could be described as "minimal" but saying it is part of the body of work that is typically referred to as "minimalism" is a little disingenuous, in my mind.

But maybe it just makes it more obvious that these categories aren't particularly useful. I think it's interesting to talk about those early works in the 70s and compare them to minimalist art, like Judd's or Serra's sculptures or paintings by Sol Lewitt, Stella, etc., but it's just a component of a much broader conversation that needs to be based in listening first.

It's interesting to me that Glass' early music didn't really click for me until I had stood inside of one of Richard Serra's Bands sculptures at LACMA. It gave me a different mental (and metal, haha) framework to engage with the music through. That's probably why the Berio/Feldman comparison was so surprising to me in the first place, because I feel like the music from those composers both demand different kinds of engagement to find them enjoyable that Glass' early music, both as a listener and a performer.

Re: Philip Glass: My problem is people don’t believe I write symphonies (2017)

#38

I saw Glass at a performing arts center in my hometown. The PAC has a lot of season ticket holders, and Glass' music triggered an older attendee to march to the front of the auditorium and yell, "this isn't music". He was quickly ushered out by his wife, but Glass was noticeably smirking, and the whole thing really added to the avant garde vibe of the performance. Amazing concert BTW. One of my favorite artists.

I wonder if there is any chance that's stagepersonship.

I think I trust Phillip Glass a bit more than that.

Re: Philip Glass: My problem is people don’t believe I write symphonies (2017)

#39
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Criticizing the work is one thing. Trying to bully people for finding beauty where you can't is kinda childish.

Many people do not realize that they do not "listen" to music. They simply put it on for background ambiance, to do other things. And before anyone feels further offended, please see this [0] post from 30 minutes ago on HN that completely proves my point made in the previous post. > I think to this day its great background music for programming work Philip Glass wrote his music to be heard in the concert hall. Very f…

I did recently (in the before times) watch a simulcast of Akhnaten at a local theater, which I quite enjoyed. Does that count?

Re: Philip Glass: My problem is people don’t believe I write symphonies (2017)

#40

I saw Glass at a performing arts center in my hometown. The PAC has a lot of season ticket holders, and Glass' music triggered an older attendee to march to the front of the auditorium and yell, "this isn't music". He was quickly ushered out by his wife, but Glass was noticeably smirking, and the whole thing really added to the avant garde vibe of the performance. Amazing concert BTW. One of my favorite artists.

The label "avant-garde" is surprising to see used to describe Philip Glass's works. What performance were you attending?

Philip Glass is constantly described as avant-garde. You may take issue with that label, but I hardly see how it can be surprising.
Post reply on HN