Live data from Hacker News

Google Music Service

music.google.com

1–10 of 92 posts

Re: Google Music Service

#3
We're sorry. Music Beta is currently only available in the United States

It bothers me when this happens... I end giving up to find proxies or other ways to reach the site.

Re: Google Music Service

#8
post #3

We're sorry. Music Beta is currently only available in the United States It bothers me when this happens... I end giving up to find proxies or other ways to reach the site.

Same here. This happen so often that I might consider renting a VPS in the US to use it as a proxy. I found some at $5/mo with 250GB/mo for bandwidth, I even think it's enough to share and pay only $2.5/mo...

Re: Google Music Service

#9
I would have thought Google had learned their lesson about doing limited roll-outs: that artificially limiting the network effect kills your product. What worked for GMail hasn't worked anywhere else.

Re: Google Music Service

#10
From the screenshot, it looks even less useful than Amazon's player.

You have to upload all of your own music yourself, which would take forever for anyone who has a collection big enough that they can't carry on their phone or ipod. Also, there is absolutely no conceivable benefit to musicians. At least amazon allows you to easily buy albums.

There doesn't appear to be any useful additional functionality either. Social interaction, concert ticket listings, artist info, last.fm tag data, lyrics and all the other things I'd want from a google music service don't look like they're going to be available.

Post reply on HN