Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Boltstream – Self-hosted full end-to-end live video streaming platform

github.com

11–20 of 101 posts

Re: Show HN: Boltstream – Self-hosted full end-to-end live video streaming platform

#11
post #6

It's a chicken and egg problem where there is not much point in building your own whizbang streaming platform and have no one come to it. Twitch is getting increasingly ad-nnoying and you can _ad_ barely _ad_ watch _ad_ it _ad_ an _ad_ ymore. That said that's still where you get the viewers and that's what people will pick. The ad-revenue sharing being the carrot here which will probably mean it's going to be success…

I run an adblocker but I'm sympathetic to Twitch's plight here.

Or at least I was until they started interrupting streams in the middle of the action with no human input to show ads.

When the broadcaster clicks the ad button, it's a good time to run ads. They're probably taking a break anyway, there's nothing critical or even interesting happening, so watching some ads is fine.

But randomly interrupting in the middle of a conversation or right as the good part hits to show an ad shows that the Twitch management no longer understands or gives a shit about their platform.

Re: Show HN: Boltstream – Self-hosted full end-to-end live video streaming platform

#12
post #6

It's a chicken and egg problem where there is not much point in building your own whizbang streaming platform and have no one come to it. Twitch is getting increasingly ad-nnoying and you can _ad_ barely _ad_ watch _ad_ it _ad_ an _ad_ ymore. That said that's still where you get the viewers and that's what people will pick. The ad-revenue sharing being the carrot here which will probably mean it's going to be success…

I run an adblocker but I'm sympathetic to Twitch's plight here. Or at least I was until they started interrupting streams in the middle of the action with no human input to show ads. When the broadcaster clicks the ad button, it's a good time to run ads. They're probably taking a break anyway, there's nothing critical or even interesting happening, so watching some ads is fine. But randomly interrupting in the middle…

They probably found that people streaming were not clicking the button often enough.

Re: Show HN: Boltstream – Self-hosted full end-to-end live video streaming platform

#14

Have you performed any load testing or measured performance and scalability?

Wouldn't it be mostly IO bound? A 10 Mbit/s stream would equal to 100 viewers on a 1Gbit connection, which you can probably handle with even a 1-2 core VPS. The primary consideration would be your transit/server provider and how well peered they are in relation to your viewers.

Re: Show HN: Boltstream – Self-hosted full end-to-end live video streaming platform

#15

Peertube is getting live streaming capability.... actually you can check it right now on https://live.canard.tube/videos/watch/5e7b916e-c5b5-4996-a97... The p2p part of it is the real nice deal and these guys are actually making something good here.

Yea, I'm looking forward to that feature. If they can implement that with a peer to peer stream that would be great.

Re: Show HN: Boltstream – Self-hosted full end-to-end live video streaming platform

#16
How secure do you think Twitch (Amazon), Facebook Gaming (Facebook), and Youtube Live (Google) are at the top of the streaming world? We’ve recently seen Mixer (Microsoft) fall, and it feels like the creators are the only thing keeping these platforms great, so what’s stopping a new streaming platform from rising above all the others other than the creator’s fear of losing stability? Why couldn’t a new streaming service with a great user acquisition strategy fully take over? This industry doesn’t feel stable at the moment, but when has the video content industry been stable.

Re: Show HN: Boltstream – Self-hosted full end-to-end live video streaming platform

#17
post #14

Have you performed any load testing or measured performance and scalability?

Wouldn't it be mostly IO bound? A 10 Mbit/s stream would equal to 100 viewers on a 1Gbit connection, which you can probably handle with even a 1-2 core VPS. The primary consideration would be your transit/server provider and how well peered they are in relation to your viewers.

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Boltstream – Self-hosted full end-to-end live video streaming platform

#18
Maybe I can latch on to this thread to ask a question — has anybody here had any experience with publishing streams from the browser directly, rather than using something like OBS?

Current thinking is I could use the MediaRecorder API to capture browser content and then push it to a server for broadcast with a tool like Boltstream. But, I’ve heard some people say it’s a bad idea to try this, and to stick with non-browser options.

Re: Show HN: Boltstream – Self-hosted full end-to-end live video streaming platform

#19

Maybe I can latch on to this thread to ask a question — has anybody here had any experience with publishing streams from the browser directly, rather than using something like OBS? Current thinking is I could use the MediaRecorder API to capture browser content and then push it to a server for broadcast with a tool like Boltstream. But, I’ve heard some people say it’s a bad idea to try this, and to stick with non-bro…

Streamyard does this, works pretty well but less customization available right now.
Post reply on HN