Live data from Hacker News

Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

thehill.com

51–60 of 77 posts

Re: Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

#51

Are they talking about spreading it through breathing, or through touching?

Turns out that catching COVID by touching surfaces is pretty low in the first place:

> The estimated risk of infection from touching a contaminated surface was low (less than 5 in 10,000)

https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.10.27.20220905v...

Re: Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

#52

I hate to be that person, but I'm personally more worried about the virus mutating under the increased selection pressure. We only defeated polio with a >99% effective vaccine, and the research for this vaccine isn't even available.

Unlike older vaccines (such as polio vaccine) which generally used weakened or killed whole virus particles (and which occasionally produced infectious cases, due to the virus not being as weak or dead as intended), this vaccine contains no whole virus particles and thus cannot result in an infectious case. It contains RNA that cause the patient's cells to emit proteins normally produced by the viral infection (which…

There is absolutely 0% chance I'll be letting that anywhere near my family. And I was a biomedical scientist formerly.

Over my dead body (one way or another).

Re: Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's a clever little meme floating about showing a perfectly normal, happy, healthy, unmasked family with the caption "conspiracy theorists" and then in the adjacent panel a visibly paranoid person with a mask and face shield captioned "normal person". Cheap, but clever.

Uh, this is probably a cultural thing, but I don't get it? Can you please explain it to me? As in, what's "cheap but clever" about it?

The stereotypical conspiracy theorist hides away at home with tin foil head-coverings to keep the mysterious airborne pathogens away.

Now, that's "normal people", while "conspiracy theorists" are those carrying on unfazed.

Re: Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's a clever little meme floating about showing a perfectly normal, happy, healthy, unmasked family with the caption "conspiracy theorists" and then in the adjacent panel a visibly paranoid person with a mask and face shield captioned "normal person". Cheap, but clever.

Uh, this is probably a cultural thing, but I don't get it? Can you please explain it to me? As in, what's "cheap but clever" about it?

Back in the day, pre-2020, conspiracy theorists were characterized as tending to avoid human contact and social interactions because they couldn't trust who was in on the conspiracy and happy families were characterized as normal people because there were a lot of them.

The meme highlights the big change in 2020 in which most people have accepted the reality of the Covid-19 pandemic and seek to reduce transmission risk by wearing a mask, avoiding close human contact and socially interactions. People that are not taking these precautions are justifying their actions to not wear masks by claiming that there is a conspiracy and that Covid-19 is all made up. Because they are not socially distancing or wearing masks they look like pre-2020 normal people, at least until they end up in the ICU.

Re: Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

#55
I'm really sick of seeing the media either pretend to be willfully ignorant of the way science works for the sake of clicks or just be stupid in the first place. Until they have something akin to study data they're going to tell you they don't know. Also, "can transmit" is a pretty tough bar to clear. If the worst off 1% of vaccine recipients can transmit COVID to someone while giving them mouth-to-mouth resuscitation it would technically count as "can transmit".

It doesn't really get reported widely, but scientific studies have indicated that, logically, people who have worse cases of the virus are more contagious. [0] [1] It is highly likely that the vast majority of people given the mRNA vaccines, which are 90+% effective in eliminating symptoms, will be very minimally contagious. Studies are pending, but there's no reason to believe that teaching your immune system to destroy the virus wouldn't also make less virus to be shed to infect other people.

[0] https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M20-2671

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-020-19057-5

Re: Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unlike older vaccines (such as polio vaccine) which generally used weakened or killed whole virus particles (and which occasionally produced infectious cases, due to the virus not being as weak or dead as intended), this vaccine contains no whole virus particles and thus cannot result in an infectious case. It contains RNA that cause the patient's cells to emit proteins normally produced by the viral infection (which…

Not that I agree with GPs concern, but this comment doesn't address it whatsoever.

It absolutely does address it.

The Pfizer chairman is saying he doesn't know whether you can get a spreadable COVID-19 infection after the vaccine has been administered, but before it takes full effect.

That's an entirely different thing from the vaccination CAUSING an infectious case of COVID-19.

Re: Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Uh, this is probably a cultural thing, but I don't get it? Can you please explain it to me? As in, what's "cheap but clever" about it?

The stereotypical conspiracy theorist hides away at home with tin foil head-coverings to keep the mysterious airborne pathogens away. Now, that's "normal people", while "conspiracy theorists" are those carrying on unfazed.

No. Note: The "No." here applies to your implied message, not your literal wording.

Conspiracy theorists are the ones who deny science.

Conspiracy theorists are the ones who refuse vaccines without reason.

Conspiracy theorists are the ones who believe in large scale fraud with no evidence.

Conspiracy theorists are the ones who think "This virus is a hoax".

I guess any of the above could also qualify for straight up stupidity, not just conspiracy theories.

Normal, sane, people follow science and act with compassion for their fellow man.

Wear a mask. It's not hard, I do it 8 hours a day.

I apologize for the rant.

Re: Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unlike older vaccines (such as polio vaccine) which generally used weakened or killed whole virus particles (and which occasionally produced infectious cases, due to the virus not being as weak or dead as intended), this vaccine contains no whole virus particles and thus cannot result in an infectious case. It contains RNA that cause the patient's cells to emit proteins normally produced by the viral infection (which…

There is absolutely 0% chance I'll be letting that anywhere near my family. And I was a biomedical scientist formerly. Over my dead body (one way or another).

> There is absolutely 0% chance I'll be letting that anywhere near my family.

I hope any children you may have are 18.

> And I was a biomedical scientist formerly.

Well we can see why it was formerly.

> Over my dead body (one way or another).

Could we maybe avoid putting others at risk?

Re: Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unlike older vaccines (such as polio vaccine) which generally used weakened or killed whole virus particles (and which occasionally produced infectious cases, due to the virus not being as weak or dead as intended), this vaccine contains no whole virus particles and thus cannot result in an infectious case. It contains RNA that cause the patient's cells to emit proteins normally produced by the viral infection (which…

There is absolutely 0% chance I'll be letting that anywhere near my family. And I was a biomedical scientist formerly. Over my dead body (one way or another).

Why?

Re: Pfizer chairman: We're not sure if someone can transmit Covid after vaccination

#60

I certainly intend to stay masked up post-jab(s). I think a month or so after the final dose it will be at the point where any viral load i might be spreading would be pretty much trustable to be at trivial levels, so that's my minimum duration. After that, I'll continue to follow public guidance from local health folks. I don't mind masking up for flights/travel for a bit, or whatever, either, if it shakes out that…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN