Live data from Hacker News

Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

npr.org

141–150 of 468 posts

Re: Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Yes, Bezos does not want an amazon union and won't just let it happen without a fight. Same as always. Which is, if I recalled correctly, illegal.

Not if you're rich

Maybe, but that doesn't make it right, and it won't change unless people are aware of it and fight against it, which is why this article is pointing it.

Re: Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

#142

Really disappointing to see the "Well, what did you expect?" comments already. Just because companies have been trying to prevent organization of their labor for over a century doesn't mean it isn't still messed up now. It's easy to say that it's just the way the world works from your desk, the people who are forced to work in Amazon's warehouses with terrible working conditions don't have that luxury.

I have not seen any convincing evidence that Amazon’s warehouses have “terrible working conditions”, do you have a source that might change my opinion?

The Center for Investigative Reporting has, through its online publication Reveal, covered Amazon for quite some time - especially with respect to injuries. See:

https://revealnews.org/?s=amazon

A search for "Amazon working conditions injuries" on DDG or Google will return many of those, but also follow-ups by many media houses considered to be reasoned/reliable, rather than rabid and ranting.

Anecdotal, perhaps, but these anecdotes are there in significant numbers.

Re: Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

#143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do companies have a right to circulate anti-union material, to have anti-union speakers come to work, etc?

Depends on the country but _tentatively_ yes, America has a infamously anti-union, anti-worker history though so there's significantly more holdover of it actually happening, what most other countries don't have is services like the Pinkertons, previously a literally rifle-armed military/police force for the purposes of seeking out and often murdering union leaders and breaking up strikes by force. What I was taught…

It is basically correct that the US police descend from a mixture of slave patrol remnants and strikebusters near the late 19th / beginning of the 20th century (though sometimes in opposition to them, the initial state police ranks were still largely drawn from private police, racist "town watches", and militia forces).

England and the rest of the Anglosphere adopted what are often called "Peelian principles," focused on policing by community consent, 50+ years earlier than that.

Re: Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

#144
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> People are getting payed $16 that is incredible for an unskilled labor position. That's one view, but it's only informed by "the way things are". Another view is based on the way things should be, that no one should have to work for less than the wage it takes to live a reasonable life. https://livingwage.mit.edu/ offers values for this. I don't see why someone should work full time and still end up poor.

And I disagree that everyone should get paid a loving wage. Let's take 2 identical twins Juan and Jamal (because if you've seen Juan you've seen Jamal). In school Jamal works hard, studies, and puts his efforts first. Juan on the other hand decides football is the way to go and along with that partying, drinking and at one point gets a gal pregnant. They graduate Jamal gets several scholarships and goes to school whi…

Do you have any statistics that can tell us how many "Jamals" actually exist in the US labour force? Because it feels like you are exaggerating a tiny tiny minority.

Re: Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

#145
In 1920 Appalachia, coal companies owned all the land, the homes and stores. They also paid workers with their own special money (that was useless everywhere else). The security companies they hired where armed and violent towards miners and their families.

https://explorepartsunknown.com/west-virginia/coal-minings-d...

Today, people can tour these old towns and learn the history of how the coal companies trapped and abused workers. A lot of unions and labor rights groups came out of the abuses that occurred in Appalachia.

Re: Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

#146
post #137

Really disappointing to see the "Well, what did you expect?" comments already. Just because companies have been trying to prevent organization of their labor for over a century doesn't mean it isn't still messed up now. It's easy to say that it's just the way the world works from your desk, the people who are forced to work in Amazon's warehouses with terrible working conditions don't have that luxury.

> the people who are forced to work in Amazon's warehouses Who is being forced?

People that cannot find a better alternative in their current personal situation. Sure they are not "forced" in a precise linguistic sense. But when it's this or nothing there is really just an illusion of choice.

Re: Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

#147
post #137

Really disappointing to see the "Well, what did you expect?" comments already. Just because companies have been trying to prevent organization of their labor for over a century doesn't mean it isn't still messed up now. It's easy to say that it's just the way the world works from your desk, the people who are forced to work in Amazon's warehouses with terrible working conditions don't have that luxury.

> the people who are forced to work in Amazon's warehouses Who is being forced?

Many people don't have the job flexibility and choice that many of us on HN have and are forced to take any available employment or go homeless.

Re: Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

#148
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can I just point out that I think the "horrible working conditions" things is a little played up. You want to know terrible working conditions dancing with a sign for 5 hours a day in the sun when it's 90+. I did that for 3 years and was happy to do the job, mind you this was only 10 years ago so it isn't forever. I made 7.50 an hour. I would've killed to get a job at amazon back then. People are getting payed $16 th…

It is incredibly played up. 10 years ago, warehouse conditions were the same or worse as they are now except you would be lucky to get $16/hr without a forklift operator certification or some other credential that made it more than just 'unskilled labor'

And ~160 years ago we had literal slavery, doesn't mean that people's working conditions currently are good, just because others were bad or even are still currently bad

Re: Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

#149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The exact same people? I marvel at their longevity! 128+ years is quite an accomplishment!

Corporations are people, legally.

People and corporations are both regarded as entities. That doesn't mean one is another.

An apple isn't a pear, even though both are fruits.

Re: Amazon reportedly has Pinkerton agents surveil workers who try to form unions

#150
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where do we draw the line? What tactics are ok for a company to use to combat unions if it doesn't want them? Or should companies just accept and work with any union that forms?

In most Western countries, workers have a right to form unions. So yes, companies have to accept it.

At the same time in most Western countries decent working conditions and wages are already mandated by law. I don't know what's the situation in the US but in Europe that means that conditions cannot be horrible to start with if the company acts within the law (which would be expected of a company like Amazon, but maybe I'm optimistic).

Unions are a way to negotiate a better deal than the legal minimum for unskilled labour.

Post reply on HN