Live data from Hacker News

It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013)

smithsonianmag.com

61–62 of 62 posts

Re: It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013)

#61
post #2

I didn't know how much of Jim Davis' motivations were commercial ones. It seems very at odds with folks like Calvin and Hobbes creator Bill Watterson: > For years, Watterson battled against pressure from publishers to merchandise his work, something that he felt would cheapen his comic. He refused to merchandise his creations on the grounds that displaying Calvin and Hobbes images on commercially sold mugs, stickers,…

I had a bunch of Garfield books as a kid, too. IIRC they were about 9”x6” and mostly black & white. I found them hilarious, I think for a couple reasons: 1. John was such a clueless loser 2. Garfield got so enraged at Nermal 3. Odie kept bouncing back This was not a deep humor. It’s the kind of humor where you see a dumb, funny video on the internet, snort a laugh, and move on, completely forgetting it ten seconds la…

I always thought of it as anti-humour, which is a form of humour in and of itself. A lot of almost-joke scenes that just sort of stop without actually going anywhere.

I liked Garfield because it dead-panned things that otherwise would have been funny. Hated the television cartoon version though.

Post reply on HN