Live data from Hacker News

Metal monolith found by helicopter crew in Utah desert

bbc.co.uk

41–50 of 515 posts

Re: Metal monolith found by helicopter crew in Utah desert

#43
post #16

Fun art installation, but it should be removed now that it's been found.

Why does it need to be removed? I understand not wanting to set a precedent, but I wish more organizations adopted a mindset that the original can stay, but no others are allowed. That leaves space for a little bit of whimsy.

Just thinking the same thing. There's no rule the you must clamp down the the first instance of a violation.

Leave it be, and leave the rule in place. If there's an epidemic of monoliths being planted on federal land, then you uproot them all and say "this is why we can't have nice things."

Until or unless that happens, just leave it alone.

Re: Metal monolith found by helicopter crew in Utah desert

#46
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How would they know the laws of federally managed public lands on other planets?

Ignorance of the law is no excuse.

Probably everyone is a criminal, because no one knows what all of the laws are.

Re: Metal monolith found by helicopter crew in Utah desert

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why does it need to be removed? I understand not wanting to set a precedent, but I wish more organizations adopted a mindset that the original can stay, but no others are allowed. That leaves space for a little bit of whimsy.

This is a federally protected land, there are no special rules for art unless it was before when such laws were made. FWIW, I find this piece of trash to be a showoff moment for some wannabe 'artist'. Mimicking a movie prop to me sounds like a low-effort, untalented mindset.

The feds say that it's illegal to install structures or art as in this case.

Re: Metal monolith found by helicopter crew in Utah desert

#48
post #16

Fun art installation, but it should be removed now that it's been found.

Presumably it's been laying unfound for a while now. If nobody's noticed it all this time, I don't see the point in removing it.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-surrey-17398342

Re: Metal monolith found by helicopter crew in Utah desert

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why does it need to be removed? I understand not wanting to set a precedent, but I wish more organizations adopted a mindset that the original can stay, but no others are allowed. That leaves space for a little bit of whimsy.

Just thinking the same thing. There's no rule the you must clamp down the the first instance of a violation. Leave it be, and leave the rule in place. If there's an epidemic of monoliths being planted on federal land, then you uproot them all and say "this is why we can't have nice things." Until or unless that happens, just leave it alone.

Eh, it's not good enough to get that kind of treatment.
Post reply on HN