Live data from Hacker News

YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them

forbes.com

11–20 of 783 posts

Re: YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them

#11
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it's kind of a shitty move by Google. It's kind of business as usual for Google. Why would anyone expect them to be kind and generous suddenly when they have consistently for years pulled the rug out underneath previosly-free services. (or killed them off completely https://killedbygoogle.com/ ) gmail subscriptions are next, just wait and see.

What do you mean by gmail subs?

Sounds like he's suggesting that you'll soon be required to pay for it.

Re: YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them

#12
post #2

Hacker News User Will Continue to Run uBlock Origin on All Sites Including YouTube Even If Webmasters Don't Want Him To

I think technically it would be pretty easy for google to embed ads into videos in a way that would be hard to impossible to block.

It would be very expensive, though, as they would have to recode videos constantly.

(Edit: my children comments are right)

Re: YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them

#13

Edit: I need to emphasise that the ads were occasional, and probably YouTube will be more agressive this time. I've also realised that many of you are using some sort of ad-blocker, so you might not felt the changes when it was (silently) rolled out years ago, but this is from my experience using YouTube on devices which I cannot install an ad-blocker (like in some instructional videos for certain robots which some c…

If you're referring to in-video ads, then no.

At present, if you choose not to monetize a video, no ads get shown unless a third part makes a copyright claim on your video.

I'm not quite sure about the situation with ads that show up in the corner of the page - those are unobtrusive enough that I'm used to mentally tuning them out.

Re: YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them

#14

I know there are several content creators (such as Jim Sterling) that have their videos ad-free as a perk for their supporters (since he's supported enough via Patreon). He's pretty angry about this change. I somewhat understand Google's stance on this, as it's a service that should be allowed to make money even on people who don't want to make money. They don't really have such a way to opt out of pretty much any ot…

If let's say that google charges 1$ (or more, adjust yourself) per gb of stored video, or 1$ per 20gb of bandwidth use to opt out of ads, will it be better?

They don't need to charge, they're making money hand over fist.

Re: YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them

#15
Bait and switch. This is what big companies do. They buy products that are a threat to them, or allow them to address the threat of another company. Then they offer the bought company's services for free for a period. Then it ends.

The point is to kill competition so they can settle in and collect rent.

Re: YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them

#16
Please use newpipe if you are on android. Your watching ads of your favourite small youtuber wont get them paid anyways because of this so make your experience a bit cleaner. Use newpipe.

Also, start looking into peertube. While its still long ways from a competing software, its going strong and the more people join it, the better will be the network effect.

Re: YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them

#17
post #2

Hacker News User Will Continue to Run uBlock Origin on All Sites Including YouTube Even If Webmasters Don't Want Him To

I think technically it would be pretty easy for google to embed ads into videos in a way that would be hard to impossible to block.

I've long wondered why they don't do this for video ads. If they were served as part of the main video stream it would be almost impossible for ad-blockers to filter them.

(I even think the DASH segmentation would allow them to this without reencoding the original video, but that's just speculation on my part)

Re: YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them

#18
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think technically it would be pretty easy for google to embed ads into videos in a way that would be hard to impossible to block.

It would be very expensive, though, as they would have to recode videos constantly. (Edit: my children comments are right)

At first I thought you had a point (and for practical purposes, perhaps you do) but I don't think it'd be particularly challenging to inject video frames into a stream without re-encoding the original video.

Re: YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them

#20
post #2

Hacker News User Will Continue to Run uBlock Origin on All Sites Including YouTube Even If Webmasters Don't Want Him To

I think technically it would be pretty easy for google to embed ads into videos in a way that would be hard to impossible to block.

Very probably not. Dynamic ad insertion usually uses separate domains for serving the ad media and it's probably not viable to inject totally unblockable dynamic ads at the media level. And also not breaking YT for some clients on the way.
Post reply on HN