Live data from Hacker News

Let's Make the Web Weird Again [audio]

podcasts.apple.com

1–10 of 54 posts

Re: Let's Make the Web Weird Again [audio]

#3
> "You must enable DRM to play some audio or video on this page"

No.

No no no no no.

This isn't right.

The modern Internet is such sellout. It didn't turn out anything like what I'd hoped.

Bittorrent, semantic tagging, RSS, decentralized aggregation. Ownership. All dead or dying.

These companies are all gobbling up the commons and pushing us into serfdom. Apple, Google, the RIAA. The whole lot of them have poached and polluted the web and protected their profits.

Pretty soon we won't be able to "view source". It'll just be binary blobs with DRM. The browser monoculture will collapse into a universal thin client that leaves "standards" in the dust and takes away all the features BigCo developers don't themselves need. Nobody wants URL bars or ad blocking extensions. Those get in the way of the revolutionary UX they've prepared for us to predictably fawn over.

If Flash can die, one day 3rd party websites can too. In fifteen years your personal website won't even work. I can hear it now: "What's haitch tea tea pee?" Too confusing. Too dangerous.

Your tiny applet will exist within the WeeChat shell that is ChromeOS. The BigCo [1] will take 50% of your profits and make you obey arbitrary rules, lest your app be taken down. This bleak utopia is coming to Microsoft Windows too, because they know best how to Protect You™ and make your computing Trusted™.

All interactions will be recorded for training the models. You don't deserve that data yourself. Only BigCo has the resources and expertise to build their own. And they'll use it against^W for you to sell more ads and Farmville Loot Crates. You're just another whale to pump full of dopamine.

"Nobody would personally own an oil rig or an airplane, so why would anybody own a computer? What a laughable concept. Only big companies get to have those. Go back to your safe and easy to understand smart tablet that we've prepared for you, and consume your TwitterTok FaceFeed."

...

I hate supporting this. Economically or with my brain.

Stallman told us it was coming. Brace yourselves.

[1] there are several, and that is an important point, because several BigCo competing for your attention cannot possibly constitute a monopoly. That's an outdated concept from last century. Go be angry at your local representative and/or family members so you can drive more engagement for us.

Re: Let's Make the Web Weird Again [audio]

#4
post #3

> "You must enable DRM to play some audio or video on this page" No. No no no no no. This isn't right. The modern Internet is such sellout. It didn't turn out anything like what I'd hoped. Bittorrent, semantic tagging, RSS, decentralized aggregation. Ownership . All dead or dying. These companies are all gobbling up the commons and pushing us into serfdom. Apple, Google, the RIAA. The whole lot of them have poached a…

I opened the link and didn't see this link, but I don't have Widevine disabled. Is Apple seriously blocking podcasts without DRM? One of the last open mediums on the web?

Re: Let's Make the Web Weird Again [audio]

#5
post #3

> "You must enable DRM to play some audio or video on this page" No. No no no no no. This isn't right. The modern Internet is such sellout. It didn't turn out anything like what I'd hoped. Bittorrent, semantic tagging, RSS, decentralized aggregation. Ownership . All dead or dying. These companies are all gobbling up the commons and pushing us into serfdom. Apple, Google, the RIAA. The whole lot of them have poached a…

I often wonder how much time it will take for the scenario you described to collapse. Once computer systems become completely closed and programming becomes unavailable to the lowly user, how are new skilled people going to find their way into the system? Will it die when the last developers of the system retire?

Re: Let's Make the Web Weird Again [audio]

#6
post #3

> "You must enable DRM to play some audio or video on this page" No. No no no no no. This isn't right. The modern Internet is such sellout. It didn't turn out anything like what I'd hoped. Bittorrent, semantic tagging, RSS, decentralized aggregation. Ownership . All dead or dying. These companies are all gobbling up the commons and pushing us into serfdom. Apple, Google, the RIAA. The whole lot of them have poached a…

I'm optimistic about Web3. Filecoin and Sia have added incentives for decentralized storage markets so I think truly decentralized applications are now practical to develop.

We realign incentives and we will realign the web along with them.

Re: Let's Make the Web Weird Again [audio]

#7
post #4
post #3

> "You must enable DRM to play some audio or video on this page" No. No no no no no. This isn't right. The modern Internet is such sellout. It didn't turn out anything like what I'd hoped. Bittorrent, semantic tagging, RSS, decentralized aggregation. Ownership . All dead or dying. These companies are all gobbling up the commons and pushing us into serfdom. Apple, Google, the RIAA. The whole lot of them have poached a…

I opened the link and didn't see this link, but I don't have Widevine disabled. Is Apple seriously blocking podcasts without DRM? One of the last open mediums on the web?

No, not as far as I can tell. It's just an MP3. I guess the DRM requirement is site-wide or something.

Re: Let's Make the Web Weird Again [audio]

#8
post #3

> "You must enable DRM to play some audio or video on this page" No. No no no no no. This isn't right. The modern Internet is such sellout. It didn't turn out anything like what I'd hoped. Bittorrent, semantic tagging, RSS, decentralized aggregation. Ownership . All dead or dying. These companies are all gobbling up the commons and pushing us into serfdom. Apple, Google, the RIAA. The whole lot of them have poached a…

I'm optimistic about Web3. Filecoin and Sia have added incentives for decentralized storage markets so I think truly decentralized applications are now practical to develop. We realign incentives and we will realign the web along with them.

I would only trust in web again if there is serious open source/libre post-quantum encryption.

Re: Let's Make the Web Weird Again [audio]

#9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm optimistic about Web3. Filecoin and Sia have added incentives for decentralized storage markets so I think truly decentralized applications are now practical to develop. We realign incentives and we will realign the web along with them.

I would only trust in web again if there is serious open source/libre post-quantum encryption.

Other than that web/internet is NOT trust worthy. Great for entertainment, not serious business or financial transaction.

Re: Let's Make the Web Weird Again [audio]

#10
post #3

> "You must enable DRM to play some audio or video on this page" No. No no no no no. This isn't right. The modern Internet is such sellout. It didn't turn out anything like what I'd hoped. Bittorrent, semantic tagging, RSS, decentralized aggregation. Ownership . All dead or dying. These companies are all gobbling up the commons and pushing us into serfdom. Apple, Google, the RIAA. The whole lot of them have poached a…

Even as BigCos do their best to ruin the mainstream for everyone, there are plenty of alternatives popping up. Gopher, Gemini, shared Unix terminals, Tor, etc.

I'm not necessarily disagreeing with your prediction, but I predict if things get so bad, there will definitely be a healthy community of counterculture hackers who will do things differently.

Post reply on HN