Live data from Hacker News

Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

ycombinator.com

111–120 of 401 posts

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

#111
>> 23. More open alternatives to Wikipedia.

Yes, deletionists - this is really one flaw of Wikipedia. The other is, that entities are persecuted for editing articles about themselves.

What about just to copy the current articles on Wikipedia and specify another rules for editing?

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

#112
post #72
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure I buy the SWOT that Graham's proposing for Craigslist or EBay. There are ways that both suck, but there's an absolutely enormous network effect they're riding on.

I agree, although when you're funding 20 startups at a time, I bet you start thinking about throwing some scratch-ticket ideas into the mix. It's unlikely they can pull it off, but with a basket of longshot, astronomical payoff startups, if one pays off, you're in great shape.

If you're young enough to try several times, this also pays off for individual founders. I think one reason Sam Altman had no second thoughts about taking on such an ambitious project was that he was only 19.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

#113
I can't believe you miss the biggest market in the world. Is everyone in your office under 30? It's HEALTH CARE, it dwarfs EVERY "INDUSTRY" in the USA right now. Even the defense industry pales in comparison.

Hey, I have a zillion health care ideas! Google saved my life. :-)

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

#114
post #2

I'm a bit surprised. Some of the ideas - ok, two of the ideas, dating and "the next craigslist" - don't seem that far off from the proverbial pie-in-the-sky "Facebook killer": the hard part is getting the critical mass, and everyone wants to make one. [edit] #9 and 10, photo/video sharing and auctions, are arguably in this category as well. I also still don't get WebOS. There must be something to it, because a lot of…

One reason those are broad is that our own filters are. We're interested in any dating site that also includes a solution to the chicken and egg problem.

BTW, by "Craigslist competitor" I don't mean a new Craigslist. I mean take one thing Craigslist does, and do it better. When you later expand outward from that, you don't have to expand into the rest of the stuff Craigslist does.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

#115
post #46

I'm passionate about online learning. I like James Burke's knowledge web idea [ http://www.k-web.org/ ], but I'm not terribly optimistic about their approach/implementation. The idea is to make a network of knowledge which enables self-directed learning. Could incorporate tests/games, dependencies (to learn x, you need to learn y, or even complete a subgame), external references for further reading, and possibly a lo…

That's sort of what we're aiming to do at http://www.dojolearning.com/ - longer term anyway. We're starting off by hitting the business market first, which is more open to change and not as tied to the existing learning systems, but we do plan to branch out in lots of ways to make a better online learning experience for everyone.

Anyway, if you're passionate about online learning, I'd love to chat about it with you if you're interested...

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

#116
post #87
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know. I was just saying that if you want to beat Google, that's their weak spot. Or at least a big one. Most people who read that one will think "huh?" But if someone reads it and thinks "Damn, how did he hear about what we're working on?" that's someone we'd really love to hear from.

The way to approach the Google problem is to ask, when have I been dissatisfied with google search? And you're right, there are very few weaknesses. One of the startup approaches to the Google problem is to join forces with them instead of competing with them. Provide a page that wraps google search, but adds additional searchable items into the searchbar (search emails, todo lists, events, facebook, google all throu…

One thing that has irked me about Google AdSense ads is when they present an ad based on faulty disamboguation: e.g., I'm reading an email from cello-dev(Cello is a Lisp package), and I get an ad for a re-hairing service[they put new hair on bows for stringed instruments].

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

#117
post #114
post #2

I'm a bit surprised. Some of the ideas - ok, two of the ideas, dating and "the next craigslist" - don't seem that far off from the proverbial pie-in-the-sky "Facebook killer": the hard part is getting the critical mass, and everyone wants to make one. [edit] #9 and 10, photo/video sharing and auctions, are arguably in this category as well. I also still don't get WebOS. There must be something to it, because a lot of…

One reason those are broad is that our own filters are. We're interested in any dating site that also includes a solution to the chicken and egg problem. BTW, by "Craigslist competitor" I don't mean a new Craigslist. I mean take one thing Craigslist does, and do it better. When you later expand outward from that, you don't have to expand into the rest of the stuff Craigslist does.

I just can't help not to relate these two things: Make a better "erotic service" and "personals" than Craigslist is. But will YC fund such a startup?

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

#118
post #112
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree, although when you're funding 20 startups at a time, I bet you start thinking about throwing some scratch-ticket ideas into the mix. It's unlikely they can pull it off, but with a basket of longshot, astronomical payoff startups, if one pays off, you're in great shape.

If you're young enough to try several times, this also pays off for individual founders. I think one reason Sam Altman had no second thoughts about taking on such an ambitious project was that he was only 19.

Had Sam Altman done other projects before Loopt?

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

#119

I would take issue with point 16 (on Google and design). I don't work for Google, but I do have a lot of respect for the company. I've never perceieved any 'design' problem. In terms of their interfaces, I think they've probably spent a huge amount of time on design, and got it exactly right. Simple, sparse and functional. From everything I've heard, the 'design' of their software and system architecture is also top…

Google's products succeed because they're technically brilliant and well executed, not because their design is massively better (see: iPod, iPhone).

Google avoids bad design by the simple expedient of making everything sparse and functional, which is the way to go if you're not a great designer.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund

#120
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're young enough to try several times, this also pays off for individual founders. I think one reason Sam Altman had no second thoughts about taking on such an ambitious project was that he was only 19.

Had Sam Altman done other projects before Loopt?

Not that I know of. He wouldn't have had much time; he was a sophomore when he started Loopt.
Post reply on HN