Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Are you depressed?

strawpoll.me

341–350 of 512 posts

Re: Ask HN: Are you depressed?

#341

Ok, here goes: I think I might have depression. But my life is by all accounts pretty damn good. I don’t have any health issues, actually I’m fitter than most people. I make a great salary, have good relationships. I show up to work and do a good job. However I’ve been managing this shitty feeling that I just can’t seem to shake. It’s been so long it’s my new normal. I get fatigued and agitated easily. I feel alone -…

I think you're already in a pretty good place - the fact you have healthy relationships, a good job and you regularly exercise is very very important. And yet, something is still off by your account. Fatigue, agitation, loneliness. It's not entirely clear to me why you get these fits of agitation, loneliness etc. A lot of depressed people feel down about themselves - they feel like they're worthless, no good, a failure etc. You don't see yourself that way - which is good, but it also calls for more exploration into your predicament. The fact you're kinda already doing everything right (sports, relationships etc) is a sign you may do need external help as you yourself said. An obvious thing that may be lacking by your account is a signifcant other, but in itself is not gonna be a cure for depression.

Re: Ask HN: Are you depressed?

#342
post #225
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As someone who has suffered from depression in the past, I'd like to borrow Steven Fry's words on depression: “You don’t get depressed because bad things happen to you. . .depression is something that happens like weather to you, it’s inside you. . .it’s not enough to talk yourself out of it by saying, ‘but I shouldn’t be depressed because I’ve got people who are nice to me’. . .It’s very important, at least to get t…

A million times this. Depression isn’t sadness, or being unhappy. It’s not even really on the same dimension as those things.

But it often has a connection with your current circumstances, no? I mean, I bet most inmates are kinda depressed right? And most people living in villas in Venice California aren't as depressed. I'm using extreme examples, I know.

Re: Ask HN: Are you depressed?

#343
For me work has been very stressful, though I'm better off than most people, the pandemic did not affect me very much but I find work very toxic. I'm a very young software engineer at 23 in a country where most engineers you will find are 26 and above I got my first full time developer job when I was 19 fresh out of high school.

Most people consider me as smart but I'm not given the opportunity to use my skills. In late 2019 I had decided to resign my current job because I found it too toxic, I had been diagnosed with bipolar and things had been very hard before I had decided to go and see a therapist who when immediately saw me referred me to a psychiatrist and I've been on medication since then.

My manager convinced me to stay and offered me a small increase in salary and promised me that my voice will be heard. He also convinced me to take a contract that involved completing an app that I had been working on. he made a lot of promises to me. As soon as I accepted his new offer and rejoined the company, he changed again, I'm still faced with the issues I used face previously and as someone with bipolar, I get stressed easily and the company does not make it any easy for me. Last week I just decided to send my manager a notification about my planned exit next year. He's trying to convince me to continue staying... So I'm just wondering why s would someone want you to stay in a company without giving you the opportunity for growth? For me it feels like they just want to use me to do the hard work and then "The right people will take the credit", considering I don't have a university degree.

Are other young engineers who are talented face similar issues in other companies? Despite my age, I've been working with computers longer than most people around me. So I do know a lot and can easily do any task. A lot of people are just usually concerned with how do I know what I know? Most of the time people don't listen to me and when things go wrong or something is very technical they always want me to be the one to do that but I get no credit. Maybe I'm the problem. Is there something about me that makes it hard to be acceptable to these people?

Re: Ask HN: Are you depressed?

#344

I'm living in Iran. Here the situation is disaster. it gets worth when you grow up in religious family. I can not listen to any music, watching any movie or even worth I can not play any video games easily.. Economical situation here is disaster so I can not rent a new apartment and move in.. I forced to go to male-only school, male-only high-school and even now I study computer science at a male-only university. And…

worth > worse !!! (worth even kind of means the opposite) Regarding all you critique: That is just how your culture is setup. Mostly males live a lonely live with each other, cf. the animal kingdom, where "young males gather in groups until they get older, if surviving and might find (younger) females, then". If you go to mixed classes, like me, then there are a lot of girls, which have zero interest in you (but have…

> If you go to mixed classes, like me, then there are a lot of girls, which have zero interest in you (but have some "older" boyfriend) and constantly are turned off by you and look down on you.

This is because in a lot of western countries we still have a strong culture of differiencing the way boys and girls are educated. For example, they are seperated from preschool, and expected to play with different toys. Experiments in "gender neutral" preschools show kids tends to play more with kids from the other gender compared to other preschools.[0]

[0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00220...

Re: Ask HN: Are you depressed?

#345
post #324
post #315

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know I shouldn't, but I'm secretly a little envious of people who are starting from scratch with absolute freedom. I kind of have it all, except for total freedom. I really have nothing to complain about and my life is great. Still, there was this time when I had nothing but a bicycle with four panniers of things for several months, wasn't sure where I'd sleep next, had to withstand cold and rain, and it was easily…

grappling with this myself these days. I would happily choose music over food years back. but once i started making code money, i got so comfortable. built up a whole world and « lifestyle » that now I (feel like I) have to maintain. and it feels like that’s how life continues to go as you accumulate a partner, pet, kids... you keep building up this house of cards that gets harder and harder to prevent from it all fa…

I recommend reading "To Have or to Be" by Erich Fromm. Great book that deals exactly with these types of questions.

Re: Ask HN: Are you depressed?

#346
Yes. I'm about 35 and I've been depressed for the past 20 years. I now have a relatively high paying job in a startup working remotely from a house I own in a forest. That was my dream, and it's great when I think about it.

But I live alone and I have no friends IRL. I've been practicing social distancing way before it was cool, and like most people it's affecting me. I've been alone without friends or lovers in major cities for most of my life before so the isolation with or without people around is not new.

Before covid I used to go to a few festivals or camps every year and do environmental activism regularly, and that'd keep the loneliness at bay, although the connections with the people I'd meet were superficial and short lived.

Being into environmental activism means that I don't see the current world situation in a very positive way to say the least. And my job, while high paying, offer no meaning at all to my life. But it pays for everything else and that's great. I've traveled without money for a couple of years before and it was great, but I prefer the security money give me in the capitalist society I'm trapped in.

I think about suicide a lot, but I'd never do it because of how it'd affect my parents and sibling, they are great and don't deserve that. I also like to live a life of contemplation in the forest and hacking stuff and following new scientific discoveries, it's just the craving for intimacy and companionship that ruins everything. Maybe when I get older I'll learn to fully let got of it, it's already a bit easier that a decade ago.

I guess the answer is probably to talk about all of that to a therapist, but I've been trying for years to make myself see one without success for now.

Re: Ask HN: Are you depressed?

#347
Never been better, personally.

I'm used to travelling a lot, I've been doing it since I was a wee baby thanks to my very international family, so it's been a very strange thing to be constrained to a single country for so long. Ignoring that though, I've been doing quite well. I was always a freelancer, so my job didn't really suffer much, I'm pretty much working exactly as much as I used to. My friend circle is all similarly international people, and we've grown accustomed to not seeing each other for months, sometimes years at a time so this is just another one of those periods for most of us. Since getting out of the house is a bit of a hassle, I mostly just do yard work now, it's very calming. Not much has changed, other than the inability of flying whenever I pleased like before, but I'm hopeful that those travel restrictions will loosen relatively soon, and once that happens I'm pretty much back where I started, which is a good place.

Re: Ask HN: Are you depressed?

#348

Nowhere else to post this so here it goes. I lost my job in January. From January - March I started looking for a job and then COVID hits at the height of my search, now suddenly no one is hiring and all the businesses are slowing down. My girlfriend of 13 years left me the day after my birthday in June before I had a chance to propose to her, I had to return the ring, she had no idea and I never told her about it. I…

This reminds me of that Wait but Why post [0] about picking your life partner. TL;DR: it is better to have no one than to be around people that you're not happy with. I know this sounds like a cliche but it is true. You're not at the bottom of the scale right now, but in the middle. The upside is that now you have the chance to pick whatever floats your boat without carrying the baggage around.

[0]:https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/02/pick-life-partner.html

Re: Ask HN: Are you depressed?

#349

I had an inability to focus and paralyzing procrastination until the election was decided. And then, like a miracle, it went away. :) Not making a political statement with that, but we have a ton of stuff weighing over all of us right now, so be easy on yourself if you feel a bit down or unable to do anything like normal productivity - you are definitely not alone.

> "Not making a political statement with that"

Negating something also 'somewhat' implies the opposite (the not negated version). Also you add a smiley ":)" in the paragraph before, which drops a very clear hint.

I can say with certainty close to 100% that you are a strong Biden supporter and fan.

I am happy for you that politics fixed your depression.

Re: Ask HN: Are you depressed?

#350
I was close to burnout early this year when I decided to quit the job market altogether (I was a programmer). I decided to start doing something else instead (teaching people how to program). I'm still doing programming, but only as a hobby, or on projects I pick. My stress levels dropped significantly, and I work much less for only a 20% decrease in pay.

That being said this COVID situation is starting to take a toll. I'm only meeting with friends in open spaces and with 1.5 meters between us. No lan parties, and stuff like that. I really hope that next year we'll get a vaccine and we can return to a more normal lifestyle because I'm starting to feel like a pit bull with half of its mouth sewn shut.

Post reply on HN