Live data from Hacker News

Ableton Live 11

ableton.com

191–200 of 268 posts

Re: Ableton Live 11

#191

The Spitfire Audio additions are a really compelling competitor to the Vienna Symphonic Library.

Not even close. VSL has many more instruments, orchestrations, articulations, and mics than the instruments bundled in Live.

Don't get me wrong, these are nice additions for Live users, but VSL is simply one of the top orchestral libraries.

Re: Ableton Live 11

#192

Ableton Live is my absolute favorite piece of software right now. It fills me with a joy I haven't felt since I first learned HyperCard or Photoshop. It's just marvelous. In fact, it's so good that it makes it harder for me to finish music since I keep tinkering on things. But I can just sink hours into it without noticing the time pass. It's so easy to get jaded with software these days because of freemium apps, dar…

Quite off topic, but: where would a person go nowadays to get up to speed about music making? (Learning, news, etc). I used to tinker with beatmaking back when fl studio was still called fruity loops, and this post has made me very nostalgic. I would like to get back as a hobby, but it's been like 15 years and I'm quite lost.

couple of ableton made, but completely browser based tutorials (they might not fit the specific topic you are looking into learning but still I think they are cool to check out)

https://learningmusic.ableton.com/

https://learningsynths.ableton.com/

Re: Ableton Live 11

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quite off topic, but: where would a person go nowadays to get up to speed about music making? (Learning, news, etc). I used to tinker with beatmaking back when fl studio was still called fruity loops, and this post has made me very nostalgic. I would like to get back as a hobby, but it's been like 15 years and I'm quite lost.

YouTube! Here are some people that I personally subscribe to and currently watch. Blezz Beats (8.68K subs) – https://www.youtube.com/blezzbeats Synth Mania (126K subs) – https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCSGAKoBpUJI5jrJLgFQxiiw Rick Beato (1.93M subs) – https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJquYOG5EL82sKTfH9aMA9Q Ave McRee (71K subs) – https://www.youtube.com/user/AveMcree Dom Sigalas (23.5K subs) – https://www.youtube.co…

just want to add my favorite music production youtuber to the list https://www.youtube.com/andrewhuang

Re: Ableton Live 11

#194
post #191

The Spitfire Audio additions are a really compelling competitor to the Vienna Symphonic Library.

Not even close. VSL has many more instruments, orchestrations, articulations, and mics than the instruments bundled in Live. Don't get me wrong, these are nice additions for Live users, but VSL is simply one of the top orchestral libraries.

True, but it feels like it provides something that scratches at VSL's surface.

Re: Ableton Live 11

#195

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have actually found the clip/scene feature in Bitwig to be better than the equivalent feature in Ableton. In Bitwig I can set the DAW to record a set number of bars for each clip and then start looping immediately after recording finishes, which is my perfect workflow for building a track. With Ableton I was not able to do this, and instead I would be required to hit 'stop' and then manually crop the clip by changi…

I'm pretty sure that you can do this with a Push using a fixed length clip. https://www.musicradar.com/tuition/tech/how-to-capture-the-p... Can you not do it without the Push?

This is one of the huge blind areas of Ableton, and one that they chose not to address in 11. You do have to use the Push to launch clips of a specified length in live performance. There have been very complicated workarounds built by third parties (BinkLooper). I have wondered if this is all a ploy to force people to buy the expensive Push. At any rate, it has definitely kept me from buying Ableton. It is regarded as a live performance tool by many but the lack of this feature, which they could easily add, makes that regard incorrect.

Re: Ableton Live 11

#196
post #4

As a UI and UX nerd, one thing I really love about the digital music production scene is that software companies writing DAWs and VSTs know their audience and strive to give power users all the tools they need to be as productive as possible. Knobs, curves, programming (Max for Live), integration with external tools. In other fields of software development instead we dumb everything down to the lowest denominator, an…

I was blown away when Propellerheads Reason introduced wire patching fully working on Windows XP!! This is one of the oldest videos I could find quickly: https://youtu.be/IC1ejK2chLg. Just to put time into perspective, the introduction of this actual feature pre-dates Facebook!

Re: Ableton Live 11

#197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's not what my experience tells me. If you read on Ableton website: > Live uses one thread to process a signal path. A signal path is a single chain of audio flow. In tracks where instrument or effect racks are used, with multiple chains in parallel, Live may use one thread per chain depending on how CPU-intensive each chain may be. If two tracks are "chained" by routings, for instance by a side-chain routing, a…

You should read the link I posted (I wrote it). Ableton's scheduling could be quibbled with, but it's better than the kernel can do. Ps. I'm the original author of Ardour, a cross-platform DAW. We use a different model than Ableton for scheduling, but not that different. We run N threads (based on a user preference for how many cores to use) and they pull signal paths from a pool, process them, and go back for more.…

As a side note... thank you for Ardour!!

Re: Ableton Live 11

#198

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You'd end up with GarageBand. It all depends on the target audience. If you have a piece of software meant to be used by experts, it should be powerful enough that it doesn't restrict them. I disagree that software has a tendency to dumb everything down to the lowest common denominator, simplifying and automating things is the purpose of software in the first place, but there's a huge amount of software out there tha…

No, you'd end up with Fruity Loops

As a long time (15+yrs) user of both. FLS has better ergonomics in a lot of places. Especially piano roll (slide MIDI notes) and arrangement view (automation as standalone clip). Plus the razor tool, my god...

FLS doesn't have a max for live equivalent, but I'd guess 90% of people don't use MFL. The edison recording workflow is hot trash IMO, or else I'd pretty readily move back to FL.

Re: Ableton Live 11

#199
post #166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1) The launch grid (I forget it’s proper name) is an increasingly common pattern in touch-based music apps; I want to touch the Ableton one. Especially in live performance. 2)The form factor of an iPad makes more sense in my music setup, in that I don’t need to haul podium or standing desk on stage as well as my instruments. 3. In producing tracks, most of my time is spent twiddling knobs, adjusting levels, etc, rath…

You should check out bitwig studio on a Surface tablet! They have had an optimized Multitouch UX mode for a few years now, and it looks pretty good.

IIRC Bitwig was actually featured in the Surface launch event (I think it was the very first generation of the Surface tablet, I might be wrong though).

Re: Ableton Live 11

#200
Be aware, that in reality, for live performance, you have to buy a costly Push device. This is if you want to create live loops of a specified length and have them start playing automatically. They crippled this feature in the DAW so that you have to buy a Push. They could have allowed you to do this without a Push in many different ways. There is a third party tool called BinkLooper which gets you there, sort of, but it's not like what they worked out with their Push. I don't want the Push on stage and I don't want to spend what is basically the price of Live all over again (plus have another expensive thing to have to upgrade again and again).
Post reply on HN