Live data from Hacker News

Why Silicon Valley has so many Bad Managers

getlighthouse.com

71–76 of 76 posts

Re: Why Silicon Valley has so many Bad Managers

#71

In engineering Hiring good managers is not what they optimize for. Yes Engineering management should still have a high level of understanding of engineering principals within that domain, but management also because a people skill. Out of all my interviews, people skills and EQ are very often overlooked.

EQ has already been co-opted as a term and rendered essentially meaningless. One job, there was a craze for it, starting at the top, so naturally we all eventually had to go to this wretched little one day course on it. I kid you not, everything was about either "fear" or "love." If that sounds familiar, if it sounds like Donnie Darko , you would be right ... almost everything we were "taught" in this emotional intel…

That sounds like mental abuse.

EQ would be more about using empathy to connect to others, try to understand other's points etc. Of course, if you "teach" such stuff to manipulative people, you get wretched results.

Re: Why Silicon Valley has so many Bad Managers

#72
> That VP who delivered your best quarter ever sexually harassed someone, again: Do you sweep it under the rug?

No. And the idea that this is a decision at all is frankly pretty disgusting. Some things are more important than having a good quarter, like your self respect and the physical and emotional safety of your employees. If your company can’t survive having criminals removed, then maybe it shouldn’t.

Re: Why Silicon Valley has so many Bad Managers

#74

There's a lot of great points in the article, though I'm unsure how Silicon Valley's early/mature companies stack against average ones. Take for instance: - Are managers at a pizza shop / drywall contractor / design studio better than the average startup? - Are managers at IBM / GE / JPM better than ones at Facebook / Apple / Google? At first blush, I'd think that we're actually better correcting for firm age, but I'…

If anything, I would argue that management in Silicon Valley is better than average. A Silicon Valley manager knows that if they mistreat their underlings too much, those underlings will quit and go somewhere else. A manager, at say, a manufacturing plant in a Rust Belt city faces no such restrictions. If they fire a worker, that worker has nowhere else to go, and as a result, the line workers in those locations and…

Unless those underlings are H-1B visa holders and cannot leave.

Re: Why Silicon Valley has so many Bad Managers

#75
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I work at a tech company on the east coast, and the managers I've talked to don't like managing west coast dev teams for all the reasons you mentioned. They said they'll refuse to show up to meetings, won't answer phone calls/emails/slack, don't document anything, etc., because they think they're code artisans and won't do anything that they think is below them.

The west coast sounds like a paradise for developers. Makes me wish I had moved...

Why didn't you?
Post reply on HN