Live data from Hacker News

VPN by Google One

one.google.com

71–80 of 129 posts

Re: VPN by Google One

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Only if in your mind "VPN" equals "anonymity and privacy" (which it shouldn't).

The P stands for Private so I think privacy would be a part of it somehow.

Private vs public.

VPNs are to allow you to connect to a private network over a public network. They are not about user privacy. Once you hit that private network, privacy is determined by other protocols, not the VPN itself.

Re: VPN by Google One

#72
post #51

Unless I’m mistaken it just appears to be for Android phones ? I guess I can see some value in it, but will no doubt be heading for the Google graveyard in 18-24months !

"iOS, Windows, and Mac coming soon"

Re: VPN by Google One

#73
post #34

What is Google One? Is this the service formally known as Google Apps or some other service? I find it hard to keep track of all their products because they change so much.

> What is Google One?

Google One is Google's paid-storage-plus-premium-support-for-consumer-products service.

You could view it as, in an imprecise way, the consumer counterpart to Google Workspace (formerly G Suite, formerly Google Apps.)

Re: VPN by Google One

#74
post #51

Unless I’m mistaken it just appears to be for Android phones ? I guess I can see some value in it, but will no doubt be heading for the Google graveyard in 18-24months !

It's been included with their Google Fi service for a while. Unless they are planning on killing Google Fi their VPN service is going to stick around I would assume. But they did just kill off my nest secure I bought, which was very disappointing.

Re: VPN by Google One

#75
I understand why no one would want to trust Google and after Snowden's revelations, I don't see why anyone should.

But when it comes to the largest VPNs such as ExpressVPN or Nord VPN, it is impossible to tell who is truly behind them. You cannot put a name on physical person in charge which is very worrying. And since the NSA is known to use front companies to spy on people [1], why couldn't they be behind all these other VPNs? At least, we know who runs Google.

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20131016033046/http://www.foreig...

Re: VPN by Google One

#76
post #17

Never in a million years would I trust google as my VPN provider. 1) No customer support 2) it will probably be cancelled in 18 months 3) they already spy on me enough with search, android, google keyboard, gmail

> 1) No customer support Google One has customer support. Largely, Google One is paid support Google consumer products,. That's actually one of the main selling points. Since this is a feature of a particular Google One tier, it comes with support. > 2) it will probably be cancelled in 18 months Probably not. > 3) they already spy on me enough with search, android, google keyboard, gmail How would being a VPN (for An…

> It doesn't increase Google's ability to spy on you

You're going to have to prove that. Your Android device doesn't send ALL your traffic to Google today. Using this would send ALL your traffic to Google. that 100% means it increases Google's ability to spy on you.

Re: VPN by Google One

#79
post #69
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> your IP is not associated to your activity Does this mean your incoming IP, or your outgoing IP? And if payment info or Google identity is associated with your activity, why would they need to bother associating an IP to your activity?

If you read the article then you would already know the answer to this question. They are using a blinding protocol so that the service that terminates the VPN is unaware of the identity of the user.

And yet this product is being built by an advertising company who's business model revolves around tracking your online activities to sell you to advertisers, which makes me deeply suspicious that there isn't some way using this makes you more trackable (by them) than using a different VPN

Re: VPN by Google One

#80
post #51

Unless I’m mistaken it just appears to be for Android phones ? I guess I can see some value in it, but will no doubt be heading for the Google graveyard in 18-24months !

It says iOS, Windows, and Mac coming soon. Not ChromeOS though?
Post reply on HN