Live data from Hacker News

Flattr - I want to give you my money

conceitedcode.com

11–20 of 59 posts

Re: Flattr - I want to give you my money

#13
TipTheWeb handles this chicken-egg problem: http://tiptheweb.org/

Tips identify content just by URL de-coupling content attribution from the authors claiming their tips. This also us to work for tipping content on YouTube, Flickr, and GitHub, etc. without requiring the site to be directly integrated with TipTheWeb.

Re: Flattr - I want to give you my money

#14
post #6

Flattr is "failing" (failing as in, failing to gain substantial traction) because of lack of users. Notch (of Minecraft fame) used Flattr for a long time on his blog and he removed it because he made so very little off it, even though he has a very high traffic blog. They shot themselves in the foot when they launched the service: a "private beta". It was the most ridiculous idea ever , here is a service that NEEDS e…

In their defense, artificial scarcity can drive buzz for the product a lot, if done well. Also, a service that's not yet done can't afford to launch to the public, especially when there's money involved. Rather than think about launching in beta vs launching publicly, think about launching in beta vs launching much later. Which is the better choice?

I think they fit more into the Google Wave category than say the gmail. With gmail everyone could instantly gain value from having an account, with wave, people fired it up, had a quick look around and noticing none of their friends were there to talk to forgot about it.

Re: Flattr - I want to give you my money

#15
post #12

HN could allow us to put a flattr link in our submissions. I've done it for my site, crickets so far... There is a similar service for Bitcoin that I am thinking about adding. That might be more interesting.

To flattr the OP or HN? If it's the first one, that could be deeply controversial (see also: the squawk on Metafilter about the same thing).

Re: Flattr - I want to give you my money

#16
post #12

HN could allow us to put a flattr link in our submissions. I've done it for my site, crickets so far... There is a similar service for Bitcoin that I am thinking about adding. That might be more interesting.

To flattr the OP or HN? If it's the first one, that could be deeply controversial (see also: the squawk on Metafilter about the same thing).

I do it for the submitter on my site. I understand why some might think it is controversial, however. Actually, it might be best to keep it to comments only. -That's user created content. I'm going to consider that for my site. Thanks.

Re: Flattr - I want to give you my money

#17
post #11

Flattr is not rare on German sites and those who use it seem to be doing reasonably well if they are fairly well known. Tim Pritlove, for example, (a podcaster) is making close to 2.000€ per month (chart and German blogpost: http://tim.geekheim.de/2011/04/14/ein-jahr-flattr/ ).

The european/american thousands separator always manages to confuse me for a second: "Two Euros a month? Who gives a crap?"

Re: Flattr - I want to give you my money

#18

TipTheWeb handles this chicken-egg problem: http://tiptheweb.org/ Tips identify content just by URL de-coupling content attribution from the authors claiming their tips. This also us to work for tipping content on YouTube, Flickr, and GitHub, etc. without requiring the site to be directly integrated with TipTheWeb.

> This also us to work for tipping content on YouTube, Flickr, and GitHub, etc. without requiring the site to be directly integrated with TipTheWeb.

What happens if I tip someone whose video, photo, or code gets taken down?

Re: Flattr - I want to give you my money

#19

TipTheWeb handles this chicken-egg problem: http://tiptheweb.org/ Tips identify content just by URL de-coupling content attribution from the authors claiming their tips. This also us to work for tipping content on YouTube, Flickr, and GitHub, etc. without requiring the site to be directly integrated with TipTheWeb.

> This also us to work for tipping content on YouTube, Flickr, and GitHub, etc. without requiring the site to be directly integrated with TipTheWeb. What happens if I tip someone whose video, photo, or code gets taken down?

Content attribution happens at the time the Tip is made, so it will be there even if the content is taken down after a user makes a Tip for it.

Re: Flattr - I want to give you my money

#20
post #11

Flattr is not rare on German sites and those who use it seem to be doing reasonably well if they are fairly well known. Tim Pritlove, for example, (a podcaster) is making close to 2.000€ per month (chart and German blogpost: http://tim.geekheim.de/2011/04/14/ein-jahr-flattr/ ).

The european/american thousands separator always manages to confuse me for a second: "Two Euros a month? Who gives a crap?"

I hear a lot of people saying that. Interesting, however, is that I, as European, don't even think twice about it[1]. My brain must be wired to look at the context primarily.

Why that is, I can only take a stab at: I guess we see a lot more from you guys on the other side of the pond than you see from us. :)

[1] Comma overload -- my English teacher would kill me.

Post reply on HN