Live data from Hacker News

My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too

azumbrunnen.me

141–150 of 169 posts

Re: My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too

#142
post #4

I'm not sure why it took so long for people to recognize this. An overwhelming majority of chatbots I've used are utter rubbish and are better served through a regular interface (search, directory listing, etc). Everyone dreads call menus / phone trees - chatbots are largely the same except there are easier & better UX alternatives in an online medium.

I had to call UPS because of a wrong delivery state a few weeks ago. I ended about in their automated phone system where you don‘t anymore press numbers but rather say what you would like. There‘s never an option to talk to a human. I ended up googling and found out a secret keyword to talk to an agent who one can directly say after choosing a language. I never have been connected faster to a human when calling a lar…

Got rear-ended in France once, called the rental car company to report the problem (damaged car), turned out you had to speak to the automated system in French to get directed to someone to actually talk to. I don't speak French. There were no other options. So the guy that rear-ended my rental car actually had to help out with the call.. even that was problematic, he lived in France but wasn't a native, apparently his French wasn't quite good enough for the system. Hertz, that's not something you should have as your user interface at your Hertz office at an international airport.

Re: My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too

#143
post #71

My favorite chatbot experience lately has been support directing me to the chatbot, which then informs me that I am capable of resolving the issue of cancelling/refunding or making changes to my transaction. It just happens to be the case, that I ordered the wrong thing. Simple as that. As I travel to the appropriate link, there is none such ability or option. I relay the appropriate message to their customer service…

Can you please elaborate on Salesforce one-reply system? Never have used them but keen to understand how they do it better

Re: My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too

#144
post #8

I absolutely despise those pop-up "Can I help you" boxes on product websites (usually Intercom). It completely disrupts my flow as a reader in trying to understand the product. That attention disruption got so bad I blocked Intercom and their ilk via injected CSS rules. I really want to take it a step further and write a plug in to interface a chat bot with the human on the other end and waste their time so sites beg…

And I don't want to "Allow Notifications from X"

Re: My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too

#145
post #66

I am an engineer at a profitable chatbot company (HelloTars). I can't entirely agree with the points mentioned in this article. Yes, a chatbot is not ready to replace human support. However, there are other areas where they show good results. We have been helping customers with lead generation chatbots for the last four years. What we have learnt is customers would instead engage with a chatbot than filling up length…

> To summarize, no chatbots are not dead. They are only beginning. Yes, there will likely be more chatbots in the future. And yes, THEN they will be usable. But no, it's not a good user experience yet. If a website needs a chatbot they: - Didn't put enough effort in organizing the website - Don't want to spend money on real support - Hate their customers

> - Don't want to spend money on real support

Nothing wrong with this. You can say this about practically any company using software for anything. Not spending money on people is the point of enterprise software.

Re: My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too

#146
post #102
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, I just block cookies from ALL sites except the few that I need to log into. GDPR is mostly irrelevant to me for that reason. The unfortunate result is that the goddamn GDPR warnings keep popping up, because ironically, the way those websites remember that you either "accepted" or "denied" the tracking request is to leave a cookie, and I don't allow or want to allow that cookie. EDIT: Separately, there are many we…

>No, I just block cookies from ALL sites except the few that I need to log into. GDPR is mostly irrelevant to me for that reason. GDPR is about a lot more than just cookies. >By blocking the modal dialog boxes, I never actually "accepted", and therefore they never got my permission to track. Ha! Unfortunately they probably treat this as if you accepted the modal (which is against GDPR).

> Unfortunately they probably treat this as if you accepted

Sure, but they can't track me anyway :)

Re: My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too

#147
post #125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because the ChatBot squashes all those different pages and forms into one location. It takes the time and mental load of trying to locate features on the site or app off of me. Instead of navigating through 3 links to reach the form, having to search the newly loaded page each time, I answer 3 questions. In truth, I just type “ATM withdrawal limit” and the form begins, because it’s so obvious what I’m trying to do.

Once you’ve got something down to muscle memory it really doesn’t matter how it works so long as it stays the same, I guess. I feel like these things are a speed bump when I run into them though. I recently canceled a my service with a utility. Instead of a simple form to select a date to shut off service, provide a new mailing address, and a submit button, I had to go through this artificial “dialog” with a robot. W…

As an example, I just needed the routing number for my account to make a payment. I was like, “shit, where is that in the app again”, but had just made this comment, so I hit help, and typed “routing number”, and it immediately responded with the routing number in big bold letters. (https://imgur.com/a/raXEyO3)

The point is to eliminate the need to work to find stuff.

Re: My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too

#148
post #135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except the salesman turns out to be a bot with the IQ of a three year old.

Kind of like this? https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p083mv25

Good one :)

For a next version of this sketch they could borrow some inspiration here: https://darkpatterns.org/

Re: My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too

#149
post #63
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The only ones I really despise are the ones that pop open as soon as you open the page - I haven't even read the damned page title yet, so no , I would not like to ask any questions or tell you anything about my requirements! Just.. go away! Actually, the ones I really despise with a burning passion are the ones like above, but which follow you around the whole site like some kind of demented Clippy 2.0 - you close t…

Yep, It's not just Clippy, it's anything that I would want to dismiss and then it doesn't persist. https://coworker.com has this annoying banner at the moment advertising their global pass. Nice X to close. I refresh page and it's back. If I clear my cookies or my adblock causes a javascript error, then fair enough. Otherwise, persist my decisions please.

For that website, get a Chrome plugin called User Javascript and CSS and set it up to inject:

    #hello_banner { display:none !important; }
    .grecaptcha-badge { display: none !important; }
I know it's a lot of work to inspect the DOM and do this for every site but I just hate banners and popups that much, and very often multiple websites reuse the same banner code so my efforts start paying off after dealing with a few dozen.

Re: My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too

#150

Earlier quoted context omitted.

NoScript goes a long way to making the web usable again. Most of these crappy applets are embedded from 3rd party domains, so you can whitelist the primary domain and still block this junk. It's a bit of a pain, yes, but I can't imagine browsing without it.

UMatrix works good for this flow too

I really hope someone in the community is able to keep the project active, it's my favorite extension by far.
Post reply on HN