Live data from Hacker News

Nokia selected by NASA to build cellular network on the moon

reuters.com

31–40 of 224 posts

Re: Nokia selected by NASA to build cellular network on the moon

#31

If there is intelligent life somewhere out there, when they travel to space, I wonder if they also insist on operating technology that is at least one generation back, for the reason of "proven reliability"? I'd say probably yes. If we ever get a visit from them, that "shmux semiconductor" will be the old model...

5G base station/terminal power usage isn't very optimized yet.

Re: Nokia selected by NASA to build cellular network on the moon

#33

Does this mean the ITU is going to assign the moon a country code? I vote for +6666 (MOON). Who decides what parts of the moon get what area codes? Imagine how long it will take to get Orange to instal a landline in a crater!

I like it, but +66 is Thailand already.

It would probably get one of the available +87x or +88x codes. If they aren't just going to issue numbers from the home country.

Re: Nokia selected by NASA to build cellular network on the moon

#34

If there is intelligent life somewhere out there, when they travel to space, I wonder if they also insist on operating technology that is at least one generation back, for the reason of "proven reliability"? I'd say probably yes. If we ever get a visit from them, that "shmux semiconductor" will be the old model...

"Greetings humans! Our vessel has arrived to destroy your planet! Please wait a few months though because this is the old model that takes a while to charge up, sorry about that..."

Re: Nokia selected by NASA to build cellular network on the moon

#35
post #15

As usual, The Onion's take on this is fantastic: https://www.theonion.com/nasa-builds-4g-tower-on-moon-tastef...

I assumed it would be about the moon aliens protesting about the tower going in their backyard. NIMMBY: not in my moon back yard :)

Re: Nokia selected by NASA to build cellular network on the moon

#36
post #15

As usual, The Onion's take on this is fantastic: https://www.theonion.com/nasa-builds-4g-tower-on-moon-tastef...

Well done. That reminds me of one of those cell phone towers disguised as a tree I drive by quite often. It is in the middle of a very large, very flat plain. I don't think there is another tree within 10 miles of it.

Re: Nokia selected by NASA to build cellular network on the moon

#37
post #7

And so the legendary indestructibility of Nokia's phones shall be put to the test once more. The very first or two digits of any phone number on Earth are the country calling codes. We should add extra digits for a planetary calling code.

Almost all of them are taken but 999 is still free!

999 is the emergency number in the UK and a few other places. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/999_(emergency_telephone_numbe...

Re: Nokia selected by NASA to build cellular network on the moon

#38

Cool and all, but I'd settle for a cellular network in Wyoming.

I've been wanting to move to Wy, but I can't figure out what locations actually have decent internet. Looks like Casper has gigabit fiber? That's all I can tell so far.

In live in San Antonio and while you can get gigabit AT&T even Google Fiber (I can get either) many neighborhoods have 25-50 mbit max from AT&T so you get whatever your cable provider (Spectrum offers).

Re: Nokia selected by NASA to build cellular network on the moon

#39
Radiation environment on the moon is worse than in the LEO. Earth's magnetic field is not protecting in the Moon. It's unclear how much rad-hard they need if they don't use it for anything safety critical. Rad-hard 90nm SoC for 4G/LTE should be relatively straightforward. Or maybe they use redundancy and use already available few generation old chipsets.

Changes for thermal management and testing eats most of the budget.

Re: Nokia selected by NASA to build cellular network on the moon

#40
post #32

Watch Elon implement this as an OTA update to Starlink without breaking a sweat, while NASA burns billions just to prototype a model...

Are reddit's Elon worshippers leaking to HN?

You're confusing respect with worship. And he was clearly joking.
Post reply on HN