Live data from Hacker News

Slow map: Mapping Britain's intercity footpaths

bbc.com

11–20 of 56 posts

Re: Slow map: Mapping Britain's intercity footpaths

#11
Fantastic initiative and set up and presented in a nice, understated and sensible way.

I’m wondering if similar projects would work outside of the UK. As far as I know, the UK is pretty unique in the fact that basically all land is freely accessible by anyone, except when explicitly forbidden?

For example here in the Netherlands, basically anything that isn’t a public street is off limits, except when the owner of the land explicitly grants access.

Re: Slow map: Mapping Britain's intercity footpaths

#12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But look at how you get footpaths to be legally protected, and how you get them protected again after they're been forgotten, and how to protect new ones - using evidence from reputable archive sources like Ordnance Survey - that's how they argue these cases. You're showing me the result - I'm telling you how that gets achieved in practice. You can read more about it here from a relevant group https://www.ramblers.or…

Is there any chance that England and Wales will get the same "Right to Roam" as in Scotland?

Given that the government is currently busy trying to make trespass a criminal offence, I wouldn't bet on it any time soon.

Re: Slow map: Mapping Britain's intercity footpaths

#13
post #5

The project page: https://slowways.uk/ As they say, there are many paths in the UK but it can take a lot of research to find long routes that don't leave you on a busy road with no pavement. I hope this project is a success and can't wait to use it.

But where is the actual data? All that this site has is some photos, I find no maps.

"We are currently working on building a website that will host all of the routes and hope to launch that later this year."

Re: Slow map: Mapping Britain's intercity footpaths

#14

Fantastic initiative and set up and presented in a nice, understated and sensible way. I’m wondering if similar projects would work outside of the UK. As far as I know, the UK is pretty unique in the fact that basically all land is freely accessible by anyone, except when explicitly forbidden? For example here in the Netherlands, basically anything that isn’t a public street is off limits, except when the owner of th…

Scotland does have "Right to Roam" (as do a number of other countries):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_to_roam

You can, in general, walk/cycle to most places in Scotland although there are fairly sensible conditions:

https://www.scotways.com/faq/law-on-statutory-access-rights

https://www.outdooraccess-scotland.scot/

I'm in the process of walking the Munros and I'm careful to check with landowners about access during the deer stalking season - I've never had a landowner be anything other than completely helpful.

NB Walkhighlands is a superb site covering walks throughout Scotland, not just the Highlands:

https://www.walkhighlands.co.uk/

Heritage Paths is also good:

http://www.heritagepaths.co.uk

Re: Slow map: Mapping Britain's intercity footpaths

#15

Fantastic initiative and set up and presented in a nice, understated and sensible way. I’m wondering if similar projects would work outside of the UK. As far as I know, the UK is pretty unique in the fact that basically all land is freely accessible by anyone, except when explicitly forbidden? For example here in the Netherlands, basically anything that isn’t a public street is off limits, except when the owner of th…

England has a right to roam (https://www.gov.uk/right-of-way-open-access-land/use-your-ri...), but it's less strong than Scotland's (https://www.scotways.com/faq/law-on-statutory-access-rights).

Re: Slow map: Mapping Britain's intercity footpaths

#17
post #5

The project page: https://slowways.uk/ As they say, there are many paths in the UK but it can take a lot of research to find long routes that don't leave you on a busy road with no pavement. I hope this project is a success and can't wait to use it.

But where is the actual data? All that this site has is some photos, I find no maps.

I was going to ask how this is any different from the data that already exists in OpenStreetMap.

The [FAQ page] answers this:

> Slow Ways walking routes – drafted, tested, reviewed and verified by volunteers – suggest the best ways to get between neighbouring towns, cities and villages. Our mapping and routing will show a limited number of paths, making it easier to see and plan journeys.

— curation.

[FAQ page]: https://slowways.uk/frequently-asked-questions/

Re: Slow map: Mapping Britain's intercity footpaths

#18
This is great. When I was looking for my missing cat I discovered so many hidden trails in my borough that was just amazing. For example a gap between two residential homes I thought it leads to someone's garden but actually it was a quite long public footpath with signs of homeless people camping on it. I also found two abandoned properties that I wouldn't see in Google Maps. One of which was totally overgrown with bushes, weeds and someone even left a half of the car there. Then I found an article that the owner of the site was ordered to clear it, but that it seems has never happened. Cat returned a few days later.

Re: Slow map: Mapping Britain's intercity footpaths

#19
post #5

The project page: https://slowways.uk/ As they say, there are many paths in the UK but it can take a lot of research to find long routes that don't leave you on a busy road with no pavement. I hope this project is a success and can't wait to use it.

Pavement = sidewalks

Translating British for my fellow Americans. Carry on.

Re: Slow map: Mapping Britain's intercity footpaths

#20

This is great. When I was looking for my missing cat I discovered so many hidden trails in my borough that was just amazing. For example a gap between two residential homes I thought it leads to someone's garden but actually it was a quite long public footpath with signs of homeless people camping on it. I also found two abandoned properties that I wouldn't see in Google Maps. One of which was totally overgrown with…

I found OpenStreetMap invaluable for places to walk during the lockdown earlier this year - it has a lot of paths that aren't on OS maps at all.
Post reply on HN