Live data from Hacker News

Beware the Casual Polymath

applieddivinitystudies.com

21–30 of 123 posts

Re: Beware the Casual Polymath

#21

This seems much less about being casual or being a polymath and more about those who overestimate the value of their own input I’m leaving this comment only because I most often do not overestimate the value of my input and therefor don’t leave comments, but this seems the perfect place to deviate

You are a machine.

Tell me about pi and pie ...

Re: Beware the Casual Polymath

#22
post #6

I think the author/post neglects the most important reason for valuing generalists and learning from them. (Hyper)specialists have a hard time understanding context outside their narrow domains, and filtering the relevance of their own specialization to a situation. Having access to a highly sophisticated hammer, everything looks like a nail through their lens. Consequently, there have a hard time communicating with…

> Generalists are typically far better at motivating the relevance of a problem/situation and filtering out the important details from the unimportant.

Couldn't agree more.

John von Neumann is a perfect example. His colleagues would often lament his unwillingness to adopt a narrow specialty, but I think it was his wide range that allowed him to maintain the passion that made him so effective. [1]

[1] http://paulgraham.com/genius.html

Re: Beware the Casual Polymath

#23

This seems much less about being casual or being a polymath and more about those who overestimate the value of their own input I’m leaving this comment only because I most often do not overestimate the value of my input and therefor don’t leave comments, but this seems the perfect place to deviate

Re-read the article until you hit the header: "Self-Reinforcing Churn"

Think about what you have recently read and dump it!

Re: Beware the Casual Polymath

#26
Statistically, the number of true polymaths has probably risen, but against total world capability to communicate, I suspect it has risen slower than the pace of n^2 connectedness, and the consequent ability to speak rubbish at large, believably.

Re: Beware the Casual Polymath

#28

Taking this back to the startup world, I find that the enjoyable wicked problem of cross-disciplinary engineering in a startup environment is that you get to build things in areas in which you have only generalist knowledge. The task of the founding team is to optimize not only the process of discovery within those specific domains but also to ensure the development and management the team, providing a correct degree…

Tell me what: "e to the i pi minus one equals zero" might mean.

lol

Re: Beware the Casual Polymath

#30

In life everyone is pushed to have an opinion on everything. On the internet any casual comment about anything is up for the attack “oh so now you claim to be an expert on X do you, well let me put you in your place...”. > “ The Twitter account you followed to understand politics now seems more focused on their mindfulness practice. ” What a "hellscape" it is when you’re reminded that other people are people and not…

lol
Post reply on HN