Live data from Hacker News

The Woolworths Poltergeist

literaryreview.co.uk

11–20 of 23 posts

Re: The Woolworths Poltergeist

#11
post #10

> "It started with the loss of religious faith in the 19th century and peaked in the late 1930s, a period of dislocating social change and mass bereavement following one war, with another seemingly imminent." It is hard to overstate this point. From our relatively comfortable vantage point, it can be hard to fully appreciate the deep psychological impact that the unprecedented loss of life must have had on so many fo…

The school my son went to in Edinburgh has a large war memorial in the middle of the playground in front of their imposing main building - 70 names on it from WW1 and WW2.

Re: The Woolworths Poltergeist

#12
post #10

> "It started with the loss of religious faith in the 19th century and peaked in the late 1930s, a period of dislocating social change and mass bereavement following one war, with another seemingly imminent." It is hard to overstate this point. From our relatively comfortable vantage point, it can be hard to fully appreciate the deep psychological impact that the unprecedented loss of life must have had on so many fo…

[deleted]

Re: The Woolworths Poltergeist

#17
post #10

> "It started with the loss of religious faith in the 19th century and peaked in the late 1930s, a period of dislocating social change and mass bereavement following one war, with another seemingly imminent." It is hard to overstate this point. From our relatively comfortable vantage point, it can be hard to fully appreciate the deep psychological impact that the unprecedented loss of life must have had on so many fo…

Thank you for the Sir Aurthur Conan Doyle quote. I my mind, I heard it spoken as if by Sherlock Holmes himself.

Re: The Woolworths Poltergeist

#18
post #6
post #2

We laugh at people of the past who believed stupid things, yet here we are in 2020 with so many believers of flat earth, pizza gate, vaccine dangers, and pandemic hoaxes. A hundred years from now it will be no different, but at least we'll finally have flying cars.

Well count me as a guilty one :). Bought a small cozy place in Wales a few years back. Whenever I visited, I would often experience the usual - cupboard doors flapping open or shut for no reason, cold bursts of air, lights flickering, you get it. I'm sure one could explain it perhaps with an environmental variable such as the temperature or wind or the levelling of the foundations. My female friends would actually ex…

It is interesting to analyse this in lieu of metaphysics of Kant and later, Schoepenhauer. I won't say I master the subject addressed by these philosophers. Far from it, I only scratched the surface and am just an amateur of the art.

But regarding the world within itself, or the world outside of human perception, there might not even be distiction between things we perceive so clearly as things in themselves, like the river bed and water, or air and trees.

All we perceive is a byproduct of experience and natural preconception of concepts like time and space. It doesn't mean, however, that what we perceive is false. It serves a orientation purpose and helps us guide ourselves in this world towards maximizing quality.

In this respect, paranormal activities might well be explained by outside phonomena. But just as separating what we normally perceive from what they really are has no practical purpose for us as humans (such is human experience, it imbues everything with human perception), observing such activities under the pure branch of rational observation misses entirely the point.

It doesn't really matter if those ghosts were real. Its effects were real not only in your psyche but also in the world (it evoked emotions in you that led you to selling the house). In this particular human aspect, they were subjectively quite real.

Re: The Woolworths Poltergeist

#19

> Alma was hiding trinkets in her vagina and shooting them out via some kind of muscular spasm. Really?

It smacks a little of "Well, we don't know how vaginas work, the only thing we know is they're powerful and mysterious and a little bit scary." That kind of superstitious ignorance is surprisingly big, but then I got to "he learned that several of the things she reported were outright premeditated fraud, but he wouldn't dismiss the other parts of her claim." Clearly not a guy used to meticulous reasoning.

Re: The Woolworths Poltergeist

#20
post #4
post #2

We laugh at people of the past who believed stupid things, yet here we are in 2020 with so many believers of flat earth, pizza gate, vaccine dangers, and pandemic hoaxes. A hundred years from now it will be no different, but at least we'll finally have flying cars.

The future will be no different if people continue to believe or dismiss theories without first confronting the arguments and evidence that validates or invalidates them (in a healthy marketplace of ideas). I never subscribed to flat earth theory, but did I learn about it and read the subsequent material confronting it? Yes. It wasn't a waste of time because it served as a valuable mental exercise that helped me impr…

But what do you do now that conspiracy theories are generated and popularized faster than you can possibly debunk? You kind of have to accept that you can't look at them all, and in that case do you live in a state of not knowing, even when there's an obvious assumption about a lot of them?
Post reply on HN