Live data from Hacker News

Tesla dissolves its PR department

electrek.co

41–50 of 139 posts

Re: Tesla dissolves its PR department

#41
post #40

Are we just going to ignore that they have an 'External Relations' department? And that their own jobs board has positions posted two weeks ago for "Marketing & Communications", PR positions all across China, and for "Community Relations Partner"? This "news" is pure fabrication. https://www.tesla.com/careers/search#/?keyword=Communication...

All of those are in China except for the content specialist.

Re: Tesla dissolves its PR department

#42
post #40

Are we just going to ignore that they have an 'External Relations' department? And that their own jobs board has positions posted two weeks ago for "Marketing & Communications", PR positions all across China, and for "Community Relations Partner"? This "news" is pure fabrication. https://www.tesla.com/careers/search#/?keyword=Communication...

All of those are in China except for the content specialist.

Not for the first one and the latter, only the middle.

Re: Tesla dissolves its PR department

#43

"There are obviously still people arranging test-drive promotions for YouTubers but their role isn’t in a traditional public relations capacity." Remember when people used to say Tesla doesn't do marketing? The last few years of Tesla has been quite sobering for myself as I had my worldview flipped upside down. With Elon/Tesla, as more information has come out with time, it's been disenchanting. I was sold a capitali…

What new information has disenchanted you?

Full disclaimer: happy Tesla owner here.

Re: Tesla dissolves its PR department

#45

"There are obviously still people arranging test-drive promotions for YouTubers but their role isn’t in a traditional public relations capacity." Remember when people used to say Tesla doesn't do marketing? The last few years of Tesla has been quite sobering for myself as I had my worldview flipped upside down. With Elon/Tesla, as more information has come out with time, it's been disenchanting. I was sold a capitali…

I get that Elon is controversial and puts a lot of bull out there. And yet, without him, electric cars would still be in their infancy and rockets would not be landing themselves. These technologies do not develop themselves and market niches do not magically get filled. Many things happen in the world because a single wealthy person wants them to happen. My recommendation is not put too much stock in the future promises, but don't diminish the actual accomplishments, which are impressive by themselves. I think there are personal lessons to be gained too, about the power of picking a stretch goal that you know is within your means to achieve, then dedicating yourself to achieving it. Being an egomaniac is no requirement and probably holds him back. We may not be working on the billionaire problem space, but our own goals can be equally lofty.

Re: Tesla dissolves its PR department

#46
post #40

Are we just going to ignore that they have an 'External Relations' department? And that their own jobs board has positions posted two weeks ago for "Marketing & Communications", PR positions all across China, and for "Community Relations Partner"? This "news" is pure fabrication. https://www.tesla.com/careers/search#/?keyword=Communication...

Sounds like something a PR department would do.

Re: Tesla dissolves its PR department

#48
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1. It's a skill that needs practice and most professionals are not trained in. 2. PR is an entryway for collecting and managing stakeholder questions that might warrant future board level action (in communication). 3. PR is usually close to the board and has it's own dynamic with marketing being further down the chain. Elon dismantling PR makes sense. Probably they rubbed him the wrong way too often. Why bother.

But so what good does a PR team do. Maybe for Tesla specifically not much. It's like how Border Cafe in Harvard Square used to be - always so busy with hour+ waits that there is no need to bother with reservations.

For a regular large sized company there are press pieces written every day that want an informative quote, shareholders cold-mailing you, customers trying all kinds of angles except the regular ones to get in touch, TV-shows that want your CEO on. All this gets managed in a way that at least suggests some uniformity in what you proclaim externally. Sure, there's domains that overlap PR / (internal) communication and marketing but generally they are treated as different tasks and organised as such.

TL;DR - They manage one single external voice. There's value in that. As other point out, Musk is a communications study in and of himself.

Re: Tesla dissolves its PR department

#50
post #17

Thea reasons PR department exists because you have a PR problem. Not having the problem is better.

"A Tesla rep just called me racial slur.". Tweet goes viral.

There you go, do you need a PR deparment now? If it's your CEO doing that job, that's a bad use of the CEO's time.

Post reply on HN