Live data from Hacker News

Google TV

tv.google

211–220 of 448 posts

Re: Google TV

#211

Yet another Google product that will be abandoned within 2 years. Don't buy the hype.

Why the Google hate in this case? I'm in love with my chromecast I've had for the past 6 years with no issues, and this seems like a great upgrade for less than I paid.

Re: Google TV

#212
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My Nvidia Shield TV from 2015 is still doing great

That's the crapshoot, isn't it. Would you have been able to know in 2015 that the Nvidia product was going to be supported, but the Logitech one would be abandoned? Real question actually. I doubt it, but that's a weakly held opinion.

Has logitech ever been been good at updates in general? Why would a peripheral company even be good at home entertainment? I'd agree that Nvidia's connection to home entertainment is just as vague, but they still sound much more reliable to me than Logitech.

And as much as people love bringing up Google deprecating stuff, I still trust them far more on updating this than any outside company.

Re: Google TV

#213

Goodness me, this is an exemplary example of the type of website that I just cannot abide. Style over content, and the presentation just plain getting in the way of the information, to the point that the user ends up leaving rather than finding out what the site is attempting to convey. Awful. Just awful.

I am partially an UI/UX designer and it took me a minute to figure out I have to scroll...

Re: Google TV

#214

Oh Google. So this is a reskin and rebrand of Android TV, launching for the first time on the new "Chromecast with Google TV". Not to be confused with a different Google TV from 10 years ago. It's unclear if they are sunsetting Android TV or supporting 2 branches of Android based TV interfaces. Side note, I have a TV with Android TV and it is chock-full-o-bugs. Only in the Google-verse.

But at 50$, it's a really decent price point for getting a smart tv + controller experience.

Re: Google TV

#215

I owned the Logitech Google TV which I bought for about $300 early in its lifespan. After about a year they shipped some really bad updates to it that made it so slow that it was essentially unuseable and removed several key features, and then never shipped another update to it again. Logitech and Google both lost interest in it and after not long all of the apps like Netflix and even Google's own Youtube stopped wor…

As far as I understand, a second generation Apple TV can't even play Youtube videos.

I thought that it didn't play certain resolution YouTube, as even the newer generations only just got 4k support for due to codec issues?

Re: Google TV

#216
I think the practice of killing off streaming services and projects that aren't "core" is a huge liability for Google. Why should I invest time and money in a service or product that might be killed off in a few years?

We need to reward companies that keep things alive for longer. I got an iPhone recently (over a somewhat cheaper Android) precisely because Apple provides OS updates for longer than any other smartphone maker. Sometimes over 5 years.

Especially as tech products have started to somewhat plateau in functionality, I value longevity over features or performance.

Re: Google TV

#217
post #47

Almost a 1:1 copy of the Apple TV app just with a worse copy of website https://www.apple.com/apple-tv-app , not new but ever so disappointing Google adds so little new to ideas they decide to adopt

Apple's website scrolls much more smoothly for me as well (although that might be since I'm using Safari).

The tv page was fine for me but the iphone and ipad pages are horrendous. I don't know why there is this trend in web design to make the page a video except you have to scroll to progress it.

Re: Google TV

#218

Yet another Google product that will be abandoned within 2 years. Don't buy the hype.

Why the Google hate in this case? I'm in love with my chromecast I've had for the past 6 years with no issues, and this seems like a great upgrade for less than I paid.

Chromecast is the only google media receiver that survived. Over the last few years we have had:

* Google TV (A different product to this Google TV) * Nexus Q * Android TV * Youtube TV * Probably 10 other things that started and shut down without anyone noticing.

Re: Google TV

#219
post #123

This might be the wrong place to complain about this issue. But "smart" TVs need to be replaced with "dumb TV + set top box" bundles. As it is now, the best panels are obsolete after a year.

Gotta disagree with this, I'm very happy with the integrated Roku in my TCL TV. And the TV still has HDMI ports, so I don't see how it's obsolete if I ever want to stop using the Roku.

Depends on the implementation. My parents samsung tv has become unbearably slow and a factory reset doesn't fix it. I assume updates are to blame. Others are also reporting that their smart tv started showing adverts after years of owning it.

Since the panel is expensive and the brains are cheap, it makes more sense to have them split.

Re: Google TV

#220

Almost a 1:1 copy of the Apple TV app just with a worse copy of website https://www.apple.com/apple-tv-app , not new but ever so disappointing Google adds so little new to ideas they decide to adopt

Hopefully they don't copy the Apple TV app's bugginess and unreliability too. While the Apple TV+ content is great, getting there isn't.
Post reply on HN