Live data from Hacker News

Tables: Tracking work for teams

blog.google

121–130 of 375 posts

Re: Tables: Tracking work for teams

#121

What a useful app. Reminds me of Airtable in some ways. I enjoy a good flexible table app any day. We're all tired of the obligatory "I wonder how long before Google deprecates this...;)" but I wonder if Google would get better adoption if they explicitly published what would be needed for them not to drop the product... 1M monthly users? 3M? ...xM? or that when a project actually reaches that point.

The only way to rebuild credibility is to do the right thing repeatedly for a long period of time. Google saying “if we get X users we won’t cancel it” both sounds like a hostage note, and doesn’t matter because we fundamentally don’t trust Google . Without that trust, it doesn’t matter why they say, since it won’t be believed.

If they say they need X users to not cancel something, that does nothing for me, even if I trust them. I will not sign up until it already hits that point, because before then, it's practically guaranteed to be canceled. And I bet at least X users would share my opinion.

Re: Tables: Tracking work for teams

#123
I see a lot of comments about people who are worried that Google might shutdown the service entirely and I agree with your concerns. The last months we have seen a lot of giants building their own database spreadsheet like hybrid, Google Tables, Microsoft Lists and Amazon Honeycode. Tools like these contain your most important data and you want to have freedom, security and independence as they can be an important part of your business.

Because of these reasons I started Baserow (https://baserow.io), which is an open source (https://gitlab.com/bramw/baserow) alternative to Airtable and the listed tools above. It is still in an early phase, but every week new features are implemented.

Some unique points:

- Unlimited rows.

- Open source, released under the MIT license.

- Uses popular frameworks like Django and Nuxt.js

- Uses PostgreSQL as database backend.

- It can be self hosted.

- You can have many rows per table, 100k+.

- Headless and API first.

- Supports plugins.

Re: Tables: Tracking work for teams

#125

PRESS RELEASE Sept 22, 2021. Google Announces that Google Tables will be sunset and all users will have to migrate away by Sept 23, 2021. "Google Tables was a great experiment but we're migrating to Google Tracker - a better version of Google Tables designed for power users." said Dep Re. Kated, VP of Engineering at Google. Google Tables has no migration tool or system for users to export their data angering some use…

[deleted]

Re: Tables: Tracking work for teams

#126
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This comment seems to top any HN post regarding a google product launch so reliably that perhaps there should be a bot which automatically pins it to the top.

A more useful bot would be one that finds and deletes that inevitably-posted noise.

It's not noise, it's a valid market signal. So I'll side with automatically appending one such comment in every Google thread until their behavior visibly changes.

Re: Tables: Tracking work for teams

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A more useful bot would be one that finds and deletes that inevitably-posted noise.

It's not noise, it's a valid market signal. So I'll side with automatically appending one such comment in every Google thread until their behavior visibly changes.

> It's not noise

In terms of HN’s overt purpose, it is.

> it's a valid market signal

Every expression of anyone's reaction to a brand is “valid market signal” on the level that that is true of this, but that doesn't stop most of that from being noise in an HN comment thread.

> So I'll side with automatically appending one such comment in every Google thread until their behavior visibly changes.

Such an automated comment would still be noise, but would have less of excuse of being a valid market signal than comments posted organically, even if that was an excuse (which it's not.)

Re: Tables: Tracking work for teams

#128

PRESS RELEASE Sept 22, 2021. Google Announces that Google Tables will be sunset and all users will have to migrate away by Sept 23, 2021. "Google Tables was a great experiment but we're migrating to Google Tracker - a better version of Google Tables designed for power users." said Dep Re. Kated, VP of Engineering at Google. Google Tables has no migration tool or system for users to export their data angering some use…

This is a bit of an over-used joke.

Given this is explicitly being launched under "Area 120", "Google's workshop for experimental products", I think it's fair to let them ship things, try things out, see what works, and close what doesn't.

Re: Tables: Tracking work for teams

#129
Think Google's obsession with machine learning has got out of control.

Looking at some of the other announcements on their blog, there's no way that an actual human either wrote those headlines or came up with the product ideas in the first place:

* Fundo: a virtual experiences platform for creators

* Shoploop: an entertaining new way to shop online

* AdLingo Ads Builder turns an ad into a conversation

* GameSnacks brings quick, casual games to any device

Has anyone been round to their offices recently to see if they're okay?

Re: Tables: Tracking work for teams

#130

PRESS RELEASE Sept 22, 2021. Google Announces that Google Tables will be sunset and all users will have to migrate away by Sept 23, 2021. "Google Tables was a great experiment but we're migrating to Google Tracker - a better version of Google Tables designed for power users." said Dep Re. Kated, VP of Engineering at Google. Google Tables has no migration tool or system for users to export their data angering some use…

This is a bit of an over-used joke. Given this is explicitly being launched under "Area 120", "Google's workshop for experimental products", I think it's fair to let them ship things, try things out, see what works, and close what doesn't.

Fair point, but why should anyone bother investing time and effort into using the thing if it's just an experiment?

Certainly not going to shift my team or multiple teams onto it if I can't trust it's going to be there tomorrow.

Post reply on HN