Live data from Hacker News

Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

luketully.ca

251–260 of 286 posts

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#251

The title and initial blurb of the article makes it sound like the rep tried to somehow disguise the cost or downplay it. But if you read the transcript, it's the exact opposite. The rep warned them the repair would cost more than a replacement before he even quoted them a price, and tried multiple times to explain why. He acted completely professionally, and the situation itself is totally unremarkable too.

I suppose the tone is open to interpretation, but I didn't try and mischaracterize the interaction. Both of us were incredulous as to the responses we were getting. When asking the same questions in a store, especially before agreeing to anything, I'd expect and have received clear answers or documents that do that.

Likewise, though I didn't mention this in the post, the first few emails Joe sent were not quotes, but payment requests with no further detail as to what was happening. I've gone ahead and updated the post.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#252

Had the same issue with delamination and because they admitted to it being their fault, took it to an Apple store just to see what they'll say. They said that it is a known defect but, wait for it, not for my model and so in my case it's my own fault by default. The person literally said yes it's delaminating but it's a different type of delamination. There was another comical scene involving googling by the employee…

The first time I experienced this, I was travelling through the U.S in 2018, in what seems like a similar event. I almost didn't get them to agree to do it, but it was up to their discretion and they obliged. However, the kicker was that they had to mail it away and it'd be gone for at least a week. I tried numerous Apple stores on our way up through California. Some said they did do MB repairs in store, but their hands were tied, they'd have to mail it away. Insane.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#253

I'm not sure what's newsworthy, here. This is quite typical of any place, that both sells and repairs stuff. The cost of repair is calculated to be just below, or at, the cost of replacement. It's unusual, but not unheard-of, to have it more than the cost of replacement. I've encountered this with TVs, phones, VCRs, stereos, non-Apple computers, cars, and I have heard stories of this applying to buildings and homes,…

I agree, but would suggest that it's newsworthy simply by virtue of it not being unusual (as well as the current holes Apple seems to be digging deeper into). Everyone will read the post with a different set of eyes, so there could be any facet that stands out to someone. One of those is that they seem quite happy to do a specific repair as long as it's under warranty, and will replace literally every major component multiple times before replacing the computer. I've also updated the post with a reference to a previous repair bill that was covered under warranty.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#254
post #99

For what is worth, I had an iMac 27" out of warranty and Apple replaced the screen for free. It had started having an issue (condensation) after 3-4 years of use and apparently the part number was from a run that could display was issue and had free repair even if out of warranty. The iMac cost like $3500 (corresponding local price), and the repair part was listed as costing $750 but given for free. Another good expe…

I think that's worth something. That's what I was generally happy with around the same time, and tried to emphasize that in the post. Buying an Apple product generally meant that you didn't need to worry, and hopefully you'd get some help for that investment when something did go wrong. Though I would say that I've never had a completely out-of-warranty major repair done. Ironically, the only out-of-warranty repair I had was when I ripped the SATA cable in my 2009 MBP. They sold me a new one and I was on my way.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#255

This is not surprising at all, the retina screen is one of the most expensive parts of the laptop. Lots of household appliances are similar to this too. If you have to repair one of the main parts of a washing machine or a dishwasher a new one will be a cheaper option. Same for a car, a friend of mine flooded his engine by driving through water that was higher than expected. His insurance company just wrote the car o…

I've updated the post with a screenshot of a previous in-warranty repair bill that indicates the screen cost around ~$500 CAD. Even the logic board and screen came out to around ~$1100, which is largely the basis for the surprising numbers.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#256
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Been a long time since I havent used apple devices (for unrelated reasons) this sounds so different from how they used to be.

Agree, about 7 years ago I spilt liquid on my MacBook Pro. They let me off the repair costs (significant, new motherboard etc..), just said be a bit more careful. Have recounted this story many times since, sad to hear things may have changed.

It's one thing for Apple's product quality (or quality control) to be less now that Steve Jobs is no longer with us. But it's another thing for customer-hostile dark patterns to become Apple's norm. :/ (I was subjected to the worst customer support experience of my life with the #KeyboardGate defect.)

Jobs was one of a kind.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#257

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Damn, what a rip-off. Why not stop giving them your money and stop buying any more of their products and services? Hit them where it hurts, their sales and bottom line. Just complaining about it doesn't get you very far as long as you still keep shoving money in their pocket. These days there are plenty of quality alternatives that are not Apple and lowering their sales should send a clear message to their board.

It will send a message but I'm not sure it's clear at all. I always see the suggestion to vote with your wallet but how does it even work with a product with usable lifecycle of 5 or even 10 years? By the end of 2025 Apple will see a sales slowdown over the past few years. At that point I'm not sure it's even possible to pinpoint specific reasons, like "customer couldn't replace keycap on a 2017 model computer" which…

If they quoted me 700 pounds to fix one key on a laptop, I wouldn't care about what the accountants think.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#258

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s not that support has changed, it’s the butterfly keyboard. You can’t replace keys with butterfly keyboard, the whole thing has to.

It's still insane that parts + labor costs £700 for a keyboard. I bet the part costs £70. I highly doubt labor could be reasonable valued at £630. Edit: currency is not American

>parts + labor costs £700 for a keyboard. I bet the part costs £70.

Lol, why? I have expensive keyboards and they are nowhere near that much for a single key. Is there any other keyboard on the planet that has such expensive keys (except maybe that one with OLEDs on every key)?

What are they sprinkling these things with to make people parrot such tripe?

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#259
post #135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For these rasons I use two phones. Apple for banking and communications involving personal data and Android for Gmail, music and ebooks.

Which one do you use the calls/texts?

Iphone for my family, Android for everyone else.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#260
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I broke the screen on a new Macbook 2 years ago, days after buying it. It was entirely my own fault so not covered by warrantee. I called Apple support and was told £800. Since I bought it with an Amex card, it was covered on that insurance, so I made an appointment to get it replaced. I went to the Apple store and was given a formal quote of £645 parts + labour. They went off to get the paperwork and were gone for a…

Huh? Instead of charging you the cost of a repair, for that new unit, they just did a swap for you free of charge?

This happens with automotive manufactures.

Vehicle breaks, the part or component that fixes it is unavailable/backordered/allocated for months+.

Manufacturers will offer to buy back the vehicle, at original sale price, rather than force you to wait (and relieving them from having to provide a loaner/rental).

Post reply on HN