Live data from Hacker News

Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

luketully.ca

121–130 of 286 posts

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#121

I can't wrap my head around Apple customers, most of the people I know that use mainly Apple products had a surprisingly amount of major issues with them but continued to buy Apple stuff only, it's like an addiction.. For example screen stopped working in a 3-year MacBook so what did the guy do? Bought new one because fixing was too expensive. Another one had a problem with the keyboard in MacBook which is one of the…

For many people, the hardware is simply a container for the software. If you prefer Apple's operating system, then there's unfortunately little choice, except perhaps Hackintosh.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#122

the right to repair movement is fascinating because it has no political alignment (it includes city folk + farmers, for example), has passed legislation in a lot of states, and implicitly comes with a bunch of other digital rights (because repair is power) it's also easy to understand -- there's no generation gap. Unlike privacy, the harms are immediate and most people have experienced them. repair.org is IMO doing a…

Unfortunately, going by Louis Rossmann's latest video, the right to repair means nothing if you don't have access to the parts you need to fix Apple products. And of late, Apple have been preventing their suppliers from selling parts to third parties.

The notion of ip is so deeply ingrained in the US, that I doubt you'll see the kind of Chinese bazaar that you really need. The US will only adapt when China gets significantly ahead.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#123
post #74

I saw a video by Louis Rossman the other day that's relevant to this. He owns an independent repair shop that repairs Apple products, and he said that Apple has basically won the fight by locking down their supply chain. Independent repair stores now cannot get Apple parts anywhere, so your only repair option in many cases is to take the thing to Apple and pay the predictably just-below-used price to get it repaired.…

You can mail a mac to Rossman's company and they'll work for P+L without the Apple upsell woo. Contact is on the about link above.

What does "work for P+L" mean?

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#124
About 4-5 years ago, my MacBook Pro's trackpad would randomly stop working and I would have to restart my laptop a few times to get it working again. Sometimes it would work for a few hours, sometimes a few minutes. I also dual-booted Linux at the time and the funny thing is the trackpad never had an issue under Linux. After quite a bit of researching, it led me to believe that the ribbon cable connecting the trackpad to the motherboard was faulty due to macOS never trying to reconnect to the trackpad if it loses a connection for even just a moment.

I brought it to the Apple store and explained that I had tried everything possible to resolve the issue without opening up the laptop myself, such as resetting NVRAM, completely reinstalling macOS completely, etc. I explained that I think that the ribbon cable is simply faulty and that it probably just needed a replacement. The Genius said that they're going to bring it in the back to do every single one of the things I mentioned that I already did.

I come back 4 hours later to pickup my laptop and they tell me that the issue is the motherboard and that replacing said board would cost $800. I asked how they determined it was the motherboard and not simply a faulty ribbon cable to the trackpad, but they wouldn't answer the question directly. After requesting their superior and restating my question a few more times, they told me that they don't have access to replacement ribbon cables and that my only option was a motherboard replacement, which itself would take about a week because they needed to order the board. That was enough for me to take my laptop and leave, even though they still didn't answer the actual question of how they determined what the actual issue was or even confirm my hunch that the issue was with the ribbon cable.

I bought a $5 replacement cable from Amazon, took about 10 minutes to swap it out using an iFixIt tutorial, and I'm still using that laptop as my main machine years later. In other words, they spent 4 hours to quote me an $800 fix that would take about a week to be done for something that was actually only a $5 fix that would take no more than 30 minutes. I've been hesitating to buy a new laptop for years because of that experience as well as the downhill quality of MacBooks as of late, such as the keyboard (although fixed now), touch bar, initial Catalina bugginess, etc.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#125

I can't wrap my head around Apple customers, most of the people I know that use mainly Apple products had a surprisingly amount of major issues with them but continued to buy Apple stuff only, it's like an addiction.. For example screen stopped working in a 3-year MacBook so what did the guy do? Bought new one because fixing was too expensive. Another one had a problem with the keyboard in MacBook which is one of the…

The answer to "why do people spend so much on Apple hardware?" used to be that they would offer fast easy and sometimes free repairs and replacements at their genius bar stores even when the product was out of warranty. I guess those days are over?

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#126

I can't wrap my head around Apple customers, most of the people I know that use mainly Apple products had a surprisingly amount of major issues with them but continued to buy Apple stuff only, it's like an addiction.. For example screen stopped working in a 3-year MacBook so what did the guy do? Bought new one because fixing was too expensive. Another one had a problem with the keyboard in MacBook which is one of the…

FWIW, I have owned _a lot_ of Apple products over the past decade. They have been almost universally reliable and overall pretty great to use. I _did_ have to send my 2018 MacBook Pro in for the dreaded & common keyboard repair. We also have a 2014 MacBook Pro that recently has had its battery inflate, but that was after years of service.

The keyboard thing was a real (and sucky) problem that Apple should not have let go on as long as they did. But the very small number of problems I've had through the years of using Macs, iPhones, iPads, Apple Watches, AirPods, iPods, etc. gives me an overall good impression of their products.

Apple's customer satisfaction rating is industry-leading: https://www.theacsi.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=ar...

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#127
post #123
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can mail a mac to Rossman's company and they'll work for P+L without the Apple upsell woo. Contact is on the about link above.

What does "work for P+L" mean?

Parts and labour cost

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#128
post #123
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can mail a mac to Rossman's company and they'll work for P+L without the Apple upsell woo. Contact is on the about link above.

What does "work for P+L" mean?

the cost of parts and labour.

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#129

They’ve also quoted me more than a whole new pair to repair some AirPods Pro that I accidentally washed in the laundry. They didn’t tell me that was the case when I was on the phone with them. Apple uses a lot of customer hostile behaviors nowadays. Recently: * I canceled the Apple TV+ year trial that came with my iPhone. While, I believe, they require other apps to allow access until the trial ends, they ended my ac…

Curious what benefit you get from using Apple Music compared to any other streaming music service?

Re: Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement

#130

I wonder if we should be surprised at this. Modern devices (phones and laptops) are designed to be small and cheap to produce in bulk in countries with cheap labour. Very few people will buy a more expensive, larger device that might be easier to repair or extend in a few years time. Doing bespoke repairs in high labour cost countries is always expensive. More so when devices are small. It's probably cheaper to get a…

That a repair of a modern device can be expensive is one thing, but here they charged more than the machines worth for the replacement part. That is just silly. The quoted labor costs were 150, which is still a lot but reasonable. But more than a few hundreds for a new screen sounds off.
Post reply on HN