Live data from Hacker News

'You're Not Allowed to Film': The Fight to Control Who Reports from Portland

reason.com

1–10 of 325 posts

Re: 'You're Not Allowed to Film': The Fight to Control Who Reports from Portland

#3
This is vital to understand for anyone who thinks they know what's going on at Portland, and - on a broader scale - most current events. There is a massive polarization of who consumes which facts, and this is simply an encoding of that: a drip-feed of exactly what one group of people wish to see.

Re: 'You're Not Allowed to Film': The Fight to Control Who Reports from Portland

#4
post #2

Interview with the same journalist: DarkHorse Podcast with Nancy Rommelmann and Bret Weinstein [1]. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfT_APUnp30

Bret, notably, lives in Portland, and has been making direct observations about these events for a while.

Re: 'You're Not Allowed to Film': The Fight to Control Who Reports from Portland

#5
Having done a fair share of media work on and in German protests myself: the biggest problem is that video evidence can and will be used by cops to go after activists - and that includes material from way outside a riot scene, given that police also look for such tiny details as shoes to (attempt to) identify people. The people at such events have something to lose: careers, families, friendships, years behind bars.

In contrast, in countries like Turkey, Belarus or other dictatorships, where the fear is getting killed regardless of protests, the situation is different - people on these protests want their faces to become public so that they cannot be "disappeared".

Re: 'You're Not Allowed to Film': The Fight to Control Who Reports from Portland

#6
If you spend any time on the Portland subreddit, you'll see plenty of stories and comments about how the city is just fine, and only Trump fans with an agenda push a "rioting and burning narrative". It's amazing watching hypocritical narrative control in action. These are the same people pushing for police body cameras.

Re: 'You're Not Allowed to Film': The Fight to Control Who Reports from Portland

#7

Having done a fair share of media work on and in German protests myself: the biggest problem is that video evidence can and will be used by cops to go after activists - and that includes material from way outside a riot scene, given that police also look for such tiny details as shoes to (attempt to) identify people. The people at such events have something to lose: careers, families, friendships, years behind bars.…

Go after them for what? Are they doing something illegal?

Re: 'You're Not Allowed to Film': The Fight to Control Who Reports from Portland

#8
This isn't just limited to Portland but is becoming a general aspect of these protests now, e.g. here[1] was DC last night where a Washington Post reporter was hounded out of the protest and then followed by "minders" to prevent his return.

Protesters are now blocking media from filming their demonstration, shining lights into a reporter’s face, blocking shots with fans umbrellas and following like “minders” ... “We have our press we know and trust,” this young woman says

[1] https://twitter.com/KunkleFredrick/status/130241105817530777...

Re: 'You're Not Allowed to Film': The Fight to Control Who Reports from Portland

#9

Having done a fair share of media work on and in German protests myself: the biggest problem is that video evidence can and will be used by cops to go after activists - and that includes material from way outside a riot scene, given that police also look for such tiny details as shoes to (attempt to) identify people. The people at such events have something to lose: careers, families, friendships, years behind bars.…

I think this is a really important perspective. Reporting of protests is not neutral, and neither is the police's response.

Re: 'You're Not Allowed to Film': The Fight to Control Who Reports from Portland

#10
post #7

Having done a fair share of media work on and in German protests myself: the biggest problem is that video evidence can and will be used by cops to go after activists - and that includes material from way outside a riot scene, given that police also look for such tiny details as shoes to (attempt to) identify people. The people at such events have something to lose: careers, families, friendships, years behind bars.…

Go after them for what? Are they doing something illegal?

Cops have plenty of ways of going after people who haven’t committed crimes.

https://projects.tampabay.com/projects/2020/investigations/p...

Post reply on HN