Live data from Hacker News

Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

github.com

51–60 of 246 posts

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#51
post #22

How does this work considering PHP is heavily made up of code from Zend (which was an Israeli company) Can Iranian-built websites not use PHP?

>Zend (which was an Israeli company)

What?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zend_(company)

>Zend, formerly Zend Technologies, is a Minneapolis, Minnesota-based software company owned by software developer Perforce.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perforce

>Perforce, legally Perforce Software, Inc., is an American developer of software [...]

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#52
Edit: Sorry I completely misread it. I thought he said just "merged" it instead of encouraging "merge" it. Still interesting to learn about Behdad though, cool stuff about localization and language support.

Interestingly merged by Behdad Esfahbod who is also iranian. He was even arrested by the iranian government in the past

> Esfahbod claims that he was arrested by Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps intelligence echelon during a 2020 visit to Tehran. He was then moved to Evin prison, where he was psychologically pressured and interrogated for 6 days. Iranian security forces let him go based on his promise to spy on his friends once he was back in United States.[2]

[1] https://github.com/armancodes/laravel-download-link/pull/9#i... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behdad_Esfahbod#Detention_Iran...

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#53

This is the problem with the internet now, profile pics, egotistical bio summaries and emojis. It was more fun when it was anonymous and the person you were talking to could have been a 43 year old neo nazi with blue hair, but their code or stuff was good, so you didn't have that getting in the way of you.

How does that apply to the story?

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#54
post #47

I never knew about such law. For those who have Pikachu eyes now, or whoever gave thumbs down on the maintainer comment, I dare you to do a single tiny transaction with Iran or an Iranian citizen which would be in violation of unilateral sanctions imposed by US on Iran and Iranian national globally and you'd see how you'll get a taste of freedom and liberty and some prison time to sweeten the deal by US. If there's #…

exactly, the hypocrisy is just off the charts. Or, a more generous interpretation, is that many people are just unaware of American imperialism.

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#55
post #27

How is accepting a PR account to having a relationship with an individual. Popular OS repository would have code contribution from 1000s of contributor, it's possible that the maintainer don't personally know a majority of them. This just don't make sense.

The word "relationship" in this context refers to any kind of relationship including a business relationship. And a quick search shows that the law in question appears to basically make any interaction (no matter how minor) with people from Israel or the Israeli government a crime, so it does seem that it applies here[1]. In particular note this quote: > Furthermore, hardware and software developed in Israel or by co…

Then in that case, could even interacting with the PR at all count as a “relationship”? I doubt they’d be prosecuted for simply posting this and closing it, but I’m looking from through US eyes.

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#56
post #47

I never knew about such law. For those who have Pikachu eyes now, or whoever gave thumbs down on the maintainer comment, I dare you to do a single tiny transaction with Iran or an Iranian citizen which would be in violation of unilateral sanctions imposed by US on Iran and Iranian national globally and you'd see how you'll get a taste of freedom and liberty and some prison time to sweeten the deal by US. If there's #…

I get why people should not thumbs down and the whole tough guy angle, but I have never heard US putting someone in jail for a merged PR. Many of the big open source projects are american citizen lead and they accept PRs from all around the world.

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#57
post #36

I would have said "Jerusalem" as a location could lend some ambiguity as to whether the committing user is Israeli or Palestinian, but ah...his username and profile picture certainly leaves nothing to the imagination.

As an Israeli I have exactly zero intention to hide my nationality in order to participate. I don't really understand this PR as GitHub is an American company that is forbidden to do business with Iranians. It seems weird to me to use the website but not take a PR. That said I am sympathetic to the package maintainer and I hope to never live in a place so repressive. It's scary as it is.

>It seems weird to me to use the website but not take a PR.

The long and short of it is that he's more afraid of his government than the US government.

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#60

Edit: Sorry I completely misread it. I thought he said just "merged" it instead of encouraging "merge" it. Still interesting to learn about Behdad though, cool stuff about localization and language support. Interestingly merged by Behdad Esfahbod who is also iranian. He was even arrested by the iranian government in the past > Esfahbod claims that he was arrested by Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps intelligence ech…

Doesn’t seem like Behdad merged (or even has privileges to do so on that repo), just that he encouraged doing so.
Post reply on HN