Live data from Hacker News

Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

github.com

21–30 of 246 posts

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#21
post #2

Does this mean that there is an Iranian government enforcement agency monitoring Github PRs?

You never know for sure in an authoritarian country, but it's plausible there could be. The Iranian government has engaged in some public efforts recently to get rid of Israel-linked tech.

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#23

How is accepting a PR account to having a relationship with an individual. Popular OS repository would have code contribution from 1000s of contributor, it's possible that the maintainer don't personally know a majority of them. This just don't make sense.

I think "relationship" might be bad translation. It's more helpful to think about it from a sanctions point of view. If you own a B2C software company you wouldn't personally know most of your customers either, but that doesn't mean you can sell to Iranian/North Korean customers.

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#25
post #8

How is accepting a PR account to having a relationship with an individual. Popular OS repository would have code contribution from 1000s of contributor, it's possible that the maintainer don't personally know a majority of them. This just don't make sense.

It doesn't make sense. But they're in a country where the law also might not make sense. Technical / administrative issues aside here I can understand how an individual might fear some sort of retaliation... even if the basis for it is absurd, the consequences could be very real.

In every country there are laws that don't make sense. Yes, the same can be said for your own country. The quantity and ridiculousness can be argued, but there's no place on Earth that's "good", just "better". For any given person, they will have some disagreements regarding the body of law that applies to them.

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#26
post #15

If this PR would have come from a sufficiently anonymous user (no location / profile picture), I'm sure it would have gone through. I'm certain maintainers don't check identity and nationality of every contributor.

I don't think it's an acceptable state of affairs if people feel pressured to keep their nationality private.

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#27

How is accepting a PR account to having a relationship with an individual. Popular OS repository would have code contribution from 1000s of contributor, it's possible that the maintainer don't personally know a majority of them. This just don't make sense.

The word "relationship" in this context refers to any kind of relationship including a business relationship. And a quick search shows that the law in question appears to basically make any interaction (no matter how minor) with people from Israel or the Israeli government a crime, so it does seem that it applies here[1]. In particular note this quote:

> Furthermore, hardware and software developed in Israel or by companies that have production branches in Israel are forbidden.

(For the avoidance of doubt, I find the whole situation quite insane -- nobody benefits from governments blocking collaboration over the internet.)

[1]: https://www.jns.org/opinion/irans-anti-israel-law-desperatio...

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#28
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It doesn't make sense. But they're in a country where the law also might not make sense. Technical / administrative issues aside here I can understand how an individual might fear some sort of retaliation... even if the basis for it is absurd, the consequences could be very real.

In every country there are laws that don't make sense. Yes, the same can be said for your own country. The quantity and ridiculousness can be argued, but there's no place on Earth that's "good", just "better". For any given person, they will have some disagreements regarding the body of law that applies to them.

>but there's no place on Earth that's "good", just "better".

I don't know what you mean by that. I get the rest, but not that.

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#29

All the people arguing semantics when the author lives in a repressive dictatorship that would literally torture you for a confession and then execute you for it.. if anyone EVER comes by this PR even a decade from now. Meanwhile, no one here would even think of violating US export controls against North Korea... when the consequences are likely just prison time. Armchair tough guys.

> no one here would even think of violating US export controls against North Korea

If there were a vibrant industrial or creative community in North Korea to interact with, I’d see the light in this argument. But there isn’t. The only entity to contract with is the state.

That makes the comparison difficult. Cuba, on the other hand...

Re: Iranian law prohibits merge of PR from Israeli?

#30
This is the problem with the internet now, profile pics, egotistical bio summaries and emojis.

It was more fun when it was anonymous and the person you were talking to could have been a 43 year old neo nazi with blue hair, but their code or stuff was good, so you didn't have that getting in the way of you.

Post reply on HN