Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Employees Slam Zuckerberg over Militia Groups and QAnon After Kenosha

buzzfeednews.com

41–50 of 118 posts

Re: Facebook Employees Slam Zuckerberg over Militia Groups and QAnon After Kenosha

#41
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I enjoy seeing these political threads here on HN. It's good for this place to finally have a look in the mirror and see what's there.

It's disheartening to see so much racism among the community here.

Hopefully its more single issue trolls. They're new, low karma accounts and HN is going to be a target for proletarization.

Re: Facebook Employees Slam Zuckerberg over Militia Groups and QAnon After Kenosha

#42
post #2

What about deplatforming BLM, which seems to be the major driver for this unrest and criminal activity? As can be seen clearly in the video, the 17 year old was running away and defending himself against multiple attackers, some of whom were themselves armed.

Are you talking about the armed teenager who drove 12 miles across state lines and put his armed self in a dangerous situation willingly? Not sure you get to call it self-defense at that time

There is a great breakdown of his interactions and timeline on twitter by NYT or WaPo. I'll find it...

There is also no evidence (in his immediate past) or leading up to the events proving he's guilty of premeditated malicious intent.

Re: Facebook Employees Slam Zuckerberg over Militia Groups and QAnon After Kenosha

#43
So what happened in Kenosha was tragic, and I don't think the issue is as cut and dry as either side would have you believe.

But my concern is I felt like this was inevitable, and will continue. I know the BLM protests are politically charged, but the problem is that there are many people's whose livelihoods and business are being permanently put out of commission and communities that are being devastated by the the looting, rioting, and protesting.

Sure people use the "they have insurance" but imagine for a minute that your entire house burnt down, does your life just magically resume because you have homeowners insurance.

Ultimately I feel like this will become more and more common because individuals are feeling as though the government is failing to portect them and as a result are willing to take matters into their own hands.

Again I'm not trying to say I disagree with the movement or the concept of police reform but I am concerned about the fact we have been letting the rioting and looting continue unchecked for months now. The fundamental reason for the government to exist is to protect the life, liberty and property of an individual, if a government fails to do that then citizens will look to doing it themselves.

Re: Facebook Employees Slam Zuckerberg over Militia Groups and QAnon After Kenosha

#45
post #43

So what happened in Kenosha was tragic, and I don't think the issue is as cut and dry as either side would have you believe. But my concern is I felt like this was inevitable, and will continue. I know the BLM protests are politically charged, but the problem is that there are many people's whose livelihoods and business are being permanently put out of commission and communities that are being devastated by the the…

There's a simple solution here- stop the police from murdering black people. If a house burns down it can be rebuilt, but you can't rebuild the lives ended by white supremacy in our police departments.

Re: Facebook Employees Slam Zuckerberg over Militia Groups and QAnon After Kenosha

#46
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I enjoy seeing these political threads here on HN. It's good for this place to finally have a look in the mirror and see what's there.

It's disheartening to see so much racism among the community here.

It's disheartening to hear people refer to anything and everything as 'racism' to the point it's lost all meaning.

Re: Facebook Employees Slam Zuckerberg over Militia Groups and QAnon After Kenosha

#47
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you talking about the armed teenager who drove 12 miles across state lines and put his armed self in a dangerous situation willingly? Not sure you get to call it self-defense at that time

What's the significance of 12 miles here?

It sounds like a dramatically long distance if you live in an urban center.

Re: Facebook Employees Slam Zuckerberg over Militia Groups and QAnon After Kenosha

#48
post #2

What about deplatforming BLM, which seems to be the major driver for this unrest and criminal activity? As can be seen clearly in the video, the 17 year old was running away and defending himself against multiple attackers, some of whom were themselves armed.

Are you talking about the armed teenager who drove 12 miles across state lines and put his armed self in a dangerous situation willingly? Not sure you get to call it self-defense at that time

There was a protest/riot (depending on who you ask) that night. 12mi is probably below the median travel distance of all people from all sides who partook and everyone who partook was also putting themselves in a dangerous situation willingly. Nobody there should have that held against them.

His actions prior to getting chased by and shooting the first guy are what I have serious questions about.

Re: Facebook Employees Slam Zuckerberg over Militia Groups and QAnon After Kenosha

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd like to see some evidence that BLM is the major driver for any criminal activities or "unrest." Instead it seems to be the continued extrajudicial killings and woundings of American citizens that always seems to proceed these protests and the frankly appalling reaction of American law enforcement to some criticism and democratic attempts to reform what is supposed to be a constructive and positive institution in…

This most recent incident in Kenosha was not "extrajudicial". The man had a knife and a fireman and was not complying with the officers. And in either case, that is not a situation that justifies burning buildings and destroying properties. Anarchy is not a solution to any problem.

The knife was in his car and they found it afterwords, it wasn't on him at the time.

Not complying with officers should not mean a death sentence. This isn't Judge Dread. Other countries besides the US manage to not regularly murder black people- in fact most countries don't have anywhere near the level of police murder that the US has.

Re: Facebook Employees Slam Zuckerberg over Militia Groups and QAnon After Kenosha

#50
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can we try to make Facebook responsible for every damn thing that happens on their platform?

The problem is that excessive blaming will foster high levels of risk aversion, as seen in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24304275

This is a case of advocating to suppress one kind of speech because it will lead to the suppression of another kind of speech. So maybe there isn't a problem here?

If the act of criticizing Facebook changes Facebook's behaviour because we've observed people are doing bad things linked to Facebook's current practices that is just the marketplace of ideas in action, isn't it?

Post reply on HN