Live data from Hacker News

SpaceX Starlink average speedtest is 42.3Mbps down / 9.7 Mbps up

testmy.net

171–180 of 325 posts

Re: SpaceX Starlink average speedtest is 42.3Mbps down / 9.7 Mbps up

#171
post #55

Fantastic. I'm keenly curious on how this will work with national regulations. Having a single global ISP is very attractive on the surface and that's with the huge caveat on monopoly, but as an additional option. I'm just not sure how this will interact with some nations' policy/restrictions. Looking at this aspect very much.

The right way of making sure this doesn't become a monopoly is to treat this satellite infrastructure just as you treat the fiber infrastructure in many countries. Where instead of having the ISP owning the infrastructure, they can rent the usage of it, so you can have many competing companies using it. So Starlink would be the infrastructure and they need to allow others to use it on the same level as the Starlink I…

The tech who installed my Starry Internet said that they were going to offer Starlink next year in rural areas. Maybe he was confused but he was reasonably knowledgeable.

We were specifically talking about Elon, Starlink and rural Internet. Obviously Starry is a completely unrelated company.

Re: SpaceX Starlink average speedtest is 42.3Mbps down / 9.7 Mbps up

#173
post #133

This is easy to have a lot of bandwidth when you only have 10s of users, but when the bandwidth will be shared between 10000 users will it plummet? I remember when 4G was new and only few user where using it, it was very fast, but when more users arrived on the spectrum, the bandwidth per user decreased and the latency incised.

I have been on EE 4G in central London (Westminster) for several years now while at work. A speed test back when it was new would get me 85/85 Mb, these days, with a much more capable device, I am lucky if I get 15/30 Mb (download is being taxed more). It's not horrific, but it's a far cry from what I was advertised when I started. I guess I'll just upgrade to their 5G plan and start the cycle again sigh

I’m on three. I’ve noticed the speed drop in town over the years. What’s really surprised me has been the lack of an increase since lockdown, even though the City is empty.

Which makes me suspect there’s something else going on rather than just undercapacity.

Chronic underinvestment across networks?

Re: SpaceX Starlink average speedtest is 42.3Mbps down / 9.7 Mbps up

#175

May be silly question, but why is the up so low compared to down?

I actually have DSL and it is similar, not speed, but asymmetry.

12 Mbps down and 768kbps up, almost 20 to 1 ratio.

Most ‘consumers’ download more than they upload.

Re: SpaceX Starlink average speedtest is 42.3Mbps down / 9.7 Mbps up

#176

May be silly question, but why is the up so low compared to down?

They must have provisioned less spectrum to uplink. Usually people want more downlink, less uplink. Symmetric services exist, but are usually offered as a "pro" or enterprise solution.

Re: SpaceX Starlink average speedtest is 42.3Mbps down / 9.7 Mbps up

#177
post #64
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

50ms ping should be reasonable for most games. whippersnappers who complain about 20ms ping should watch some quakeworld or quake 3 cpma where this dude rat used to destroy everyone on 300ms.

On some games (Rainbow 6: Siege being the one I'm most familiar with) latency actually helps you, as the enemy has an out of date picture of where you are.

Yes, in Natural Selection 2 you can't properly ambush anyone unless you take into account the ping and jump on them before you even see each other.

Re: SpaceX Starlink average speedtest is 42.3Mbps down / 9.7 Mbps up

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have been on EE 4G in central London (Westminster) for several years now while at work. A speed test back when it was new would get me 85/85 Mb, these days, with a much more capable device, I am lucky if I get 15/30 Mb (download is being taxed more). It's not horrific, but it's a far cry from what I was advertised when I started. I guess I'll just upgrade to their 5G plan and start the cycle again sigh

I’m on three. I’ve noticed the speed drop in town over the years. What’s really surprised me has been the lack of an increase since lockdown, even though the City is empty. Which makes me suspect there’s something else going on rather than just undercapacity. Chronic underinvestment across networks?

More and more users use 4G at home rather that WiFi. In general, home WiFi seems flaky, stops working in some rooms, cuts out if you go outside, etc.

It's often easier to just use 4G always.

Re: SpaceX Starlink average speedtest is 42.3Mbps down / 9.7 Mbps up

#179
post #133

This is easy to have a lot of bandwidth when you only have 10s of users, but when the bandwidth will be shared between 10000 users will it plummet? I remember when 4G was new and only few user where using it, it was very fast, but when more users arrived on the spectrum, the bandwidth per user decreased and the latency incised.

I have been on EE 4G in central London (Westminster) for several years now while at work. A speed test back when it was new would get me 85/85 Mb, these days, with a much more capable device, I am lucky if I get 15/30 Mb (download is being taxed more). It's not horrific, but it's a far cry from what I was advertised when I started. I guess I'll just upgrade to their 5G plan and start the cycle again sigh

I remember when 4G launched here in Atlanta I could pull down 100Mbps no problem.

I still can (pulled 150mbps down as a test for this comment), but I could then too. Getting 150/30 to nearby servers.

I guess I live next to the tower lol.

Re: SpaceX Starlink average speedtest is 42.3Mbps down / 9.7 Mbps up

#180
I'm eagerly awaiting reports from beta users about the length of downtime during antenna repositioning and handover to another satellite.

Hopefully it's sub-second. I can't think of anything apart from a competitive gamer playing a shooter that might be intolerant of this.

Post reply on HN