Live data from Hacker News

WireGuard support in Mikrotik RouterOS v7.1beta2

forum.mikrotik.com

41–50 of 79 posts

Re: WireGuard support in Mikrotik RouterOS v7.1beta2

#42
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not. Why would one want that workload on their router when they can offload it to a $35 Pi?

One of the main selling points of Wireguard is that it runs much leaner than OpenVPN or IPSec tunnels, especially on embedded hardware, so there isn’t much of a workload in the first place.

Crypto used by IPSec (aes, sha) is often accelerated by hardware - and the above mentioned Ubiquiti has hardware for that. Chacha/Poly used by Wireguard are not.

Re: WireGuard support in Mikrotik RouterOS v7.1beta2

#43
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not. Why would one want that workload on their router when they can offload it to a $35 Pi?

One of the main selling points of Wireguard is that it runs much leaner than OpenVPN or IPSec tunnels, especially on embedded hardware, so there isn’t much of a workload in the first place.

IPsec is pretty light.

Re: WireGuard support in Mikrotik RouterOS v7.1beta2

#46
post #22

The ball's in your court, Ubiquiti

Not ubiquiti's doing but this repo has pre-built kernel modules of wireguard and vyatta integration for I think most of the edgerouter series: https://github.com/WireGuard/wireguard-vyatta-ubnt I haven't updated/tested in awhile but last I remember I was seeing 800+ mbit/s on my dinky mips ER-X. Pretty amazing and easy to use.

Unfortunately 3rd party software installs are lost on updates, so you need to be local to the router before upgrading (or have a secondary VPN available).

Development of EdgeOS has really slowed down though, there hasnt been a stable firmware update in 6 months (and that was just a small hotfix).

Re: WireGuard support in Mikrotik RouterOS v7.1beta2

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Anyone have any experience here with getting wireguard running on pfsense?

I don't think *BSD supports wg yet. would love to see this

AFAIU OpenBSD has official support for Wireguard: https://man.openbsd.org/wg

Re: WireGuard support in Mikrotik RouterOS v7.1beta2

#50
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One of the main selling points of Wireguard is that it runs much leaner than OpenVPN or IPSec tunnels, especially on embedded hardware, so there isn’t much of a workload in the first place.

IPsec is pretty light.

Doesn't feel light to setup if you're trying to get a tunnel working between different providers. We had a strange dead peer issue between Fortigate and Mikrotik and could never figure it out as it happened so rarely. All phase 1 and phase 2 settings were identical. I can imagine that happens elsewhere too.
Post reply on HN