Live data from Hacker News

Rideshare operations are being suspended in California

lyft.com

831–840 of 1001 posts

Re: Rideshare operations are being suspended in California

#831
post #791
post #584

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exactly. Uber and Lyft are a 19th century labor situation which masks itself by using 21st century technology

by giving drivers the right to turn the app off at any time? when did that happen in the 19th century?

A taxi could simply turn its light off.

Re: Rideshare operations are being suspended in California

#832
This is why healthcare benefits shouldn't be tied with employment. IMO, that's the biggest thing contractors are missing out on by not being traditional employees. It's not like being an employee in the US gives you much more legal protection than being a contractor due to "at-will" employment laws. Universal healthcare decouples this critical service from employment, making _everyone_ more able to work flexibly.

Re: Rideshare operations are being suspended in California

#833

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're asking for better run states, it looks like Texas is doing well but I'm unfamiliar with most other states to give you a good answer. As 20 year California resident, what I do know is that nothing has gotten better here over that time frame. Everything from infrastructure to taxes to city planning is much worse now than ever. CCPA is probably the only good outcome I can think of.

The state that scared uber and lyft off with background requirements, fingerprinting, and restricting bikelanes? I think maybe the grass is just greener.

It was the City of Austin that scared off Uber and Lyft for a time not the state. Lots of West coasters came to Austin and brought their political problems with them. The City of Austin is CA lite basically.

Re: Rideshare operations are being suspended in California

#834
post #586

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, not based on one person, but sometimes making uneconomic decisions based on human decency? That’s the society I’d rather live in. I mean, if numbers are all that matter, I’m fairly sure someone could come up with a model to deprioritise and disenfranchise almost anyone - the disabled, the elderly, the retired...

Is forcing wheelchair users to use subway human decency to you? We're talking about a situation where it's cheaper to let them use taxi service, and it's a better experience. My uncle lives in a wheelchair by the way. The horror of imagining him having to use the subway...

yeah the proposal from the original comment also seems more designed to “teach” the billionaire by making him sit next to a disabled person instead of helping the wheelchair bound person. all out of some sort of sense of justice

Re: Rideshare operations are being suspended in California

#835
post #7

So this is basically an admission that the ridesharing business model is not viable without worker exploitation?

Because the previous medallion system was so much better. Either the driver rented the car to a middleman who rented the medallion from a rich owner, or said owner was selling and financing (most banks won't touch these medallions!) a medallion at a ridiculous interest rate to a driver that plans to use it as his retirement savings. Pre-Uber, the more I spoke to cab drivers the more it seemed their industry was a pyr…

>"Either the driver rented the car to a middleman who rented the medallion from a rich owner, or said owner was selling and financing (most banks won't touch these medallions!)"

There are plenty of commercial banks that have underwritten loans for taxi medallions and built up a significant portfolio Just in NY for example - North Fork Bank, Capital One, Provident and Signature Bank, See:

https://www.autofinancenews.net/allposts/finance/loss-mitiga...

https://nyrej.com/print/18823

https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20200117005338/en/Sig...

Re: Rideshare operations are being suspended in California

#836

Earlier quoted context omitted.

'Ridesharing' (Which is a hilarious term for the simple fact that the ride is not being shared, the driver is not intending to go to your favorite bar. ) isn't a 21st century situation or solution. It's not a profitable or a good force in an economy, it does not pay a reasonable wage for anyone to live on, it is not environmentally friendly unless done in large quantities of people,(which is called a bus). Ridesharin…

I agree with you on one point, "ridesharing" is a silly word. I would call it something like an "Open Car Service". The main reason I can't get on board with the rest of this line of argument is that it ultimately just comes down to paternalistic protection of the poor disenfranchised gig workers that you clearly view as being less than capable, rational adult humans. The number of gig economy workers has been growin…

Yeah, there are many reasons that people like driving for Uber and/or Lyft, and it's very closed-minded to say that the market can't exist if it doesn't fully and completely replace a "real job" for all of its drivers, up to and including full-time employment with attached benefit packages.

I've had friends who've done it just because they enjoy meeting people who are coming into town and hearing their stories, telling them about the area, etc. Many of the rides I've taken, upon talking to the driver, they'll say they do it because it gets them out of the house and they can work whenever they want. Very few of the people were trying to use it to replace a conventional employment situation.

We should all be grateful that the state is rescuing all of these people from the exploitative habits of these unprofitable companies, I guess.

Re: Rideshare operations are being suspended in California

#838
post #7

So this is basically an admission that the ridesharing business model is not viable without worker exploitation?

Because the previous medallion system was so much better. Either the driver rented the car to a middleman who rented the medallion from a rich owner, or said owner was selling and financing (most banks won't touch these medallions!) a medallion at a ridiculous interest rate to a driver that plans to use it as his retirement savings. Pre-Uber, the more I spoke to cab drivers the more it seemed their industry was a pyr…

[deleted]

Re: Rideshare operations are being suspended in California

#839
post #791
post #584

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exactly. Uber and Lyft are a 19th century labor situation which masks itself by using 21st century technology

by giving drivers the right to turn the app off at any time? when did that happen in the 19th century?

Underpaid day laborers could walk off the job site any time they wanted to and go to another site the next day...

Re: Rideshare operations are being suspended in California

#840

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Who forced Lyft to shut down? Was it the state, or did they freely choose to cease operations? Obviously, spin will characterize this in any way that's advantageous. But nobody 'forced' Lyft to close.

The state made their business model illegal. Yes, technically that’s not the same thing as shutting them down, since they could have switched to a different business model, but it’s a distinction without a difference.

They can still run the same business model, they will just have to increase employee compensation (and fares).

This is like saying that raising the minimum wage will drive McDonald's out of business. At the current prices, sure, but McDonald's will raise prices 10% to compensate (wages are not 100% of the cost of a burger) and keep on trucking.

Post reply on HN