Live data from Hacker News

YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 39 posts

Re: YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

#11
> If this bump in the road rattles you enough to close shop, you shouldn't be an entrepreneur.

I question the value of telling someone they "shouldn't" be an entrepreneur. Even that they "aren't" an entrepreneur.

Closing shop doesn't have to be a permanent thing.

Didn't get accepted for this round of YC? Decide what that means for you, then continue to live your life.

Re: YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

#12

Girl Scout Gold Award recipient here just got rejected. (: I'm looking for a cofounder if anyone knows anyone interested in working on a social startup. I'm more interested in finding passionate people than people with a particular skillset.

You might want to look into why the images on pages like http://yellowrubberball.com/why-yrb/ on your site hang off the side of the page in Chrome 10.0.648.204 on OS X.

I noticed it on the home page too.

Re: YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

#13

I turned 18 before I could complete my Eagle. But Boy Scouts had a lasting impact on the way I live my life. There are many things I have tackled in my life because I have the courage to stand up and do something others might not. A scout is trustworthy, loyal, helpful, friendly, courteous, kind, obedient, cheerful, thrifty, brave, clean and reverent.

I got my Eagle at age 18 and 3 months... They give you 6 months to do the paperwork after your 18th birthday.

Re: YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

#14
I got to the badge below Eagle (Life) basically as fast as it was mechanically possible to. I'm not sure when exactly, but by 8th grade at the latest. Then all of my friends dropped out of scouts when we got to high school. I ended up being Senior Patrol Leader and running the troop for a couple of years, and I avoided working on an Eagle project for a while... I had time.

Then at some point I decided I'd rather do something that other kids my age were also doing, so after much hand-wringing I quit Boy Scouts and joined the theater. I ended up being the lead in the school musical senior year, and I sung in choirs all through college. I did light opera. I joined a gospel choir and performed in baptist churches all across the state.

I also developed a deep belief that I could try totally new things that were outside my comfort zone, and excel at them.

I sometimes wonder whether I should've stayed and gotten the Eagle. Finishing things is certainly a weakness of mine. Maybe if I had spent those last two two years of high school hanging around with 13 year olds and building a bridge in the woods I'd be a better finisher. But I'd be a worse artist. And I'd be a more cautious person.

This is the second time I got rejected from YCombinator. And quitting is the furthest thing from my mind. But I'm glad I quit back then.

Re: YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

#15

> If this bump in the road rattles you enough to close shop, you shouldn't be an entrepreneur. I question the value of telling someone they "shouldn't" be an entrepreneur. Even that they "aren't" an entrepreneur. Closing shop doesn't have to be a permanent thing. Didn't get accepted for this round of YC? Decide what that means for you, then continue to live your life.

If rejection makes you stop building the company that you envision, love, and put all of your effort behind, then you will never succeed running a startup. This may be a bold statement, but I'd love to hear what Jobs, Gates, Zuck, or anyone else with expertise in the area have to say.

Re: YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

#16
Yes and No. A good entrepreneur needs to be able to execute and part of that is spending time on the right ideas and features for that idea. I'd say the ability to assess sensibly the question 'Am I working on the best thing I can be at the moment' is more important than dogged pursuit of a single goal.

Re: YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

#17

Girl Scout Gold Award recipient here just got rejected. (: I'm looking for a cofounder if anyone knows anyone interested in working on a social startup. I'm more interested in finding passionate people than people with a particular skillset.

Eagle Scout here. We got rejected as well. I wonder how much bearing gold/eagle awards actually have on the yc selection process. Are you out in the bay area Katie?

Re: YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

#18
I got rejected twice. However, I have a different idea for a startup. Non web startup, not based on coding. Based on the fact that I never even got a reason why I was rejected, I thought I'd apply differently this time. Saved my application in a file and then posted it here:

http://thypope.posterous.com/my-latest-y-combinator-applicat...

Tried to make them think. I believe they're in a loop of... self-indulgence, really. Since I think they do their best to stay the $#@! away from taking risks with any "unorthodox" ideas.

Re: YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

#19
Disappointed.

I've got nothing against YC, but I've seemed to go into "success is the best revenge" mode ha.

To be honest it's a good wake up call, I need to stop treating my start up as a lifestyle business.

Dropping out of university at the end of this term and i'm pushing forward with it.

Decisions been made.

Re: YC s11 Rejected Applicants: This is the real test.

#20
post #19

Disappointed. I've got nothing against YC, but I've seemed to go into "success is the best revenge" mode ha. To be honest it's a good wake up call, I need to stop treating my start up as a lifestyle business. Dropping out of university at the end of this term and i'm pushing forward with it. Decisions been made.

Have you considered whether you're following a fantasy? Maybe you should seek advice from someone you trust who doesn't drink the HN/TechCrunch Kool-Aid. Somehow I doubt you were rejected from YC due to lack of effort.
Post reply on HN