Live data from Hacker News

Reddit reports 18% reduction in hate content after banning nearly 7k subreddits

theverge.com

11–20 of 173 posts

Re: Reddit reports 18% reduction in hate content after banning nearly 7k subreddits

#11
post #6

Since there's no objective definition of "hate content", this is akin to them patting themselves on the back for outright censorship based on their own arbitrary definitions.

The_Donald promoted the Charlottesville hate rally, people with white shirts and torches.

Seems pretty clear cut! What about the other 6999?

Re: Reddit reports 18% reduction in hate content after banning nearly 7k subreddits

#13

Since there's no objective definition of "hate content", this is akin to them patting themselves on the back for outright censorship based on their own arbitrary definitions.

Not censorship.

Freedom.

Private property includes the freedom to restrict what occurs on that property. Reddit is private property.

Same goes for Hacker News.

Let freedom ring!

edit: guess people don't like freedom :-(

Would Hacker News be "censoring" me if they deleted my submission to TIMECUBE? Isn't it "MAH RAIGHT" to proselytize my sincere and deeply-held beliefs about TIMECUBE?

Are you CENSORIZING MAH FREEZE PEECH by downvoting and thus hiding from public view, this comment?

Re: Reddit reports 18% reduction in hate content after banning nearly 7k subreddits

#14
post #8

>The company also says that half (48 percent) of all hateful content on the site was targeting a person’s ethnicity or nationality. That was followed by their class or political affiliation (16 percent), [...] "Hate speech" now includes your political affiliation? That's news to me. I thought it's usually restricted to immutable characteristics about a person (race, religion, gender, etc.).

How is religion immutable when political affiliation is not?

Re: Reddit reports 18% reduction in hate content after banning nearly 7k subreddits

#16

Since there's no objective definition of "hate content", this is akin to them patting themselves on the back for outright censorship based on their own arbitrary definitions.

They clearly outline their definition of "hate content" in their post about it. [0] They go over the methodology and dig a bit into the results. It looks like a good start.

[0] - https://www.reddit.com/r/redditsecurity/comments/idclo1/unde...

Re: Reddit reports 18% reduction in hate content after banning nearly 7k subreddits

#20
More accurately would be to say Reddit reports 18% of hate content moved to a different platform. This would be akin to saying "salmon30salmon saw a reduction in hate content when he stopped attending hate group meetings".

While I appreciate any attempt to reduce hate, it isn't really something to cheer in this case. The goal is to reduce hate, and pushing people further into the fringes doesn't do that. Now instead of being part of a community that has hate, but also positive information, the hate groups are going to be forced into a more focused hate forum. It is a means to further push people to the fringes which could further radicalize folks.

Essentially, Reddit etc. doesn't make people hate more, the internet just exposes the hate that already existed. It is part of a larger cultural problem. People don't generally become hateful after seeing 12 memes, they are raised in an environment that breeds hate. Banning the subreddits _feels_ good, but it is not a solution to the core problem.

Post reply on HN