Live data from Hacker News

Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

businessinsider.com

21–30 of 112 posts

Re: Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

#21

They need to make people responsible, not the corporate entity.

Why? The company profited from the crime. That would create some interesting incentives.

You can’t effectively punish a company, especially not a company the size of Facebook.

But if individuals go to prison for their actions, people will be more careful how they act.

Re: Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

#23
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why? The company profited from the crime. That would create some interesting incentives.

You can’t effectively punish a company, especially not a company the size of Facebook. But if individuals go to prison for their actions, people will be more careful how they act.

Corporate death penalty.

Re: Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

#27

They need to make people responsible, not the corporate entity.

Why? The company profited from the crime. That would create some interesting incentives.

So what you're saying is that whenever i commit a crime i just need to do it under a business name and it's all good? It's simply ridiculous to think that.

Re: Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

#28
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can’t effectively punish a company, especially not a company the size of Facebook. But if individuals go to prison for their actions, people will be more careful how they act.

Corporate death penalty.

Not sure why this is downvoted as it brings up an interesting position. Why can't there be violations so severe that they force the corporation to be dissolved?

Re: Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

#29

Today I learned: the idea that a corporation can commit a crime is a very new one. [1] People commit crimes, not companies. [1] William Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England 464 (1765) (“A corporation cannot commit treason or felony or other crime in its corporate capacity though it’s members may in their distinct individual capacities.”)

>People commit crimes, not companies.

I thought corporations are people, my friend.

Re: Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

#30
post #29

Today I learned: the idea that a corporation can commit a crime is a very new one. [1] People commit crimes, not companies. [1] William Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England 464 (1765) (“A corporation cannot commit treason or felony or other crime in its corporate capacity though it’s members may in their distinct individual capacities.”)

> People commit crimes, not companies. I thought corporations are people, my friend.

Someone needs to eat the cake
Post reply on HN