Live data from Hacker News

Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

businessinsider.com

1–10 of 112 posts

Re: Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

#7
It's pretty obvious that the fine won't be $500B since it was likely set that high specifically so when it's knocked down it doesn't go to something absurd like $1,000. However, I do hope this sees some traction, especially as Facebook is now fully moving forward with its plan to merge Instagram, WhatsApp and Facebook.

Re: Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

#8

Where do those fines go?

> Where do those fines go?

They aren't fines. They are damages and go to the people affected.

In the case of the $650 million proposed settlement for Facebook proper (The judge in the case already rejected a $550 million settlement agreement as "far too little"), all Illinois Facebook users would get a check for $1000+

By the way, this article is really poorly written. The $5000 * 100 million users is not the way it works. The Illinois law says it is $1000-$5000 per violation, so the few million Illinois Instagram users (I have absolutely no idea how many there are) would be entitled to $1000-$5000 every time Instagram did a facial recognition lookup on them, which could easily cause a total liability to be in the tens or hundreds of billions of dollars.

Facebook fought against their lawsuit for years until it was finally ruled that they would have to go to trial. And now they are settling. That's likely what is going to happen here too. If they can keep it out of the courtroom, they'll pay nothing. If they can't, they'll offer up a few hundred million to make it go away.

Re: Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data

#9
This sounds almost like the previous lawsuit (mentioned in the article) that was settled by Facebook for $650 million, which was concerning Facebook’s use of facial recognition, wasn’t noticed by the lawyers of this case. The best they can hope for would be one more settlement that will be a tiny fraction of a percentage of the $500 billion ask. Hopefully they have strong evidence against Facebook’s statement that Instagram doesn’t do facial recognition.
Post reply on HN