Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Films that made you see the world differently?

news.ycombinator.com

211–220 of 340 posts

Re: Ask HN: Films that made you see the world differently?

#211

Movies with great impact on me: 1. Untouchable - must see 2. Gattaca - are we going there? 3. 1984 - must see 4. Idiocracy - initially looks like joke/stupid movie, but it's more real then we may want to agree 5. Life of others (made in Ge) 6. Amelie Poulain (made in Fr) 7. Turtles can fly (made in Ir) 8. Stalker - the russian original (3 parts) (made in Ru) 9. Metropolis Other good movies: Lost Horizon The Bucket Li…

Gattaca is one of my favorite movies

Re: Ask HN: Films that made you see the world differently?

#212
post #179

Snowpiercer Most people see this movie as a very on-the-nose example of class struggle. But I see it as a commentary on how we humans build and interact with the very system that we collectively create to sustain ourselves as a species. The system always has its apologists, supporters and opposition, but deep down all but the most extreme zealots understand that the system has to change with time or fail, and the lon…

Maybe this is more than what people usually understand when they hear the term "class struggle" but this is actually exactly what Marx is talking about when he describes the "system" of capitalism and how all of the classes are dependent on it even though they are in conflict. This is related to the "inherent contradictions" built into the system which he also discusses.

One word you mention though -- "Hypernormalisation" -- reminds me of a film that made me see the world differently. I don't know if you intentionally used that term, but the Adam Curtis film Hypernormalisation is, I believe, an absolute must watch, probing for some clarification on the logic of the last 40-50 years of history in our capitalist/neoliberal society.

Re: Ask HN: Films that made you see the world differently?

#214

I would suggest "The Big Short". It mainly focuses on the huge disaster of the 2008 financial bubble, and what led up to it. Before watching the movie I had this feeling of how impossible it could have been for so many normal people to be screwed over so royally. The crisis obviously happened, but I lacked the understanding of how something like that could have happened. After the movie it was clear to me how systemi…

I didn't see any normal people getting screwed in the movie.

Re: Ask HN: Films that made you see the world differently?

#215
Swimming to Cambodia[0] because it was both highly insightful and stylistically unique - it’s a monologue by a single person(Spalding Gray [1]) and Lauri Anderson’s excellent soundtrack adds just enough you visualize much of what he describes. At least I did but that might have been the LSD.

Rest in piece Spalding Gray.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swimming_to_Cambodia [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spalding_Gray

Re: Ask HN: Films that made you see the world differently?

#216
post #106

Vera drake. It's about a woman who does abortions when it was illegal in UK. She is caught and ends up in jail. It shows whatever your stance on abortion that making it illegal doesn't stop it and is risky for women The film also shows the hypocrisy of the well off woman who can still get an abortion. While the poor can't access this Finally when the film was released it struggled in America as people expected Vera d…

> It shows whatever your stance on abortion that making it illegal doesn't stop it That’s not an argument. Making homicide illegal does not stop serial killers, is this a good reason for legalizing homicide? I am not taking a side on the dispute, but: are you in favor of abortion? Then just say openly that, according to your system of values, a fetus of N months can be rightfully killed, for some value of N.

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Films that made you see the world differently?

#217

Tree of Life - Tererence Malick Stalker - Andrei Tarkovsky

I’d you liked Stalker I also recommend the book it was based on (“Roadside Picnic”). The book is very different from the movie in terms of tone, but I feel like the book gives a bit more context to the movie. It’s a case of the book/film being complimentary to each other in a really nice way.

Re: Ask HN: Films that made you see the world differently?

#219
post #177
post #19

Jiro Dreams of Sushi. It highlights the true nature of mastery, how deep it goes, and what an actual master looks like. One of the chefs needed 10 years of experience before they would let him do the egg sushi. There's the deep networks that support it too, the master fishmongers, the master rice planters, and all the master brokers in between who knew how to find the good stuff.

> One of the chefs needed 10 years of experience before they would let him do the egg sushi. That only ever struck me as extremely pretentious, to be perfectly honest. The chef in question needing 10 years of experience before they would let him do the egg sushi strikes me as essentially the same harmful mentality the Japanese have toward productivity, thinking that clocking in as many hours as possible equals produc…

You are missing the philosophy. It's not about getting the job done.

Re: Ask HN: Films that made you see the world differently?

#220
post #214

I would suggest "The Big Short". It mainly focuses on the huge disaster of the 2008 financial bubble, and what led up to it. Before watching the movie I had this feeling of how impossible it could have been for so many normal people to be screwed over so royally. The crisis obviously happened, but I lacked the understanding of how something like that could have happened. After the movie it was clear to me how systemi…

I didn't see any normal people getting screwed in the movie.

When the michael scott team went down to florida they met a man who had been paying rent to a landlord who never paid the mortgage.

p.s. but the parent poster is probably referring to the people who were duped into a floating rate mortgage, or the idea of paying nth mortgage with n+1th mortage (which is reasonable as long as rates decrease/stay low forever), or retail investors/small time investors who bought securities they were assured were high quality but were not. These people didn't get much screen time (beginning of movie bankers, line of side bets at the roulette table)

Post reply on HN