Live data from Hacker News

Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

apnews.com

121–123 of 123 posts

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why must it? Why not have they work only with 80% reliability if it could lower the price and put it in the hands of way more people?

Because if it had 80% reliability it wouldn't be a safety device at all. Think of cars, would you buy at a very discounted price a car whose brakes would fail 2 times out of 10? Different contexts, I know, but when safety is a must price doesn't matter much.

I encourage you to be more quantitative. We trade money for safety constantly. Every time you drive your car to work you do so, and likewise every time you buy a small car.

As of a decade ago, incorrect airbag deployment killed one person for ever 7 lives it saved. Nonetheless, they were mandated by law for many classes of cars, and were purchased voluntarily for others. And this was the right decision. They could have spent thousands of dollars per unit to get the mistake rate even lower, but that wouldn't have been worth the money.

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#122
post #107
post #99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can easily see someone making, for example, three giant triangles or circles for a variety of reasons—fun, art, or engineering—without the intent to alarm anyone. If someone were to visibly write out SOS or HELP, though, they are either in need of help, or extraordinarily careless (or even malicious) in their deceit. But that’s unlikely enough to still warrant checking in.

Morse code for SOS was literally based on on this idea of threes. ...---... I for one, would investigate three triangles in the sand in a remote area. It might be a fun art project for that back country woodsman, but it's much, much, more likely a distress signal, whatever form it takes.

Sure, but if I were in a situation where I needed help, I'd choose the unambiguous signal, that even people who have never heard of "the idea of threes" grasp immediately. "HELP" or "SOS" ist just very, very obvious.

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#123

Interestingly the international ground air code for requiring help is normally an X or a V. But I would still write SOS or HELP. You can imagine the scenario: “Hey Jane check out that - looks like a V in the sand” “Heh yeah”. “Weird”. or “Hey Jane does that say HELP?” “Heh yeah. Wanna check it out?” “Yeah let’s take a look”.

How cross culture are HELP or SOS? We're talking about being on a tiny remote island here. There's no guarantee that the people who see your message speak English, or have much exposure to western culture at all. Is SOS known to all cultures?

English is the international language for aviation. All pilots speak English to a required standard.
Post reply on HN