Live data from Hacker News

A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

bbc.com

81–90 of 99 posts

Re: A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The digital emissions from this story are an estimated 1.2g to 3.6g CO2 per page view. Holy cow, that is a lot . 1-3 grams of CO2 per single load of a page? Makes me feel guilty about even clicking the article.

I'm having a very hard time rationalizing these numbers. Something has to have some very poor assumptions: Let's assume each page load is ~1mbit, and it's being served from 1000km away. 1mbit may be low, but most of it will presumably be content delivered by a CDN which is far closer than 1000km. The reference design (which I work on) for 400G DWDM systems are ~100W for 2 transceivers + EDFA + switches, for a standar…

It's the bbc - accuracy is the very least of their concerns. They're much more focused on harassing pensioners for their state sponsored extortion racket money.

Re: A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

#82
post #37
post #2

When I see a wave foil I wonder how that doesn't make more drag than power...is this similar or something different?

What sort of wave foil do you mean? It's not clear from this article how the trimaran works, but you can see in the photos that there is a gap at the top of the outboard hulls. So I suspect it's the relative motion between the outboard hulls and the inboard one which is converted to hydraulic power - makes sense, it will be a short movement with a huge force behind it. That is then fed to a generator, electrical stor…

Most seem to involve a wing or fin extending out from the hull in some way.

That seems like it would introduce drag and greatly limit speed.

Re: A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

#83
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is exactly the kind of order-of-magnitude estimation that I was looking for in the article. Where did you get the wave energy numbers?

Here's a quick estimate: The potential energy of the wave will go like mass x gravitational acceleration x height. If the depth (front to back) of the wave is about 1 meter and the height is also about 1 M, then per meter of wave we get M g h g = 10 m / s^2; M = 1 g / cm^3 = 10^6 g / m^3 = 10^3 kg / m^3; H = 1 m MGH ~ 10^4 Joules per meter If a wave comes every 10 seconds —> 10^3 joules / sec, not far from what this…

Just a note: at sea, when the ratio of wave height to wave length exceeds 0.17, the wave will break, so a 1m by 1m is impossibly steep.

Re: A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

#84
post #10

I've been long enamored with Philippine boat making. The first time I was asked if I wanted to ride in a canoe, I said no and had horrid flashbacks of tipping over in dirty ponds in the south USA. Theirs, even homemade ones, have stabilizers. Such a simple, but brilliant idea.

This is likely because stabilizers don't make sense for the usecase of those in the southern US. Canoes there were typically used navigating between rivers, creeks, and lakes where the stabilizer would be cumbersome due to plant life and just size. Ocean going canoes, or canoes on large rivers don't encounter these problems in the same way making stabilizers worthwhile

Re: A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

#85
post #82
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What sort of wave foil do you mean? It's not clear from this article how the trimaran works, but you can see in the photos that there is a gap at the top of the outboard hulls. So I suspect it's the relative motion between the outboard hulls and the inboard one which is converted to hydraulic power - makes sense, it will be a short movement with a huge force behind it. That is then fed to a generator, electrical stor…

Most seem to involve a wing or fin extending out from the hull in some way. That seems like it would introduce drag and greatly limit speed.

Oh this kind of thing? https://wavefoil.com/

I'm assuming they've tested it and it's not entirely fraudulen and does in fact give more speed than drag?

Re: A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm having a very hard time rationalizing these numbers. Something has to have some very poor assumptions: Let's assume each page load is ~1mbit, and it's being served from 1000km away. 1mbit may be low, but most of it will presumably be content delivered by a CDN which is far closer than 1000km. The reference design (which I work on) for 400G DWDM systems are ~100W for 2 transceivers + EDFA + switches, for a standar…

It's the bbc - accuracy is the very least of their concerns. They're much more focused on harassing pensioners for their state sponsored extortion racket money.

I'm not sure that's relevant to this discussion.

The government continues to reduce the amount of money they send to the BBC, which continues to produce world-class television and is struggling to find the money to do so.

They've decided that they will no longer offer the complimentary license to the elderly.

None of that should have any bearing on the accuracy of their environmental reporting.

Re: A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

#87
post #5

It’s honestly a shame that we didn’t keep pursuing sail technology. It’s great that we’re finally getting somewhere environmentally-friendly with ship tech nowadays as in the OP, but if we’d put the same amount of effort to innovate and advance sails like we did steam, I imagine we’d have pretty amazing (and completely green) methods of transport for all but the heaviest cargo loads (and even then, just split the loa…

> It’s honestly a shame that we didn’t keep pursuing sail technology ...

You mean something like this? https://www.top-yachtdesign.com/oceanwings-by-vplp/

Re: A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

#88
post #85
post #82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most seem to involve a wing or fin extending out from the hull in some way. That seems like it would introduce drag and greatly limit speed.

Oh this kind of thing? https://wavefoil.com/ I'm assuming they've tested it and it's not entirely fraudulen and does in fact give more speed than drag?

I'm not really sure the existence of a thing really indicates efficiency or usefulness, that's not a high bar.

Re: A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

#89
post #82
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What sort of wave foil do you mean? It's not clear from this article how the trimaran works, but you can see in the photos that there is a gap at the top of the outboard hulls. So I suspect it's the relative motion between the outboard hulls and the inboard one which is converted to hydraulic power - makes sense, it will be a short movement with a huge force behind it. That is then fed to a generator, electrical stor…

Most seem to involve a wing or fin extending out from the hull in some way. That seems like it would introduce drag and greatly limit speed.

Hydrofoils have a very high lift drag ratio. You also have to remember the wetted area of the hull produces significant drag too. Lifting most or all of the hull out out of the water can enable dramatically higher speeds, at the cost of stability and complexity. The biggest America's Cup catamarans were roughly the scale of a 7 story apartment building, but were capable of lifting their entire mass on a foil the size of an ironing board. Because of the density of water, foils can generate a lot of force as lift.

Re: A new design ship in the Philippines is partly powered by wave energy

#90
post #22

> The emissions from travel it took to report this story were 0kg CO2. The digital emissions from this story are an estimated 1.2g to 3.6g CO2 per page view. Maybe this is what finally could push companies towards making lighter and more efficient websites? At least an estimate of a webpages watt usage (server and client side).

I remember writing a paper in college about what the environmental impact of a web page was. One of the biggest energy savings Identified by far was changing the color of your website to use dark backgrounds.
Post reply on HN