Live data from Hacker News

Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

apnews.com

51–60 of 123 posts

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#51
post #47

Call this a freely given and viable but hard to monetize idea - this is a very tractable area for software and drones. Same with locating people in lost wilderness areas. You have a programmatic way to organize coverage areas, you have access to above-human audio and video capabilities, and it reduces the resources/time ratio that is critical in rescues. This was the tragic and avoidable story that convinced me this…

The "search" part of search and rescue is a solved problem. There's no reason to go into the wilderness without a PLB in 2020. PLBs cost around $300 [1], they have five+ year batteries, and they don't require a subscription. If you need to use it, you turn it on, it grabs a GPS lock and transmits your coordinates for about a day, during which at least one satellite will see your signal and downlinks all over the plan…

If you use a PLB to get rescued, do you then owe a big check to the rescuing organization like when you call for an ambulance in the USA?

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#52
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're not even expensive to buy. I picked one up for a few hundred dollars for hiking. I believe it's good for 10 years, until the battery needs replacing. I don't even do particularly intense hikes, usually not even overnight, but I read a few stories and realised how easy it is to end up in a situation where you need one. You just have to slip over and land badly, that's all it takes. Or maybe it won't be me, but…

A few hundred dollars seems fastastically expensive to me. What is possibly inside it that justifies that price?

Seriously, what the fuck is up with this attitude?

People will spend thousands of dollars on ultralight gear, and then balk at $300 for a magic button that summons a helicopter when you have a broken leg.

It's literally the cheapest life insurance you will ever be able to buy.

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#53
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A few hundred dollars seems fastastically expensive to me. What is possibly inside it that justifies that price?

It’s a satellite commS device. You also need a service for it to be useful. I do find it somewhat amusing to read a comment that a device that locates me anywhere on the planet and can communicate that information via satellite costs a few hundred dollars! to be vaguely amusing.

You absolutely do not need service to use a PLB. You pay $300 once and fill out a (free) form online with your extended/emergency contact info.

A satellite text messenger like SPOT is not a PLB.

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#54
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The "search" part of search and rescue is a solved problem. There's no reason to go into the wilderness without a PLB in 2020. PLBs cost around $300 [1], they have five+ year batteries, and they don't require a subscription. If you need to use it, you turn it on, it grabs a GPS lock and transmits your coordinates for about a day, during which at least one satellite will see your signal and downlinks all over the plan…

If you use a PLB to get rescued, do you then owe a big check to the rescuing organization like when you call for an ambulance in the USA?

Yes, especially if the service calls a helicopter.

The criticism against these is they've become so common that people either get overconfident and hike out beyond their abilities, or people call for help on minor issues like they didn't pack enough water or they get a headache.

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#55

Is it me, or does it rather instead look like they arranged tree branches + leaves to make the word, not dug in sand? And on another note, when you see things from an island scale, you can see that even at the size they drew those letters, it might've been missed. The world is big...

I imagine those tree branches are "in" the sand though...

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#56
post #32

Call this a freely given and viable but hard to monetize idea - this is a very tractable area for software and drones. Same with locating people in lost wilderness areas. You have a programmatic way to organize coverage areas, you have access to above-human audio and video capabilities, and it reduces the resources/time ratio that is critical in rescues. This was the tragic and avoidable story that convinced me this…

I'd like to see all phones and phone towers fitted with an emergency ping ability and an emergency ping protocol, since almost everyone carries a phone these days. If you needed help, you'd enter a text describing your situation (a default text would be used if you could only click a "HELP!" button), put the phone in a special mode that would shut everything down to conserve battery power but would send out a stronge…

I've heard of ski resorts using stringray-like devices to locate avalanche victims.

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#57
post #3

How often is the best earth-facing satellite imagery updated? It'd be really cool to sic handwriting recognition on it to continuously look for "SOS".

Planet are looking to offer multiple times per day. Although I think that requires the camera to be slewed and a site targeted rather than being able to cover the whole earth every single orbit.

Remember that cloud cover is really common in a lot of places. The UK in January averages less than 2 hours per day of sunlight. You need enough satellites to image everywhere several times per day to allow for that. And even then you may have overcast weather for several days at a time.

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#58
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The "search" part of search and rescue is a solved problem. There's no reason to go into the wilderness without a PLB in 2020. PLBs cost around $300 [1], they have five+ year batteries, and they don't require a subscription. If you need to use it, you turn it on, it grabs a GPS lock and transmits your coordinates for about a day, during which at least one satellite will see your signal and downlinks all over the plan…

If you use a PLB to get rescued, do you then owe a big check to the rescuing organization like when you call for an ambulance in the USA?

If the rescuing organization is going to ask you to pay for your helicopter flight, they're probably going to ask regardless of whether they got your location from a PLB ping or from "SOS" drawn in the sand.

If you don't use a PLB, you better hope they don't try to charge you for the search flights as well, which don't need to happen if you use a PLB.

But yeah, as the sibling comment mentioned, you'd better be serious if you decide to press the button. You're not summoning a taxi.

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#59
Interestingly the international ground air code for requiring help is normally an X or a V.

But I would still write SOS or HELP.

You can imagine the scenario: “Hey Jane check out that - looks like a V in the sand” “Heh yeah”. “Weird”.

or

“Hey Jane does that say HELP?” “Heh yeah. Wanna check it out?” “Yeah let’s take a look”.

Re: Men rescued from Pacific island after writing SOS in sand

#60
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, there are just personal locator beacons which you can rent and tell rescue personnel exactly where you are if you need a rescue.

This is the right answer. A Garmin InReach or similar device with two-way messaging capabilities should be regarded as standard equipment now for anyone going into backcountry or remote areas. The two-way messaging allows local rescue teams to assess your condition, confirm your location, and deploy the appropriate resources more quickly.

Yep. I planned to hike the Appalachian Trail this year (canceled due to covid), and the Garmin InReach was universally recommended equipment.
Post reply on HN