Live data from Hacker News

What is 5D chess?

en.chessbase.com

11–20 of 108 posts

Re: What is 5D chess?

#11

How do you know if you have won? Or is it about avoiding checkmate in all possible timelines for all possible time travelling moves?

I'd think the same way you know you won regular chess. You capture the opponent's king. Checkmate is just an acknowledgement that the current player has no way of avoiding their opponent from taking their king on the next move.

Re: What is 5D chess?

#12
We skipped right over the opportunity for non-integer fractal dimensional chess! In all seriousness, this looks super interesting. I’d love to see some live gameplay of it.

Re: What is 5D chess?

#13

3d chess is another popular variant: https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-dimensional_chess Lot of games you could spin up in this manner. I wonder if we are going to do that for all the board games with tried and old strategies. HN has any suggestions on what those board games should be? Game on steam: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1349230/5D_Chess_With_Mul... There is a discord linked in the game help menu where p…

Some people are currently playing it on Twitch https://www.twitch.tv/directory/game/5D%20Chess%20With%20Mul...

Re: What is 5D chess?

#14
It looks amazing, and I really want to play it, but however I count I only end up with 4 dimensions. A chess board is 2D, time back-and-forth is 3D, and going up/down across universes is 4D. What's the 5th? Are they counting real-life-time as the 5th? In which case normal chess is 3D, which seems like an abuse of terms.

Re: What is 5D chess?

#15

It looks amazing, and I really want to play it, but however I count I only end up with 4 dimensions. A chess board is 2D, time back-and-forth is 3D, and going up/down across universes is 4D. What's the 5th? Are they counting real-life-time as the 5th? In which case normal chess is 3D, which seems like an abuse of terms.

It's only 4D. I believe they called it 5D chess because they didn't want people to interpret this as 3D chess + time. If I recall correctly, the tutorial mentions at some point that the 5th dimension is "unused".

Re: What is 5D chess?

#16
I bought this game a few weeks ago with a friend and we jumped in without any prior knowledge about the game or how it worked. After about 3 hours we were finally starting to understand the basic principles and I have to say wow, it's an absolute blast to play. Many hours in now we've finally begun developing our own strategies and it's absolutely insane. I have to say that 5D Chess is one of the most creative and innovative games that I've played in recent memory and I highly recommend it.

Re: What is 5D chess?

#17
post #11

How do you know if you have won? Or is it about avoiding checkmate in all possible timelines for all possible time travelling moves?

I'd think the same way you know you won regular chess. You capture the opponent's king. Checkmate is just an acknowledgement that the current player has no way of avoiding their opponent from taking their king on the next move.

So checkmate in any one timeline counts? You couldn’t do all timelines.

Re: What is 5D chess?

#18
post #15

It looks amazing, and I really want to play it, but however I count I only end up with 4 dimensions. A chess board is 2D, time back-and-forth is 3D, and going up/down across universes is 4D. What's the 5th? Are they counting real-life-time as the 5th? In which case normal chess is 3D, which seems like an abuse of terms.

It's only 4D. I believe they called it 5D chess because they didn't want people to interpret this as 3D chess + time. If I recall correctly, the tutorial mentions at some point that the 5th dimension is "unused".

The 5th dimension is just so tightly curled up that, after discretization, just looks like it's not present.

Re: What is 5D chess?

#19

How do you know if you have won? Or is it about avoiding checkmate in all possible timelines for all possible time travelling moves?

When there are multiple parallel time-lines, you have to input a move for each one before you can advance to the next turn. But to win, you have to mate just one of the opponent's kings. One player can have multiple kings on one board, because they can move through time and between time-lines.

I have no idea what high-level play will end up looking like, but the streamer from whom I learned the above [0] said that the most common way to win is to mate a king on a board in the past. Those already have their options of escaping an attack restricted by ordinary chess rules; it gets worse when you can make additional threats from the future.

[0] https://youtu.be/LOotGsWbaeA

Re: What is 5D chess?

#20

3d chess is another popular variant: https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-dimensional_chess Lot of games you could spin up in this manner. I wonder if we are going to do that for all the board games with tried and old strategies. HN has any suggestions on what those board games should be? Game on steam: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1349230/5D_Chess_With_Mul... There is a discord linked in the game help menu where p…

Non-mobile URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-dimensional_chess
Post reply on HN