Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Sidekick (YC S20) – A hardware device to connect remote teams

news.ycombinator.com

81–90 of 234 posts

Re: Launch HN: Sidekick (YC S20) – A hardware device to connect remote teams

#81

As the founder of a remote company this defeats the purpose for me. Benefits of remote: - No commute - No office politics - No forced schedule - Less meetings - More writing - Forced communication - No "assess in seats" culture In part, this seems to defeat at least: - No forced schedule - Less meetings - No "asses in seats" culture My hunch is that your market research consisted of only talking to companies that are…

I'd consider using a product like this and I don't give a shit about draconian politics. The issue is that remote work has downsides. One downside is dramatically less collaboration. I like collaborating with team-mates, not just drudging away by myself. If this could help create more of a spontaneous back and forth in-person feel, that could be valuable. I don't know how it would feel, I'd have to try it and see. Bu…

> One downside is dramatically less collaboration.

This is simply an excuse for why remote doesn't work. It's a dead horse. If you find yourself collaborating less as a result of remote work, then I question your remote setup and culture.

> If this could help create more of a spontaneous back and forth in-person feel.

I actually feel less shitty by spontaneously reaching out to my colleagues via Slack or by phone when remote than I do tapping on their shoulder in an office.

> But I think you and the other people in this thread are being way too negative and defensive.

I wouldn't say my comment was that negative. This device is a threat to the upside of remote working, so it should be met with criticism. That doesn't mean I wish them any ill will. My biggest issue with something like this is that a device is now required for remote work and you must sit at your computer from 9am to 5pm. That's why a lot of people hate working from an office, so to recreate that at home would be a nightmare.

Re: Launch HN: Sidekick (YC S20) – A hardware device to connect remote teams

#82
post #3

> Sidekick is a new hardware device […] So your "new hardware device" is a Samsung Galaxy Tab A 10.1 (2019) with a stand, isn't it? What's your motivation to offer hardware instead of selling the Android app separately as well, so customers could use it without the hassle of getting hardware shipped?

A guess? Hardware startups mean money to investors. ;)

Do they though? I thought investors heavily favor software because of infinite scaling.

Re: Launch HN: Sidekick (YC S20) – A hardware device to connect remote teams

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd consider using a product like this and I don't give a shit about draconian politics. The issue is that remote work has downsides. One downside is dramatically less collaboration. I like collaborating with team-mates, not just drudging away by myself. If this could help create more of a spontaneous back and forth in-person feel, that could be valuable. I don't know how it would feel, I'd have to try it and see. Bu…

I keep hearing this but it makes no sense to me. If people need to collaborate, what exactly is stopping them from doing it over video? On my team we collaborate all the time remotely.

From our experience, the best collaboration doesn't happen during planned meetings. It happens during spontaneous conversations and that's what we're trying to bring back.

Re: Launch HN: Sidekick (YC S20) – A hardware device to connect remote teams

#84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd consider using a product like this and I don't give a shit about draconian politics. The issue is that remote work has downsides. One downside is dramatically less collaboration. I like collaborating with team-mates, not just drudging away by myself. If this could help create more of a spontaneous back and forth in-person feel, that could be valuable. I don't know how it would feel, I'd have to try it and see. Bu…

> One downside is dramatically less collaboration. This is simply an excuse for why remote doesn't work. It's a dead horse. If you find yourself collaborating less as a result of remote work, then I question your remote setup and culture. > If this could help create more of a spontaneous back and forth in-person feel. I actually feel less shitty by spontaneously reaching out to my colleagues via Slack or by phone whe…

Thanks for the feedback, we're still really early so this datapoint is really helpful.

Sidekick works really well for teams that need to be always communicating real-time. This isn't all remote teams, but the subset that needs this is underserved and we're trying to help with Sidekick.

Re: Launch HN: Sidekick (YC S20) – A hardware device to connect remote teams

#86

The way I see it, being "always on" is one of the worst things about office work. Always on is a constant distraction from doing good concentrated work. I think off by default is a far better paradigm for remote communication tools.

Thanks for the feedback! Agree that for a portion of the remote work force, asynchronous communication is probably effective.

Teams that love Sidekick need to be always talking as if they're in the same room. To these teams, it's not a distraction but critical for getting their job done.

Re: Launch HN: Sidekick (YC S20) – A hardware device to connect remote teams

#87
post #30

Did you do a trademark search yet? T-Mobile US had a Sidekick device not long ago and may not have abandoned their registration.

Thanks for the heads-up. We'll take a look.

In particular, T-Mobile's last "Sidekick" device was an Android phone. You should probably start looking for a new name now.

Re: Launch HN: Sidekick (YC S20) – A hardware device to connect remote teams

#88
There are multiple services available that do this, without hardware, and with more privacy features (like being able to fuzz your camera such that people know you're there but can't actually see you picking your nose or whatever).

they don't steal desk space. they let you use the same screen for other things. they're cheaper.

BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY

I've tried them with my team at a past co and people were FREAKED THE EFF OUT by the idea. They DO NOT WANT. It doesn't matter that it's logically the same thing as being in an open office. they DO NOT WANT a camera pointing at them, even knowing that it's not recording.

some people are ok with this, most aren't.

this appeals to "leaders" who don't trust that their people are working if they can't see them at their desk.

DO NOT USE THIS. Society is _NOT_ ready for cameras pointed at them while they work and folks feel it's a SERIOUS invasion of privacy.

Re: Launch HN: Sidekick (YC S20) – A hardware device to connect remote teams

#89

As the founder of a remote company this defeats the purpose for me. Benefits of remote: - No commute - No office politics - No forced schedule - Less meetings - More writing - Forced communication - No "assess in seats" culture In part, this seems to defeat at least: - No forced schedule - Less meetings - No "asses in seats" culture My hunch is that your market research consisted of only talking to companies that are…

If it defeats the purpose for you, sounds like this product isn't relevant to you? My guess is something as nuanced as a workplace (of which, there are MANY types, and you're right, a lot are just moving to remote work per COVID) will require different setups for different sets of people.

I won't dispute your jab at the traditional workplace culture/politics, but I certainly wouldn't assume your personal preferences (and perhaps, the common preference of HNers) is the golden standard.

Many people work better with others "around" and enjoy the company/atmosphere, myself included. Sounds like this product addresses that exact market.

Re: Launch HN: Sidekick (YC S20) – A hardware device to connect remote teams

#90

The way I see it, being "always on" is one of the worst things about office work. Always on is a constant distraction from doing good concentrated work. I think off by default is a far better paradigm for remote communication tools.

Thanks for the feedback! Agree that for a portion of the remote work force, asynchronous communication is probably effective. Teams that love Sidekick need to be always talking as if they're in the same room. To these teams, it's not a distraction but critical for getting their job done.

Best of luck to you guys! I understand the different point of view.
Post reply on HN