Live data from Hacker News

Y Combinator has lost its soul: A YC founder's perspective

twitter.com

31–40 of 436 posts

Re: Y Combinator has lost its soul: A YC founder's perspective

#31
post #12

Check sizes are 125k now; you won't be able to hire a rockstar dev but you have something to hang onto for a year if you budget wisely: https://www.ycombinator.com/deal/

You can absolutely hire a rockstar dev, you need to think in terms of cashflow. You may not be able to pay a full year of salary, but you can still pay their full weekly salary as you go until you either run out of money or produce enough revenue to get to that point.

Re: Y Combinator has lost its soul: A YC founder's perspective

#32
post #6

He lost me with the whole "make founders take on massive personal debt to survive" tweet. Removing that particular stressor, particularly from people from poorer backgrounds who lack the access to that kind of credit is how we get a better sampling of ideas.

I’d suggest the opposite. One who is used to living off $1k a month for 1-2 years have an upper hand on founders used to a more cushy lifestyle. Or even having no income and almost broke for years like many successful founders I know of.

Re: Y Combinator has lost its soul: A YC founder's perspective

#33
post #6

He lost me with the whole "make founders take on massive personal debt to survive" tweet. Removing that particular stressor, particularly from people from poorer backgrounds who lack the access to that kind of credit is how we get a better sampling of ideas.

Yeah, he calls it a "filtering function"... yes, to filter out people without safety nets.

Not a filtering function - I know of a few founders who scrapped by on Medicaid and food stamps for years to build a successful business by they had no savings

Re: Y Combinator has lost its soul: A YC founder's perspective

#34
He says "the check sizes are too big" as if they're giving prelaunch startups $50M or something. The $125k that YC gives startups is nowhere near big enough to remove the drive/urgency to succeed.

If startups are coming into YC with a more mature product than in the early years (and it seems that way), then adjusting the focus towards fundraising actually makes sense.

Not to repeat what's been said in other comments, but to say that founders should be willing to put themselves in deep financial risk to prove their drive...that just comes from an incredibly privileged mindset.

It reminds me of the people saying that if their school is going online-only, students should instead take gap years to build something, incorrectly assuming that no one needs that student loan money for living expenses.

Re: Y Combinator has lost its soul: A YC founder's perspective

#36
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, he calls it a "filtering function"... yes, to filter out people without safety nets.

Not a filtering function - I know of a few founders who scrapped by on Medicaid and food stamps for years to build a successful business by they had no savings

But why put founders through that added stressor if YC easily has the resources to prevent it?

Re: Y Combinator has lost its soul: A YC founder's perspective

#37
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The solution may be wrong, but the idea is right. If people can just casually come into YC with no particular consequences for failure, that greatly reduced drive to succeed. "I'll just go back to FAMGAN after" or "I'll be able to transition from MBA grad + YC to something high paying" I don't think is great for success drive.

you can be motivated without going hungry. not being able to afford basic things is extremely stressful and takes time away from doing whatever YC wants them to do - that time is spent making sure that food is on the table. exactly the opposite of what you intend.

Precisely! Which is why I think the intent is good, keep people driven, but the method, not giving people the basics to live, is not good.

Re: Y Combinator has lost its soul: A YC founder's perspective

#38
post #26
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah I noped out of this as soon as I saw it. The guy is suggesting investing in startup founders but not giving them enough to live while they get that company off the ground. What is the point of that? Completely self-defeating.

It is not YC’s job to support the company. That is the founders job. I’d suggest money supporting the company at seed diverts from a focus on monetary fit asap. $25k is enough to scrap by for enough months which should be the initial goal

The problem is there are many brilliant people that can't just scrap by - with a mortgage and family. But I respect the VC's right to choose the kind of people they sponsor.

Re: Y Combinator has lost its soul: A YC founder's perspective

#39
post #6

He lost me with the whole "make founders take on massive personal debt to survive" tweet. Removing that particular stressor, particularly from people from poorer backgrounds who lack the access to that kind of credit is how we get a better sampling of ideas.

Yeah, fully agree. Founding a company is stressful enough. The idea that adding existential threat is helping is ridiculous to me.

Re: Y Combinator has lost its soul: A YC founder's perspective

#40
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not a filtering function - I know of a few founders who scrapped by on Medicaid and food stamps for years to build a successful business by they had no savings

But why put founders through that added stressor if YC easily has the resources to prevent it?

They don’t know at onset if a company deserves that much money. $25k is enough to see what people can accomplish in 3 months - maybe they take less equity. Most companies either have wrong leaders, wrong market, wrong skills, wrong business ideas but big dreams. That amount is enough to filter through the above.
Post reply on HN