Live data from Hacker News

Tired of note-taking apps

akkshaya.blog

341–350 of 481 posts

Re: Tired of note-taking apps

#341

Personally I find Apple Notes the most convenient for quick jotting down of ideas etc. It’s not the most advanced in terms of features but it loads instantly, is quick to use and is available on all of my devices. Have tried numerous alternatives but they’ve never stuck e.g. they’re slow to start up or are fussy to use or don’t work well on one platform. For deeper sketching out of ideas, diagrams etc I really like C…

I agree with this and notes is what I use - apple notes with cloud sync, especially on the phone. Every now and then, I move it all out of notes into standalone text files in a directory tree in Dropbox.

Why?

Because several times now I've lost notes due to Apple's cloud "sync." On a few occasions, the note turned up in the trash (with no action on my part) or simply disappeared.

Putting aside the spontaneous deletes, one thing that seems to more frequently push things into the trash is editing the same note on more than once device - the handling of this on the icloud backend appears to be "hell, just delete it."

edit: I should note that this spontaneous delete thing was more common a year ago, but then again, I've dramatically reduced the number of notes I maintain, now down to like 30 or so as opposed to the hundred+ I used to keep.

Re: Tired of note-taking apps

#342
I don't have a solution for mobile (not a big deal for me), but at least on desktop I just use a git repository of markdown files with Sublime Text.

My main complaint is that markdown hyperlinks are just extremely ugly to look at in text form, so I wish there was a nice editor or extension that supports hyperlinks. I've stuck with Sublime Text for the note-taking simply because it loads so fast and the keyboard shortcuts are great, but open to alternative editors (ideally open source). Or maybe there's a good Markdown extension for Sublime that I'm not aware of.

Re: Tired of note-taking apps

#343
I use QOwnNote with NextCloud. It has a lot of features and is very enjoyable to use. It doesn't lock you down with a specific format. It just adds an additional database for tags. You have the raw files with txt or markdown format organized perfectly in your folders. And with the ability to host the sync server by yourself, you don't need to give the sensitive information to third-party organization.

Re: Tired of note-taking apps

#344

I don't have a solution for mobile (not a big deal for me), but at least on desktop I just use a git repository of markdown files with Sublime Text. My main complaint is that markdown hyperlinks are just extremely ugly to look at in text form, so I wish there was a nice editor or extension that supports hyperlinks. I've stuck with Sublime Text for the note-taking simply because it loads so fast and the keyboard short…

Check out Bear. You can write notes in Markdown format but with some QoL features from traditional note taking apps, including a nicer hyperlink experience

Re: Tired of note-taking apps

#345
Creating a note-taking app and/or a Todo list are effectively rites of passage. There's something aspirational both in the creation of the app and the creation of a more orderly daily existence.

Looked at this way, I think we can explain both the proliferation for, and the dissatisfaction with note taking apps.

Re: Tired of note-taking apps

#346
My note taking app or choice is Squid/Papyrus. Works best with a stylus.

It is essentially virtual paper, it replaces a notebook, no more, no less.

But the thing it has that I've seen nowhere else is that it is vector based, with an unlimited size canevas and high zoom (10%-1000%).

It sounds so obvious as a feature. I mean, if you have a stylus, besides drawing, taking notes is the most obvious thing you can do with it. And what can a screen do and paper cannot? Scrolling and zooming. And because smartphones are powerful computers and we have good algorithms, there is no reason to limit canevas size artificially.

So I went in and looked at the most popular note taking apps, thinking: these are made by many-million dollar companies they must have that. And no. All I found was cloud-synchronized text files. None took advantage of the drawing capabilities of smartphones, or they did it in a half-assed way. The S-Note app (I have a Galaxy Note 4) is nice, but it is bitmap and with a limited canevas size, why? Can't Samsung do better?

Only one app did it right and that's Squid (previously Papyrus). And it is a little known one compared to the likes of Evernote. It isn't even mentioned in the article even though it is the closest thing to the "writing things down" solution it recommends, so I suspect the author doesn't know its existence. Otherwise I think he would have mentioned it, even if it is just to talk about how it doesn't fit his needs.

Re: Tired of note-taking apps

#347
post #312
post #128

Funnily enough, I don’t think there is a really good one. There’s lots that almost do it but not quite. - Evernote: no note linking - Bear: lovely but no web or android version - OneNote: appalling in the way only MS can be - SimpleNotes: too simple - Zoho: too ...urgh - Keep: too Googley - Apple notes: too Appley - Standard Notes: too buggy I’m clearly a fussy sod. But really, just a nice, oss, local files, ability…

Would you mind elaborating on why Standard Notes is too buggy? Only thing that comes to mind is the use of React Native and Electron (suboptimal performance / UX) but I've never had any issues myself. I'd like to hear of alternatives that apply the same e2e encryption model.

I also am on Standard Notes and haven't noticed it being buggy. But I'm presently a free user and never switch editors.

It was after buggy experiences on Simplenote that I had to jump ship. I don't know if I just had too many notes, or what, but it became slow, updated in weird ways that lost things or copied the same line multiple times, jumped to the top when I tried to scroll down, etc. Just all manner of strange behaviors.

Re: Tired of note-taking apps

#348
The title of this blog post strikes a chord although whilst I love writing with a fountain pen, transcribing my notes to computer later is a royal pain.

It's also irritating to have bunches of notes in Apple's Notes app, in Confluence, in Notion, in Google Docs and goodness knows where else.

The movement to cloud has driven a coach and horses through the whole reasoning behind the EU/US push to get Microsoft to be more open and not hold institutions to ransom with data locked within a proprietary vendor's platform:

https://www.infoworld.com/article/2618153/how-microsoft-was-...

Now we've gone full tilt towards a world of proprietary clouds where we don't even have custody of our own data and instead entrust it to a MongoDB cluster somewhere managed by the latest hot, new note taking startup.

Where are the regulators when you need them to ensure we can get our data in and out of these platforms?

As for me, I find vim or Sublime and Markdown synced via Dropbox work tolerably well. I keep toying with the idea of writing an open source Markdown syncing solution with open source clients for note taking...

That aside the proprietary nature of the cloud and especially how it pertains to note taking (and todo apps) is a real step backwards. The regulators who forced Microsoft to submit in the past would be gnashing their teeth at the situation we have today.

Re: Tired of note-taking apps

#350
I settled on Rednotebook on Linux on my work laptop.

It has almost no features beyond a daily page and a term cloud (basically, an index of terms where the most frequent terms have bigger fonts).

I use some informal markdown syntax, in the sense that i mostly recognize visually.

Post reply on HN