Live data from Hacker News

Google to Invest $10B in India

techcrunch.com

281–290 of 349 posts

Re: Google to Invest $10B in India

#281
post #280

Between Apple and Google heavily investing in Indian facilities , I wonder if this is going to actually lead to physically outsourcing our jobs for real

What is different about this situation than previous situations? The history of claiming high tech software engineering will soon outsource itself to India is long.

Re: Google to Invest $10B in India

#282
Between Apple and Google investing heavily in facilities in India, I wonder if this is the writing on the wall that is the start of building up outsourced H1-b teams in economical state-of-the-art headquarters while they transition down their real estate footprint in the Bay Area in the wake of the 'new normal' way of remote working due to Covid-19.

Any predictions for the next 10 years if this will be a threat to on-shore devs considering the braindrain occurring at the direction of our president's myopic leadership and executive orders?

Re: Google to Invest $10B in India

#283
post #3

There's been a recent surge in American companies investing in India primarily through Reliance Jio (owned by Mukhesh Ambani who's got a good connect with the current ruling Government). It's been spiking since the Anti-China sentiment led Buy and Use 'Made in India' cries. Government has even asked eCom Flipkart and Amazon to display Country of Origin for each product. With all these, This investment from Google see…

On the topic of country of origin, they list the country of origin on all produce I've purchased here in the UK. It blows my mind that it is profitable to ship grapes to the UK from South Africa.

Re: Google to Invest $10B in India

#284
post #281
post #280

Between Apple and Google heavily investing in Indian facilities , I wonder if this is going to actually lead to physically outsourcing our jobs for real

What is different about this situation than previous situations? The history of claiming high tech software engineering will soon outsource itself to India is long.

The opportunity to be first to market to establish custom hardware fabs and house H1-b talent in new headquarters blocked by current political leadership from immigrating here from India and opportunity to wrestle away control from Shenzhen and China and establish and control their own supply chain.

Re: Google to Invest $10B in India

#285
post #282

Between Apple and Google investing heavily in facilities in India, I wonder if this is the writing on the wall that is the start of building up outsourced H1-b teams in economical state-of-the-art headquarters while they transition down their real estate footprint in the Bay Area in the wake of the 'new normal' way of remote working due to Covid-19. Any predictions for the next 10 years if this will be a threat to on…

I don't understand. If they decide to hire more in India they won't need H-1Bs any more.

Also, presidential cycles are short. A four-year presidency is simply not long enough to cause massive brain drain to be a threat for anything. But if the next administration continues to be myopic, I can see that trickle of brain drain turn into a torrent.

Re: Google to Invest $10B in India

#286

Getting the feeling China has blown it and successful companies looking to expand into Asia are now looking at India instead. I also saw that Foxconn is looking to build Apple products in India now too.

I don't think China has really "blown" it in the sense that they wanted foreign expansion and investment but failed. The Chinese had always wanted a homegrown tech industry, and they are pretty successfully at that.

Re: Google to Invest $10B in India

#287

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Publicly traded companies can't afford to play favorites, they "have to" go where the profits are and make the best of it, whether it's decades of being the mole in a wack-a-mole game with the Chinese system, or having to invest extra billions in India. True to some extent only. Apart from profits, publicly traded companies also clamour for a stable business environment. And authoritarian countries have an inherent…

> No one can make 50 year plans for China, like they can do with US Five years ago, I would have agreed with you about the US. But the direction that politics have gone since then makes me a lot less sure. The rate that corruption has grown under the Trump without repercussions is absolutely astonishing. Like any relationship, I don't know how that break in trust between the government and its citizens can be repaire…

Give me a break. Very little has effectively changed in the past five years, aside from the insane polarization of the media.

The Trump administration's "astonishing rate of corruption" you are perceiving is being massively overstated by partisan media outlets.

Previous administrations were free to engage in all manners of corruption, while the mainstream media touted their "coolness".

Re: Google to Invest $10B in India

#288
post #244

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure why you're being downvoted. I feel the same way about h1b visas. I wish instead of importing cheap labor we spent extra money and trained people in the African American community that don't have as many opportunities.

- How much did america gain from colonial behavior done in India. Remember capital flows, India --> Colonial UK --> 13 Colonies -> Infrastructure Not saying your wrong, but your point just comes to "who got screwed over more" it's not productive to have that debate, because you might ask well Fly Down To the Worst Third World Countries who were hurt most by America, or prior colonialist

> Remember capital flows, India --> Colonial UK --> 13 Colonies -> Infrastructure

Given that the Battle of Plassey, establishing the first UK colony in India, happened in 1757, this flow of funds from the British Raj to the 13 colonies seems unlikely.

Re: Google to Invest $10B in India

#289
post #209
post #199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Mukhesh Ambani who's got a good connect with the current ruling Government To be fair, Mukesh has got good connections everywhere. He is India's most powerful person. Amitabh and the Shahrukh (some of the world's richest actors, both half billionaires) both volunteered as servers at his daughters wedding as a show of appreciation. If a man can command the most powerful of his country to such level of willful subser…

> volunteered as servers at his daughters wedding ... subservience I don't know about you, but when I hear "working as a server at a wedding attended by many powerful people", I don't think "subservience", I think "unique opportunity to make connections, and to potentially snoop insider information."

I am not sure you comprehend the fame and reach of the actors mentioned. They don’t need connections, they are super famous in their own right.

Also note, Amitabh is in his late seventies. I doubt he is interested in connections at his age.

Re: Google to Invest $10B in India

#290
post #194
post #174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And I suppose you voluntarily pay more tax than you need to?

"He" is not a for-profit corporation, but a human person. Corporations aren't people no matter how much dollars go into PR efforts to tell people otherwise. As such, them not paying their part to the society is damaging no matter how many personal appeals you do. Please stop humanizing corporations to make them get away with not paying their part.

> Corporations aren't people no matter how much dollars go into PR efforts to tell people otherwise.

It's not PR efforts, it's literally the law.

Post reply on HN