Live data from Hacker News

California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system

latimes.com

11–20 of 63 posts

Re: California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system

#11

As a Hindu I'd like to take the opportunity to share that the implementation of the caste system is not based on what it really means to be Hindu. The Vedas state that one's caste is fluid (not based on lineage) and can change in one's lifetime, and that further a person of the worker class is not lesser than someone of the priest caste, they both perform dharma necessary for the community.

are you defending the caste system?

Re: California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system

#12
This guy is a Principal Engineer at Cisco. This is nearly as high as you can go on the engineering track. The fact that he's complaining about being discriminated against while some how making it to the 95th percentile paygrade is a bit revealing.

Not saying it's impossible, but I dont buy it.

Re: California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system

#13
post #6

This will be an interesting case because it will need to test how a construct like caste maps on to the protected classes of US anti discrimination law. There's plenty of overlap between caste and many US protected classes, including race, class, and religion, but there is not a tight fit to any of them. Perhaps countries like the UK have more experience with this, because they have proportionally much larger and old…

It's the equivalent of hiring white supremacists and letting them make employment decisions.

Re: California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system

#14
post #10

shocking but still confused. When they practiced the indian caste system in the US, how would they interact with people not from india, e.g. people with US, EU, Vietnam, Korea etc background? Do they get treated as "high caste" or "low caste" people?

Caste is highly correlated to skin pigmentation, so in practice... this would be almost indistinguishable from regular old racism.

Re: California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system

#15
post #11

As a Hindu I'd like to take the opportunity to share that the implementation of the caste system is not based on what it really means to be Hindu. The Vedas state that one's caste is fluid (not based on lineage) and can change in one's lifetime, and that further a person of the worker class is not lesser than someone of the priest caste, they both perform dharma necessary for the community.

are you defending the caste system?

It sounds like he's defending _a_ caste system, but probably not the one you're thinking of.

Re: California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system

#17
post #11

As a Hindu I'd like to take the opportunity to share that the implementation of the caste system is not based on what it really means to be Hindu. The Vedas state that one's caste is fluid (not based on lineage) and can change in one's lifetime, and that further a person of the worker class is not lesser than someone of the priest caste, they both perform dharma necessary for the community.

are you defending the caste system?

caste system would have no problems. Caste discrimination is the problem. Every religion and Entire world has caste system in one form or the other. otherwise there would be no fights.

Re: California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system

#18
post #13
post #6

This will be an interesting case because it will need to test how a construct like caste maps on to the protected classes of US anti discrimination law. There's plenty of overlap between caste and many US protected classes, including race, class, and religion, but there is not a tight fit to any of them. Perhaps countries like the UK have more experience with this, because they have proportionally much larger and old…

It's the equivalent of hiring white supremacists and letting them make employment decisions.

[deleted]

Re: California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system

#19
Constant double standards from Comifornia

This is the same place that uses state force to force business's to hire X wamans or non whites as management/ceo roles instead of hiring on MERIT and letting companys choose who they staff

Re: California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system

#20

As a Hindu I'd like to take the opportunity to share that the implementation of the caste system is not based on what it really means to be Hindu. The Vedas state that one's caste is fluid (not based on lineage) and can change in one's lifetime, and that further a person of the worker class is not lesser than someone of the priest caste, they both perform dharma necessary for the community.

I'm also Hindu. It's quite obvious that caste and lineage are immanent within much of our cultural patrimony. I don't mean to get into an ideological debate but there is no point to this pretense.
Post reply on HN