Live data from Hacker News

Curry Before Columbus

contingentmagazine.org

1–10 of 71 posts

Re: Curry Before Columbus

#4

Curry is curry due to it containing tumeric, and tumeric is native to India. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turmeric

Ginger and turmeric look very similar. It seems that ginger came from south-east Asia. https://www.motherearthliving.com/natural-health/know-your-s...

Interesting that it was not mentioned in the older recipes in the article.

Re: Curry Before Columbus

#5

Curry is curry due to it containing tumeric, and tumeric is native to India. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turmeric

You may as well say curry is curry because it has cumin in it, and cumin is native to India. Curry is really just a word made up by non-Indians to describe spicy gravy, or depending on who you ask, it can be used to describe any sufficiently spiced food. If you google curry potatoes, you’ll find plenty of recipes. If you google jeera aloo (which literally just translates to cumin potato) you’ll find plenty of very similar recipes. You can also find plenty of recipes for Thai, Indonesian, Malaysian... curries, and the only thing they have in common with Indian curries is use of spice and a gravy textured sauce, but using completely different spice bases and cooking techniques.

Re: Curry Before Columbus

#7
I've spent about 3 years in India, through a combination of work and family, and rarely see anything called "curry" on menus. Part of what this author seems to be getting at is that "curry" reflects a colonial viewpoint that homogenizes groups outsite the west. Thus, Indians, Thais and Japanese food has "curries" (even though these curries are very different from one another). In contrast Hungarians have "Goulash."

Re: Curry Before Columbus

#9
... curry leaf gets a mention. So let's talk about curry leaf in the context of curry not being a 'thing' ... I have a curry leaf plant and we use it in our dal, and in rogan josh (a curry but also not a curry) and spinach and potato diahes
Post reply on HN